The Corner

DC Circuit Gitmo Decision: “Stinging” Defeat?

I haven’t had a chance to study yesterday’s decision from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit regarding detention proceedings for enemy combatants held at Guantanamo Bay.  But it’s already clear that the New York Times account this morning, portraying the ruling as a major defeat for the Bush administration, is misleading.

There’s a dispute over what “the record” of a detention proceeding, called a Combatant Status Review Tribunal (CSRT), is.  The government took the position that it is only the information presented at the CSRT; the combatants claim it is all information the government has pertaining to the detainee, whether it is presented at the CSRT or not.  The combatants won on that issue, but the three-judge panel appears to have been very careful about deferring to the executive branch regarding what information is deemed classified; and it makes provision for the government to disclose very sensitive information only to the court, not the combatant.

I was also suspicious of the Times report because, after you wade sixteen paragraphs into the story — paragraphs which have very little to do with the case decided yesterday but are obviously intended to convey the impression that the sky is falling on the Bush administration’s military tribunals — reporter William Glaberson drops this “oh, by the way” graph:  “The ruling also included significant victories for the government, including a decision allowing the Pentagon to limit the subjects that the lawyers can discuss with detainees and authorizing special Pentagon teams to read the lawyers’ mail and remove unauthorized comments.”

All the spin that’s fit to print.

Most Popular


UNC Caves to the ‘Buy Local’ Silliness

One of the silly notions loose in America is that there is some virtue in buying local -- preferring sellers simply because they're located in "your area" (city, county, state, country) over those located elsewhere. In other words, geographical discrimination is, supposedly, good. Governments and governmental ... Read More

Running With Trump

Jeff Roe, who managed Senator Ted Cruz’s presidential campaign in 2016, has a message for Republican congressional candidates: Don’t run from Trump this year. Instead they should “[f]ix bayonets and charge the hill.” What exactly does this mean? It’s not that they should “support the president’s ... Read More
Law & the Courts

One More Point on McCabe . . .

One point to add to Jonathan Turley’s column about Andrew McCabe, and the glaring double standard of whether an FBI official will face obstruction-of-justice charges if he’s caught lying to an FBI internal investigation. In 2015, McCabe's wife Jill ran for a state senate seat in Virginia and received ... Read More

The Pope Francis Challenge

An unforced error from a Vatican communications office the other day drove me a little something like crazy. The nature of the unforced error is that it is wholly unnecessary and typically distracting. And so it was. Days before, as the fifth anniversary of Pope Francis’s election as pope was approaching, a ... Read More