The Corner

Economy & Business

California’s Economic Performance Is Hardly a Vindication of the ‘Blue State’ Model

Over the past several years, many Republican leaders and conservative analysts have written about the diverging economic fortunes of Republican-governed states with relatively smaller governments and Democratic-governed states with relatively larger governments. Unfortunately, all too often the complex economic and public-policy issues involved have gotten oversimplified. Some analysts have compared California and Texas as prototypical Blue and Red states, for example. That has been rhetorically useful for conservatives in the past. But it has proved problematic over the past year as falling oil prices have slowed the growth of the Texas economy while California has continued to benefit from Pacific Rim trade. As a result, Democratic operatives and liberal columnists have been crowing lately about California’s superior performance, as if it disproved the economic virtues of lower taxes, less regulation, and other market-friendly policies.

It does not. Two cases establish precisely nothing, particularly when those two cases happen to be such exceptional ones as California and Texas. Most careful academic studies on the matter conclude that heavy state taxes and regulations tend to hamper state economic growth, all other things being equal. That’s the key phrase, of course. No serious person would suggest that state fiscal and regulatory policies are the most important factors affecting state economies, or even that they are large enough to swamp other factors when seeking to explain state-by-state differences in economic performance. Natural resources, geography, climate, and international trading patterns are clearly important.

At the very least, analysts should look at a range of large states rather than just two. I recently took a look at three measures — employment growth, GDP growth, and per-capita income growth — for the 10 most-populous states. In each case, I began the time series in June 2013 (because I was thinking in terms of state fiscal years). The job count grows through November 2015. The GDP measure goes through 2nd Quarter 2015. The income measure goes through 3rd Quarter 2015. Here are the topline results:

‐In employment growth (from the payroll survey), Florida, California, Georgia, Texas, and North Carolina beat the national average (in that order). Falling below the national average were Michigan, New York, Ohio, Illinois, and Pennsylvania (with PA have the lowest job-growth rate during the period).

‐In GDP growth, here are the same ten states ranked highest to lowest: Texas, Florida, California, North Carolina, Georgia, National Average, New York, Illinois, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Ohio.

‐In per-capita income growth, here are the same ten states ranked highest to lowest: California, North Carolina, Michigan, New York, Georgia, National Average, Florida, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Texas, Illinois.

Placed in the larger context, then, California’s recent economic growth looks less like proof of the superiority of the Blue State model and more like further evidence that, when possible, people still prefer to live and do business in sunny climes, particularly if they are on a coast. Three states — California, North Carolina, and Georgia — have above-average performance in all three categories. Two more, Texas and Florida, do well in two of the three measures. Michigan and New York beat the national average in only one, per-capita income. Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Illinois rank low in all three.

Just as liberals shouldn’t try to use California’s recent performance as a proof for their favored theories about economic growth, conservatives should avoid falling into the trap of holding up just a single state to prove our case. Nor should we oversell the effects of public policy, good or bad. California has such a wealth of natural and human resources that it is not easy to deal its economy a mortal blow — although its liberal politicians seem determined to test that proposition.

John Hood is a syndicated columnist and the president of the John William Pope Foundation, a North Carolina–based grantmaker.

Most Popular

Culture

‘Epstein Didn’t Kill Himself’

It was just one more segment to fill out the hour, and thereby fill the long 24 hours of Saturday’s cable news on November 2. Or so it seemed. Navy SEAL Mike Ritland was on the Fox News program Watters World to talk to Jesse Watters about trained German shepherds like the one used in the raid that found ... Read More
Film & TV

The Manly Appeal of Ford v Ferrari

There used to be a lot of overlap between what we think of as a Hollywood studio picture (designed to earn money) and an awards movie (designed to fill the trophy case, usually with an accompanying loss of money). Ford v Ferrari is a glorious throwback to the era when big stars did quality movies about actual ... Read More
Politics & Policy

ABC Chief Political Analyst: GOP Rep. Stefanik a ‘Perfect Example’ of the Failures of Electing Someone ‘Because They Are a Woman’

Matthew Dowd, chief political analyst for ABC News, suggested that Representative Elise Stefanik (R., N.Y.) was elected due to her gender after taking issue with Stefanik's line of questioning during the first public impeachment hearing on Wednesday. “Elise Stefanik is a perfect example of why just electing ... Read More
White House

Impeachment and the Broken Truce

The contradiction at the center of American politics in Anno Domini 2019 is this: The ruling class does not rule. The impeachment dog-and-pony show in Washington this week is not about how Donald Trump has comported himself as president (grotesquely) any more than early convulsions were about refreshed ... Read More
U.S.

What Happened to California Republicans?

From 1967 to 2019, Republicans controlled the California governorship for 31 of 52 years. So why is there currently not a single statewide Republican officeholder? California also has a Democratic governor and Democratic supermajorities in both houses of the state legislature. Only seven of California’s 53 ... Read More