Brother Hugh’s observation about the Supremes as a priestly sect does resonate with me a bit. I tried reconciling that to the fact that I’d much rather have a Bork than a Miers on the bench, and the best I can come up with right now is the difference between “should be” and “is”.
The “should be” part of me would be happy with an ordinary men of ordinary intelligence who simply had the guts and honesty to look at each case and ask what the Constitution has to say about that and, if the Constitution is silent, to send it back to the legislatures to get hammered out. I can’t argue that knowing 18th century history is a plus, but I also don’t hold that the Constitution was meant to be a brain buster. A little honest reading of English quickly demystifies most questions, and learning a little about the language as spoken by the Founders only makes it clearer.
The “is” part has to recognize that the Supreme Court has overstepped its bounds so far and so long that it is, in effect, a ruling priesthood.
So, as a practical matter, I have to agree with you. But in principle I don’t think it should take a High Priest to correctly execute the office.
Enough rambling. What I’m *really* miffed about is that Hugh is in Florence and I’m not. I love that place.
Recommended

Biden Signs Executive Order Allowing the U.S. to Fund Global Abortions
The policy was first instated by President Reagan to ensure that taxpayers would not be required to indirectly fund abortions in other countries.

Exclusive: 48 Senators Promise to Oppose Any Bill that Funds Abortion
Pro-life lawmakers pledge to resist spending bills that don’t include the Hyde amendment.

The Absurd Criticism of Rand Paul’s Rachel Levine Questioning
How likely is it that this dangerous ideological agenda is about to get worse?

Cruz: Actually, It Is Constitutional to Impeach and Convict a Former President
Never mind how he voted.

What Happened to Officer Sicknick?
Democratic impeachment managers have a duty to explain how Officer Sicknick died.

Minnesota Nasty
Minneapolis is a nice city no longer.
The Latest

Ted Cruz Responds to Reports John Boehner Told Him to ‘Go F--- Yourself’
‘He suggested that I do something that was anatomically impossible,’ the Texas senator said.

AOC Calls for Investigation into ‘Extraordinarily Serious’ Cuomo Sexual-Harassment Allegations
Lindsey Boylan, a former staffer for the N.Y. governor, recently published an essay detailing the alleged harassment, including unwanted touching and kissing.

Biden: Illegal Immigrants Should Be Able to Get Vaccine without Fear of ICE
The Department of Homeland Security announced earlier this month that ICE would not conduct enforcement activities at or near vaccination sites.

GameStop: Markets Adjust, Politicians Frown
The week of February 22: GameStop, again, a poor choice for Interior, China’s rare-earths play, and much, much more.

House Narrowly Passes Massive COVID-Response Bill, Including $15 Minimum Wage
The bill passed largely along party lines.

What Makes the Classics Worth Studying
One classical scholar believes that the field is too implicated in ‘whiteness’ to survive as-is. Here’s why he’s wrong.