The Corner

Gosar on Benghazi: ‘What If It Had Happened to Chelsea?’

Representative Paul Gosar is tired of waiting for answers on Benghazi. So today, the Arizona Republican drove from Capitol Hill to the State Department to hand-deliver a letter with some questions for John Kerry, and brought a few reporters and staff along for the ride. The mini SUV his scheduler drove was too full for everyone to have a seat, so the congressman stretched out in the back trunk area of the vehicle, where he chatted about dentistry (he’s a dentist) and home repair during the ride over.

But after meeting with Ur Mendoza Jaddou, the deputy assistant secretary for regional, global and functional affairs within the bureau of legislative affairs (Kerry wasn’t available, and press couldn’t attend the meeting), Gosar expressed deep frustration with how the Obama administration has handled the Benghazi attacks. And he’s especially frustrated with Hillary Clinton and her infamous “What difference does it make?” comment.

“What if it had happened to Chelsea?” Gosar said. “She would have really cared if something was going on.”  

“Nobody’s lesser or greater, that’s what our Constitution is about,” he added. “All men are created equal.”

He added that his colleagues on the House Oversight and Government Reform committee — which has been investigating the Benghazi attack — were “a little bit nervous” about his direct approach.

“The thing about it is, I’m one of these people that if you’re not getting anywhere, you gotta change it up and you gotta ask more questions,” he says. “If individuals have to take this into their hands and start trying to get different results from a different methodology, you got to. I’m results-oriented.”

Gosar’s letter directs a number of questions at the State Department, including who gave the go-ahead for Susan Rice to blame the attack on a YouTube video and what the State Department stood to gain from this decision.

He also told reporters that the bipartisan opposition to military intervention in Syria has made him optimistic that Democrats might start speaking up about Benghazi as well.

Here’s the text of Gosar’s letter:

September 11, 2013


The Honorable John Kerry

Secretary, U.S. Department of State


Dear Secretary Kerry:

It is now the first anniversary of the terrorist attack on our diplomatic facilities in Benghazi, Libya. As you know, our assets there were destroyed and four Americans—including a United States Ambassador—were brutally killed.

I am writing to ask your assistance in expediting the collection and reporting of information about what happened that night and the ensuing response from the administration. I am a member of the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, which is investigating what happened during the attack and occurred afterwards so that the families of the victims—in addition to the American public at-large—may find closure. I do not intend to duplicate the Oversight Committee’s efforts, but I share Chairman Issa’s frustration with the prolonged delays shown by the State Department in response to Chairman Issa’s May 15, 2013 letter seeking documents and the May 28, 2013 subpoena issued by the committee.   

I am concerned that administration officials are circumventing the Freedom of Information Act by utilizing private emails for official business. The actions of former Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Lisa Jackson have raised the prospect that other administration officials are using secret emails to obscure what is being done, and by whom. Further, we still do not have information about the decision to fabricate a cover story about a video leading to the Benghazi attack and the decision to blame Americans for the attack instead of factually disclosing that it was the result of a premeditated terrorist attack.

I also remain troubled by the lack of transparency from the administration with regard to disclosing who made the decision to order our military rescue teams to stand down, thereby abandoning our men in the field.   

I am now asking the following information be provided:

(1)   Are any State Department employees using private email accounts to conduct official business?

(2)   Has any review or audit been conducted internally to determine if employees are using personal or non-governmental emails to conduct official business?

(3)   Who gave final approval for Ambassador Susan Rice to tell the public and the media that the attack in Benghazi was a spontaneous attack stemming from protests about a video?

(4)   Why did the State Department want to mislead the public as to the cause of the attack on Benghazi? What was to gain by blaming the attack on a video as opposed to disclosing the truth—that the attack was a terrorist plot?

(5)   Typically we never leave our men on the field of battle. It is the one truism upon which our men and women in uniform used to be able to rely. Who approved the order not to send a military rescue for the diplomatic staff? What was the reasoning? Is this decision a change in longstanding policy or a one-time aberration?

I look forward to your response addressing these issues. It is my belief we can learn from our mistakes, and clearly, many mistakes were made before and after the Benghazi attack. American blood has paid for those mistakes, and we owe it to them to get to the bottom of this and create a better path forward.


Paul Gosar (AZ-04)


Cc:       Chairman Darrell Issa

           Ranking Member Elijah Cummings


The Latest