The Corner

National Security & Defense

Did Huawei’s Chairman Just Admit that Huawei Spies?

According to Reuters, Huawei’s chairman offered to make no-spy agreements with Western governments to be allowed to participate in building 5G networks. Is the offer an implicit acknowledgment that Huawei does indeed spy on its customers, or that it has the capability to? Part of the offer was to make Huawei’s equipment meet the no-spy, no backdoor standard demanded by the West, according to the report. Again, if Huawei’s equipment already met those standards then there would be no need to pledge to change current practices. As the U.K.’s Cyber Security Centre concluded in March, Huawei’s equipment is rife with security risks, and despite promises of millions of dollars in systems upgrades, the company had failed to significantly close the gaps.

If Huawei’s repeated denials of espionage activity are changing the attitude among potential government customers (and some, like Germany, seem appeased, while the U.K. sits on the fence), then why make the no-spy pledge? It may make political sense, but it certainly doesn’t make logical sense. If you don’t already spy, or don’t have the capability of doing so, then the pledge is meaningless; if you do spy, then nothing you promise will be believable, given the obviously hidden nature of the activity. If anything, the chairman’s offer may wind up convincing Westerners of the risk of letting Huawei into national 5G networks, something the Trump administration has been only partially successful at doing.

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

CNN: Everything but the News

For a while, we thought MSNBC had temporarily usurped CNN as the font of fake news — although both networks had tied for the most negative coverage (93 percent of all their news reports) of President Trump’s first 100 days in office. A cynic would argue that CNN had deliberately given Trump undue coverage ... Read More