The Corner

Court-Packers Say Court-Packing Is Not Court-Packing

Share this story

The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C.

Melpomenem/Getty Images

A good sign that your argument is neither good nor popular is when you have to keep changing the long-accepted meaning of words. So it is with a Bloomberg Law op-ed by law professors Tonja Jacobi and Matthew Sag titled “The Supreme Court Needs 15 Justices.” The op-ed’s subhed leads off: “Changing the law to allow 15 U.S. Supreme Court justices would not be court packing. It would allow the court to take many more cases and address some of the urgent issues that it currently neglects.” Bloomberg uses the same line in promoting the op-ed on Twitter:

To be fair to Jacobi and Sag, the text of the op-ed does not actually say this, so it is possible that the effort at redefining the words is the work of a Bloomberg Law editor, but it is a terrible argument. The whole reason why we use the term “Court-packing” to refer to expanding the Supreme Court for purposes of tipping its ideological balance is that we have an extremely notorious historical example of exactly that being proposed: Franklin D. Roosevelt’s 1937 plan. It was, for a while, the hottest issue in American politics; it was resoundingly rejected by the public, the media, and FDR’s own party; and it has since stood for decades in the history books as the very paradigm of presidential overreaching being too much even for his own party. Until very recently, there was not the slightest question that this is what “Court-packing” meant, and dictionaries and history books considered that a settled question. The only possible purposes of redefining the term are for proponents of Court-packing to try to escape the bad odor that historically has hung around FDR’s plan, or for opponents of other things to try to shoehorn them into being Court-packing so as to absorb that bad odor. The Bloomberg Law piece even features a YouTube video that helpfully explains what Court-packing is, and guess what? Even in the video, it’s FDR’s plan.

Dan McLaughlin

About the Author

Dan McLaughlin

Dan McLaughlin is a senior writer at National Review Online and a fellow at National Review Institute.

Comments

On “Court-Packers Say Court-Packing Is Not Court-Packing”

Advertisement

Advertisement