The Corner

Judicial Restraint and Its Genealogy, Ctd.

I wrote about Damon Root, an advocate of what I would describe as libertarian judicial activism, in this space yesterday. He responds today.

He clarifies that he is not saying that judicial restraint was the invention of progressives. He says he is merely saying that the progressives influenced later conservatives who championed judicial restraint. He writes: “Ponnuru must be unaware that Robert Bork himself proudly owned up to the decisive influence that Progressive legal thinking had on his own intellectual development.”

I must? Root is responding to a post in which I wrote that “Holmes and progressives sometimes spoke in favor of judicial restraint” and “their work has influenced later conservatives. (For what it’s worth, I think that much of influence has been baleful.)” I’ll add now, though, that some of that influence has been for the good: The progressives were wrong about many things, but not about the limited role the courts should play in setting public policy.

I have no quarrel with the banal thesis that progressive legal thought influenced later conservative jurists. I don’t think that gets the libertarian legal project very far—let alone, as I discussed yesterday, that it converts John Marshall and James Madison into posthumous allies of it.

Ramesh Ponnuru is a senior editor for National Review, a columnist for Bloomberg Opinion, a visiting fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, and a senior fellow at the National Review Institute.

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

FBI Lovebirds Is D.C. Satire at Its Best

What do you get when you take Dean Cain, an actor famous for playing Superman on TV, and Kristy Swanson, the actress who was the original Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and give them the chance to play a couple of adulterous, wildly partisan FBI agents working at the highest levels of the Mueller Russiagate ... Read More
Film & TV

In Toy Story 4, the Franchise Shows Its Age

For a film franchise, 24 years is middle-aged, bordering on elderly. Nearly a quarter-century after the first Toy Story, the fourth installment, which hits theaters later this week, feels a bit tired. If earlier films in the franchise were about loss and abandonment and saying goodbye to childhood, this one is ... Read More