The Corner


Goldberg, God, and Human Rights

Detail of Declaration of Independence by John Trumbull, 1818 (Wikimedia)

Jonah Goldberg opens his National Review cover story, an excerpt from his new book, with some provocative assertions:

Capitalism is unnatural. Democracy is unnatural. Human rights are unnatural. God didn’t give us these things, or anything else. We stumbled into modernity accidentally, not by any divine plan.

When the Founders said “We hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness, . . .” they cheated. It is not self-evident that our Creator endowed humans with unalienable rights. Something self-evident is, by definition, obvious, needing no demonstration. The existence of gravity is obvious. It is self-evident that fire burns. Yet it’s hardly obvious to everyone there’s even a Creator.

I want to offer amendments to three of Jonah’s claims in this passage.

First, I think certain human rights can be described as, in an important sense, “God-given.” The protection of rights requires institutional and cultural achievements on the part of human beings, but their existence as valid moral claims rests on the kind of beings we humans are. And the kind of beings we are, on the classical theistic account, is the kind of beings God caused us to be. The intellectual and political defense of those rights need not advert directly to our creation or our Creator; Jonah tells us his will not. That move is defensible, but so is the claim that we are endowed by our Creator with basic rights.

Second, the Declaration’s reference to “self-evident” truths is also defensible. The claim of (a certain kind of) human equality isn’t a “self-evident truth” if the term is taken to mean “a truth instantly obvious to all people.” If it were such a truth, it would hardly need stating. But a “self-evident truth” can mean a truth that cannot be deduced from more fundamental truths. You can know its truth without needing, or being able to provide, a formal demonstration on the order of a mathematical proof; precisely because it is basic, you can defend it only through indirect arguments. The principle of non-contradiction is such a truth. So is the principle that all human beings are equal in the possession of certain fundamental rights.

Third, what seems to us to have been stumbling accidentally may reflect a divine plan.

While I resist some of the formulations early in Jonah’s essay in light of the foregoing, I agree with (and enjoyed) what he writes in its main body. My point is that what he writes is completely consistent with classical theism, and more closely in harmony with a wholesome reverence for the Founders, than one might assume from that introduction.

Ramesh Ponnuru — Ramesh Ponnuru is a senior editor for National Review, a columnist for Bloomberg View, a visiting fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, and a senior fellow at the National Review Institute.

Most Popular


Responsibility and Blame

David L. Bahnsen has written a book on themes dear to my heart. It’s called “Crisis of Responsibility: Our Cultural Addiction to Blame and How You Can Cure It.” I have done a Q&A with the author, here. Thinking about his book, I remembered a few things — and shared them with David in our podcast. ... Read More

Monday Links

The Guy Who Makes the World’s Best Paper Airplanes. The Theater That Shakespeare Stole. The Invention of the Baby Carrot Phrases commonly used today which are derived from obsolete technologies. This device was used to resuscitate canaries in coal mines. The Surprisingly Complex Design of the ... Read More

Richard Pipes, Historian of Totalitarianism

‘My subject is the Russian Revolution, arguably the most important event of the twentieth century. It is my considered judgment that, had it not been for the Russian Revolution, there would very likely have been no National Socialism; probably no Second World War and no decolonization; and certainly no Cold ... Read More

School Shootings and the Incentives of Violence

Today’s Morning Jolt discusses school shootings and the common difficulties of the teenage years, and I thought of another aspect that I forgot to include -- the degree to which our society, in its reaction to violence, inadvertently rewards that violence. Every teenager wants attention, to be recognized, to ... Read More
NR Marketing

Down the Home Stretch

Our Spring 2018 Webathon winds up this week. El jefe, Mr. Lowry, makes the case, wonderfully, for your participating, even at this final stage. In case you need some visual inspiration, we’ll use this horse race image from the novel Ben Hur (you'll remember the 1959 movie version starred the late NR ... Read More