The Corner

McCain on Gitmo

Ed Whelan has criticized Ruth Marcus’s column already, but I want to zero in on one passage from it.

McCain’s sharp criticism of Boumediene, she writes,

makes little sense from a man who has repeatedly vowed to shut down Guantanamo — on his first day in office, no less — and ship its remaining prisoners to Fort Leavenworth.

After all, the whole point of stashing the detainees at Guantanamo was to avoid giving them the rights that everyone acknowledged they would have on U.S. soil. So the McCain solution — sending them to Leavenworth — would create the very situation he now decries.

I can see pros and cons to McCain’s Gitmo pledge. But it’s not clear that being on U.S. soil would automatically grant detainees all the rights that are being debated, let alone that “everyone acknowledged” as much. Here’s what a lawyer friend of mine wrote me on this point:

[I]n Hamdi (2004), the Supremes indicated that even an American citizen held in the U.S. as an enemy combatant should not have full-blown criminal defendant rights in a habeas proceeding to challenge combatant status.  Justice O’Connor suggested that a [Combatant Status Review Tribunal] would probably be sufficient, as long as their was judicial review to ensure that it was a reasonably fair proceeding. To be sure, Boumediene seems much different in tone from Hamdi.  But there is law on the books — recent law from many of the same justices in the Boumediene majority — suggesting that merely bringing the detainees into the U.S. does not mean they get the full run of constitutional rights or that their habeas proceedings must resemble civilian criminal trials.

Ramesh Ponnuru is a senior editor for National Review, a columnist for Bloomberg Opinion, a visiting fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, and a senior fellow at the National Review Institute.

Most Popular

The Pollster Who Thinks Trump Is Ahead

The polling aggregator on the website RealClearPolitics shows the margin in polls led by Joe Biden in a blue font and the ones led by Donald Trump in red. For a while, the battleground states have tended to be uniformly blue, except for polls conducted by the Trafalgar Group. If you are a firm believer only in ... Read More

The Pollster Who Thinks Trump Is Ahead

The polling aggregator on the website RealClearPolitics shows the margin in polls led by Joe Biden in a blue font and the ones led by Donald Trump in red. For a while, the battleground states have tended to be uniformly blue, except for polls conducted by the Trafalgar Group. If you are a firm believer only in ... Read More
Media

Jeffrey Toobin and Our Public-Hate Ritual

Oh, Jeffrey Toobin — let him among us with a free hand cast the first stone. Toobin, a writer for The New Yorker and fixture on CNN, was participating in a role-playing exercise on a Zoom call with his magazine colleagues, wargaming election-night scenarios. Toobin was standing in for the courts when he ... Read More
Media

Jeffrey Toobin and Our Public-Hate Ritual

Oh, Jeffrey Toobin — let him among us with a free hand cast the first stone. Toobin, a writer for The New Yorker and fixture on CNN, was participating in a role-playing exercise on a Zoom call with his magazine colleagues, wargaming election-night scenarios. Toobin was standing in for the courts when he ... Read More
Politics & Policy

How Air Conditioning Ruined America

When Joe Biden was first elected to the U.S. Senate having just reached his 30th birthday, he met with James Eastland, a veteran segregationist Democrat from Mississippi, and asked him what the most significant change to the Senate had been in his time. Eastland first arrived in the Senate in 1941. “Air ... Read More
Politics & Policy

How Air Conditioning Ruined America

When Joe Biden was first elected to the U.S. Senate having just reached his 30th birthday, he met with James Eastland, a veteran segregationist Democrat from Mississippi, and asked him what the most significant change to the Senate had been in his time. Eastland first arrived in the Senate in 1941. “Air ... Read More