The Corner

It’s Not Kristallnacht

For the last year, liberals cosseted by total control of Washington have insisted that it is the right that is overcome with the paranoid style of American politics. And to be sure, there are some overly conspiratorial guys on the right. But for sheer hysteria and paranoia, how can anything on the right compare to the cries of “kristallnacht!” belching forth from establishment liberals? Frank Rich played the Kristallnacht card as did John Avlon of the Daily Beast in response to a handful of broken Democratic windows. This is as rational as thinking if an Asian guy steals a comic book from a gas station, it’s proof that Genghis Khan is about to invade. It’s like a comparing a blackjack dealer shift change at an Indian casino to the Trail of Tears. And yet, these people say it as if conservatives need to apologize for something. Worse, this kind of guilt-by-association routinely passes as intelligent commentary. It’s amazing.

Anyway, from my column:

The Daily Beast’s John Avlon insists that Vanderboegh’s rallying cry, combined with some threats and broken windows, make “the parallels, intentional or not, to the Nazis’ heinous 1938 Kristallnacht . . . hard to ignore.”

Actually, it’s really, really easy to ignore the parallels. During Kristallnacht, Nazi goons destroyed not just 7,000 store windows but hundreds of synagogues and thousands of homes. Tens of thousands of Jews were hauled off to concentration camps by the Nazis, who had been in total power for half a decade.

This combination of state power and murderous, genocidal intent is nowhere on display in America today, not in the Obama administration (contrary to what some overheated right-wingers claim) and certainly not among out-of-power conservatives and “tea partiers.” It’s amazing anyone needs to point this out, but a few fringe libertarians’ throwing bricks to beat back an expansion of government is not the same thing as the tightening fist of the National Socialist Third Reich. Indeed, it’s an anti-American slander to suggest anything like it is going on here, and it cheapens the moral horror of the Holocaust.

Don’t tell that to the Democrats and their media transmission belt, who largely turned a blind eye to partisan vandalism and extremist rhetoric against Republicans for eight years but now express horror at what they claim to hear from the right.

Columnist Paul Krugman, who encouraged liberals to hang Sen. Joe Lieberman (I., Conn.) in effigy, is concerned about right-wing “eliminationist rhetoric.” The Washington Post’s Courtland Milloy can’t stand the incivility of the tea partiers, which is why he wants to “knock every racist and homophobic tooth out of their Cro-Magnon heads.” Frank Rich says the mantra “take our country back” is now code for a white racist backlash — though it was an apparently fine Democratic applause line when George W. Bush was president.


The Latest