The Corner

Culture

In Defense of Zachary Evans: A Reply to David French

(Unsplash)

In a recent edition of his “French Press” newsletter, published by The Dispatch, our friend and former co-worker David French criticizes National Review news writer Zachary Evans for his report on the backlash against ultra-Orthodox Jews who have settled in Rockland and Orange counties in upstate New York. My respect for David is great, but his criticism is unjustified.

The criticism is twofold. First, David finds “jarring” Zack’s quotation of a source who compared the ultra-Orthodox to locusts and accused them of stripping resources from communities. Well, yes, it is jarring. That’s the point, no? I understand that it can be jarring to read a “dehumanizing” (David’s accurate description) remark about a community — and that it’s particularly jarring if the community is one’s own — but the quotation presented an attitude that, in fact, exists in Rockland County. It was self-evidently relevant to the article’s topic. The article included other quotations characterizing opposition to ultra-Orthodox development as anti-Semitic, not that Zack’s critics have bothered to mention that. A news story is not a “platform” for its sources, and averting one’s gaze will not make a problem disappear. Shall we take a hard look at what is, or pretend it isn’t? I would rather be jarred and understand the reality of a painful or alarming situation than have my feelings spared and mistakenly believe things are better than they are.

The second part of David’s criticism is that Zack’s emphasis is wrong. David writes: “There’s [a] key sentence in the [Evans] article: ‘There is no indication that [the Jersey City and Monsey attackers] attacked Jewish targets for reasons related to outmigration from New York City to the surrounding region.’ So why the extensive focus on the thing that doesn’t seem material to the attacks?”

If David had quoted the following sentence, which is also key, he would have answered his own question. That sentence reads: “Yet the attacks have rattled ultra-Orthodox in those areas nonetheless, owing in part to preexisting disputes between some ultra-Orthodox communities and the neighboring non-Jewish population in those areas.” Zack is of course not the first to report this; that very sentence links to another news article, in another publication, saying much the same.

So, yes, the outmigration is not “material to the attacks” in the sense of having caused or justified them; but it is material to ultra-Orthodox fears of violence amid rising community tensions. And that is what I take Zack to have written about. David might have preferred to read a piece focused on the attacks themselves, but “You did not write the article I wanted you to write” is, in this context, a trivial complaint. News of the attacks has not, after all, been ignored or overshadowed, and a perusal of Zack’s archive shows that he himself has written repeatedly about anti-Semitic violence.

David also writes:

As I read Evans’s piece, I had a singular thought: He’s waving away the mountain and focusing on a pebble. He’s missing the ocean for the puddle. People do not launch machete attacks over zoning disputes. They don’t open fire in kosher supermarkets because their new neighbors don’t make good salaries. There might be “simmering local conflicts” over zoning (welcome to America; there are always “simmering local conflicts” over zoning), but none of that is truly relevant to deadly violence.

Again, Zack’s article does not say that zoning disputes are “relevant to deadly violence.” Rather, it maintains that they are relevant to the fears of a community that has been the target of deadly violence. Maybe David finds that topic to be a pebble and a puddle. I do not. I challenge readers who think it insignificant to watch the anti-ultra-Orthodox campaign video released by the Rockland County GOP. Yes, it’s about a zoning dispute. That doesn’t preclude it from being revoltingly anti-Semitic, and therein lies its significance in the wake of anti-Semitic violence even though it cannot be said to have caused that violence.

David ends with some moving reflections on “people building a home”: “When [Evans] described the way that ultra-Orthodox build their houses close together, how they vote together to protect their interests, and how they devote their time to religious studies, one word came to mind — home.” Just so. I read Zack’s piece largely as an article about people building a home and encountering bigotry while doing so. The conventions of news writing perhaps made it difficult to say that as clearly as one might have done in an opinion piece. But I hope that David and anyone else who was troubled by the article will give it another read with these thoughts in mind. I believe that if they do so, many will find it to be not only excellent but important.

Most Popular

Elections

Bernie’s Huge Victory

Bernie had a massive night in Nevada, with a diverse nomination-winning-type coalition. According to the entrance poll, he won whites and Hispanics and did well among blacks. He won men and women. He won college graduates and did particularly well with non-college graduates. He won Democrats and independents. ... Read More
Elections

Bernie’s Huge Victory

Bernie had a massive night in Nevada, with a diverse nomination-winning-type coalition. According to the entrance poll, he won whites and Hispanics and did well among blacks. He won men and women. He won college graduates and did particularly well with non-college graduates. He won Democrats and independents. ... Read More

Elon Musk’s Plan to Settle Mars

He who follows Freedom, let him leave his homeland, and risk his life. — Adam Mickiewicz, Polish poet, 1832 Last week my wife Hope and I traveled to Boca Chica, Texas, to meet with Elon Musk. While we talked inside the SpaceX onsite headquarters, a mariachi band played outside, providing entertainment for ... Read More

Elon Musk’s Plan to Settle Mars

He who follows Freedom, let him leave his homeland, and risk his life. — Adam Mickiewicz, Polish poet, 1832 Last week my wife Hope and I traveled to Boca Chica, Texas, to meet with Elon Musk. While we talked inside the SpaceX onsite headquarters, a mariachi band played outside, providing entertainment for ... Read More
U.S.

Women’s Sports Should Be Women’s Sports

Transgender sports policies make a mockery of women’s competition. Just look at the state of Connecticut. At the 2018 state open for women’s track and field, two young men identifying as transgender took first and second place in the 100m race. Their participation not only deprived young women of their ... Read More
U.S.

Women’s Sports Should Be Women’s Sports

Transgender sports policies make a mockery of women’s competition. Just look at the state of Connecticut. At the 2018 state open for women’s track and field, two young men identifying as transgender took first and second place in the 100m race. Their participation not only deprived young women of their ... Read More
Elections

Bernie’s Houses

Mike Bloomberg scored a hit -- a palpable hit -- in the debate this week when he pointed back at Bernie Sanders and said: “What a wonderful country we have, the best-known socialist in the country happens to be a millionaire with three houses.” Many conservatives laughed and cheered and wondered why Bernie ... Read More
Elections

Bernie’s Houses

Mike Bloomberg scored a hit -- a palpable hit -- in the debate this week when he pointed back at Bernie Sanders and said: “What a wonderful country we have, the best-known socialist in the country happens to be a millionaire with three houses.” Many conservatives laughed and cheered and wondered why Bernie ... Read More

Escape from Wuhan

The onset of the crisis in Wuhan startled me like a jump scare in a horror movie. You’ve seen the kind I mean. The audience is led to believe that the monster, psycho killer—or what have you—pursuing the intended victim is still distant. Then whatever it is stands up from behind, leaps out in front, bursts ... Read More

Escape from Wuhan

The onset of the crisis in Wuhan startled me like a jump scare in a horror movie. You’ve seen the kind I mean. The audience is led to believe that the monster, psycho killer—or what have you—pursuing the intended victim is still distant. Then whatever it is stands up from behind, leaps out in front, bursts ... Read More