Like so much of the academic world, the peer-review process has become corrupt, ineffective, and dysfunctional. Fortunately, there is a solution. In todayโ€™s Martin Center article, Professor Adam Ellwanger interviews two statistics professors, Ryan Martin of NC State and Harry Crane of Rutgers, about Researchers.One, which, Ellwanger writes, โ€œinvites scholars of all disciplines to use its platform to publish their scholarship without the middleman.โ€

Martin says, โ€œToday, the bestowal of this mark of quality has become the primary role of the peer review process. But this creates a disincentive, especially for junior folks, to try to branch out and develop genuinely new ideas. So, itโ€™s kind of like these mob movies like Goodfellas and Casino: the strategy to be successful in a world like that is to keep your head down and stay in line. That also happens in the academic world.โ€

Crane adds, โ€œPeer-reviewed research is referenced all the time as evidence that a published claim is true. If something was peer reviewed, then that means itโ€™s been vetted, so people assume it must be true. But thatโ€™s not actually what peer review does. In reality, peer-review is a purely administrative process that allows people to rise up the academic ladder. Whatever scholarly purpose it serves is secondary. Thatโ€™s why we started Researchers.One.โ€

Researchers.One allows any scholar to upload his or her research, where it is available for anyone to read and comment on โ€” except that anonymous comments are not allowed. Authors can respond to criticism. Real debate over the merits of the work ensues.

Why is that better? Martin explains: โ€œThe typical style of peer-review relies on the subjective assessment of two or three anonymous reviewers. From our perspective, that judgment is better left to a broader community of scholars that help one another refine and test the work thatโ€™s been done. Thatโ€™s not something any individual viewer or an editorial board can do. โ€œ

Letโ€™s hope that Researchers.One catches on. The way the peer-review process currently functions, itโ€™s too easy for hostile reviewers to suppress good research, and too easy for bad but politically correct research to gain unearned praise and acceptance.