The Corner

The D.C. Gun Case

Jan Crawford Greenburg writes on the administration’s brief in the case, which gunners are criticizing. I think she characterizes the administration’s position more fairly than John Lott did on our site the other day. I don’t think the administration is saying, as Lott puts it, that “since the government bans machine guns, it should also be able to ban handguns.” I think it is saying that if the Supreme Court forbids laws against handguns, it should be careful to make sure that it does not do so on the basis of a rule that also forbids laws against machine guns. It leaves open the possibility that the courts could find the D.C. gun ban unconstitutional.

Still, I found the brief confusing. My confusion could reflect ignorance about guns. Judge Silberman ruled that the gun ban is unconstitutional, and the administration brief disputes part of his reasoning. Here’s part of how it characterizes Silberman’s holding:

The court of appeals adopted a two-part test, under which a particular weapon is a Second Amendment “Arm[]” if it (i) bears a “reasonable relationship to the preservation or efficiency of a well regulated militia,” and (ii) is “of the kind in common use at the time” the Second Amendment was adopted. . . . The court concluded that the handgun respondent sought to possess was covered under both of those prongs.

It goes on to question that test.

The court’s decision could be read to hold that the Second Amendment categorically precludes any ban on a category of “Arms” that can be traced back to the Founding era. If adopted by this Court, such an analysis could cast doubt on the constitutionality of existing federal legislation prohibiting the possession of certain firearms, including machineguns (emphasis in brief).

That’s what I don’t get. Do machine guns belong to a category of weapons that can plausibly be traced back to the Founding era?

Ramesh Ponnuru — Ramesh Ponnuru is a senior editor for National Review, a columnist for Bloomberg View, a visiting fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, and a senior fellow at the National Review Institute.

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

The Blackface Party

I must have missed something: Was there some kind of all-hands white-people meeting at which we voted to kick the Democrats out? Elizabeth Warren, Rachel Dolezal, Beto O’Rourke — what’s up with all the ethnic play-acting? Isn’t cultural appropriation supposed to be a bad thing among progressives? Isn’t ... Read More
Film & TV

A Right-Wing Halloween

‘The world is not a dark and evil place,” insists an exasperated woman played by Judy Greer in Halloween. “It’s full of love and understanding!” I put the question to the class: Is she right? In the new film (not a reboot but a sequel that occurs 40 years after the events in the 1978 original and ... Read More