The Corner

Minor Quibbles . . .

In “California’s Illegal-Immigrant Deficit,” Heather Mac Donald transforms California’s budget crisis into an illegal-immigrant crisis. The $5 billion California spends on illegals, she contends, represent “almost a quarter of California’s $21.3 billion deficit.” But California is slated to spend $111 billion in its 2009-2010 budget, and illegals are 8% of California’s population. California spends considerably less per capita on illegals than on citizens.

The calculation on which Mac Donald’s piece is based cites estimates that $4 billion is spent on the children of illegals.

But in fact, 73% of the children of illegals are American citizens, having been born here. Perhaps you don’t like birthright citizenship (although most of us are citizens for no better reason). But public-education expenditures on their citizen children are no more wasteful than other public-education expenditures.

Heather reports that 10% of the state prison population consists of illegals. But if federal incarceration statistics are any guide, more than half of Hispanic incarcerations are for immigration violations, not for drug offenses, larcenies, or crimes of violence. If so, illegals, at 8% of California’s population, are rather less crime prone than natives.

But these are mere quibbles. Mac Donald is right in substance, if not in magnitude: Undocumented immigrants impose public costs. These costs are a result of lawbreaking. In California, these costs may represent a couple percent of total state expenditures.

Most Popular

Law & the Courts

Yes, There Was FBI Bias

There is much to admire in Justice Department inspector general Michael Horowitz’s highly anticipated report on the FBI’s Clinton-emails investigation. Horowitz’s 568-page analysis is comprehensive, fact-intensive, and cautious to a fault. It is also, nonetheless, an incomplete exercise — it omits half ... Read More
U.S.

Yes, Hillary Should Have Been Prosecuted

I know this is ancient history, but — I’m sorry — I just can’t let it go. When historians write the definitive, sordid histories of the 2016 election, the FBI, Hillary, emails, Russia, and Trump, there has to be a collection of chapters making the case that Hillary should have faced a jury ... Read More
Sports

Let the World Have Soccer

The United States of America did not qualify for the World Cup this year. Good for us. Soccer is corrupt, hyper-regulated, impoverished by a socialist-style fondness for rationing, and organized to strangle human flourishing. It is so dependent on the whims of referees that is in effect a helpless captive of the ... Read More