The Corner

On Foreign Tech Workers, the Evidence Is against Marco Rubio

During last week’s debate, Marco Rubio was asked about the fired Disney employees who were required to train their foreign replacements as a condition of their severance pay. “You support increasing the H-1B visa program that made it possible to bring in these foreign workers,” said journalist Stephen Dinan. “Doesn’t this program take jobs away from Americans?” In response, Rubio described the Disney case as an “abuse” of the program, claiming companies are not allowed to use H-1Bs to replace American workers.

Where are the fact checkers when we need them? Mark Krikorian already noted here that undercutting American workers is actually the norm for the H-1B program, not the exception that Rubio might have us believe. To bolster Mark’s point, I want to highlight the best evidence I have seen on how H-1Bs affect employment and wages. A recent paper by economists Kirk Doran, Alexander Gelber, and Adam Isen takes advantage of the fact that H-1Bs are distributed by a random lottery on the day the number of applications exceeds the cap. The researchers were able to isolate the effect of H-1B workers by comparing companies that applied for a visa and won the lottery with companies that applied and lost.

If H-1B workers are truly exceptional talents for whom there are few American substitutes, then we would expect to see that lottery-winning companies increase their employment relative to the lottery losers by roughly the number of H-1B workers they receive. (In fact, if the more grandiose claims about immigrant productivity are true, then we would expect the lottery-winning companies to generate even more jobs beyond the ones that go to the H-1Bs.) Instead, both lottery-winning and lottery-losing firms ended up with employment levels that were statistically indistinguishable. Presumably, the losing companies just went ahead and hired someone who was not an H-1B.

Although the evidence is less robust, it also appears that lottery-winning companies lowered median wages and increased their profits relative to the lottery losers. So the lottery data are more consistent with the view that firms use the H-1B program to hire cheaper substitute workers from abroad, not to bring in the next Einstein.

Reducing labor costs is not an inherently bad thing, of course, since the efficiency gains may lead to lower prices for consumers. Nevertheless, Senator Rubio and other H-1B supporters need to stop pretending the program is merely being “abused” by a few bad apples. Trading wages for efficiency is the H-1B’s raison d’être.

Jason Richwine is a public-policy analyst and a contributor to National Review Online.

Most Popular


Men Literally Died for That Flag, You Idiots

The American flag’s place in our culture is beginning to look less unassailable. The symbol itself is under attack, as we’ve seen with Nike dumping a shoe design featuring an early American flag, Megan Rapinoe defending her national-anthem protests (she says she will never sing the song again), and ... Read More

The Plot against Kavanaugh

Justice on Trial, by Mollie Hemingway and Carrie Severino (Regnery,  256 pp., $28.99) The nomination and confirmation of Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court was the political event of 2018, though not for the reasons anyone expected. All High Court confirmations these days are fraught with emotion and tumult ... Read More
Politics & Policy

He Just Can’t Help Himself

By Saturday, the long-simmering fight between Nancy Pelosi and her allies on one side and the “squad” associated with Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez on the other had risen to an angrier and more destructive level at the Netroots Nation conference. Representative Ayanna Pressley, an African-American Massachusetts ... Read More
White House

On Gratitude and Immigration

Like both Rich and David, I consider it flatly inappropriate for the president of the United States to be telling Americans -- rhetorically or otherwise -- to “go back where you came from.” In consequence, you will find no defense of the president from me, either. What Trump tweeted over the weekend was ... Read More

Gender Dissenter Gets Fired

Allan M. Josephson is a distinguished psychiatrist who, since 2003, has transformed the division of child and adolescent psychiatry and psychology at the University of Louisville from a struggling department to a nationally acclaimed program. In the fall of 2017 he appeared on a panel at the Heritage Foundation ... Read More

The ‘Squad’ Gives a Gift to Donald Trump

On Sunday, Donald Trump gave the Democrats a gift -- comments that indicate he thinks native-born congresswomen he detests should “go back” to the countries of their ancestors. On Monday, the four congresswomen handed Trump a gift in return, managing to respond to the president’s insults in some of the most ... Read More