Robert Delahunty and John Yoo are in good company in thinking that the Constitution forbids the Senate from convicting a former official in an impeachment trial. But I think their argument for that view has two great weaknesses.
The first is that they wrongly take the other side of the debate to “concede. . . on the constitutional text” — by which they seem to mean that we acknowledge that the text of the Constitution confines impeachment to currently serving officials. That premise makes their argumentative work easier: To refute the other side as they present that side, they need establish only that there aren’t good reasons for overcoming the constitutional text. But the premise is false. I’m one of the people they mention, and I don’t acknowledge, because I don’t believe, that the text either says or implies that impeachment is limited to current officials. Scholars who believe the Constitution allows late impeachment — including Michael McConnell, Jonathan Adler, Brian Kalt, and many others — don’t make that concession either.




Comments