The Corner

Energy & Environment

The Earth: It’s Alive! It’s Alive!

Earth photographed from the Apollo 16 spacecraft shortly after trans-lunar injection, April 16, 1972. (NASA)

There the New York Times goes again — pushing radical environmentalist advocacy in its Sunday paper. This time, we are told that Gaia Theory is alive and well — the ridiculous and neo-pagan notion that the earth is a living, perhaps sentient, organism and should be treated as such.

If earth is alive, why not give it rights that are coequal to those of humans? And indeed, Lake Erie was just granted rights by voters in Toledo. The Amazon and three other rivers have also been transformed into rights-bearing entities.

Moreover, if earth is alive, how can humans be considered anything other than one of countless species and no more important than any other? That’s the message often peddled by uber-greens. Indeed, why not consider us as a cancer or maggots afflicting poor, beleaguered Gaia?

Actually, those misanthropic tropes are common in contemporary environmentalism, a venerable movement that has been substantially coopted by what was once its extremist fringe. No wonder the Times published a piece trying to resurrect the idea of a living plant that has been in eclipse for some time.

After describing the amazing complexity of ecological systems–which could just as easily be deployed as an argument for the existence of God –“science writer” (!) Ferris Jabr proclaims,The Earth is Just as Alive as You Are:

Those who bristle at the notion of a living planet will argue that Earth cannot be alive because it does not eat, reproduce or evolve. Yet science has never established a precise and universally accepted definition of life, only a long list of its qualities. Like many living creatures, Earth has a highly organized structure, a membrane and daily rhythms; it consumes, stores and transforms energy; and if asteroid-hitching microbes or space-faring humans colonize other worlds, who is to say that planets are not capable of procreation?

If Earth breathes, sweats and quakes — if it births zillions of organisms that ceaselessly devour, transfigure and replenish its air, water and rock — and if those creatures and their physical environments evolve in tandem, then why shouldn’t we think of our planet as alive?

Because it isn’t! It is a planet, not an organism. Life exists on it, but the earth is no more alive than Mars. Surely, a science writer should deal in scientific facts rather than mystical notions. Good grief, even James Lovelock, who created Gaia Theory, now worries that environmentalism has become a religion.

Did I say mystical? Yup:

Humans are the brain — the consciousness — of the planet. We are Earth made aware of itself.

No. The earth isn’t aware of anything, including us.

Of course, columns such as this are primarily aimed at castigating humans as the great despoilers in order to guilt us into sacrificing our thriving to save the earth:

By fuming greenhouse gases, we have not simply changed the climate; we have critically wounded a global life form and severely disrupted its biological rhythms. No other member of this living assembly has our privileged perspective. No one else can see the sinews and vessels of our planetary body. Only we can choose to help keep Earth alive.

In an odd sense, the column supports human exceptionalism, although that certainly wasn’t the author’s purpose in writing the article or the Times’s in publishing it. As a moral species, we do indeed have the duty to treat the environment properly. But we also are duty-bound to provide for our thriving and improve the lot of destitute humanity. These can all be done at the same time under an HE approach, but that isn’t what radical environmentalists are much interested in.

Most Popular


It’s Time for Colin Kaepernick to Move On

Colin Kaepernick. Remember him? Below-average quarterback. Above-average poseur. Not “activist,” not really. Activists actually say stuff. Kaepernick almost never says anything. He’s like the Queen or most popes — you have to read the deep-background musings of supposed members of his inner circle to get ... Read More

The Age of Miscalculation

On August 7, 1998, more than 200 people were killed in terrorist attacks on U.S. embassies in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, and Nairobi, Kenya. Americans learned three names most of them never had heard before: Ayman al-Zawahiri, Osama bin Laden, and al-Qaeda. On August 20, 1998, President Bill Clinton ordered a ... Read More

Jay-Z Joins the Ranks of the Insufficiently Woke

Rapper and mogul Jay-Z announced his company’s new partnership with the National Football League and has made much of the social-justice Left furious: I think that we forget that Colin [Kaepernick]’s whole thing was to bring attention to social injustice, correct? So, in that case, this is a success; this is ... Read More