The Corner

More On The Fair Tax

I should have added a clarification along these lines as well. From a reader:

Jonah, I read your latest Corner post titled “Re: the Fair Tax, A Partial Correction,” and I’d like to offer a clarification. The Fair Taxers (and others) typically argue that the repeal of the 16th Amendment would make an income tax unconstitutional. However, that is not the case. The income tax is permitted under Article I, Section 9, Clause 4 of the Constitution, with the “census or enumeration” part referring to Article I, Section 2. The debate before the 16th Amendment was ratified was whether the income tax was a direct tax and therefore subject to apportionment. An 1894 case, Pollock v. Farmers’ Loan and Trust Co, ruled that a tax on income derived from property is indistiguishable from a tax on the property itself and was therefore a direct tax…but only a direct tax on that segment of income. An income tax on wages isn’t a direct tax, per Pollock, and therefore allowed without apportionment. It was a decision that went against all other previous decisions and treatments on the subject, but we were stuck with it anyway. Rather than come up with an income tax scheme that apportioned taxes on income from property but left other income alone, the 16th Amendment was introduced to remove the apportionment requirement from any and all income taxes. So the 16th Amendment doesn’t create the income tax. Instead it explicitly says that an income tax is not subject to be apportioned, whatever the source of the income. It’s actually a rather refreshing case of the Supreme Court’s interpretation being overruled by Congress in a Constitutionally prescribed manner. Thanks, John

Most Popular

Education

Ivy-League Schools Wither

A  number of liberal bastions are daily being hammered — especially the elite university and Silicon Valley. A Yale and a Stanford, or Facebook and Google, assume — for the most part rightly — that each is so loudly progressive that the public, federal and state regulators, and politicians would of ... Read More
Elections

Weirdo O’Rourke

Friends of the young Bill Clinton and Barack Obama spoke of the special glow of promise they had about them, even back in their early twenties. Angels sat on their shoulders. History gave them a wink and said, “Hey, good lookin’, I’ll be back to pick you up later.” Robert O’Rourke? Not so much. He ... Read More
Elections

One More Profile of Beto, Because America Needs It

Somewhere in Texas, filed on the fly by a glossy-magazine correspondent, and totally not as a parody written by Jim Geraghty -- “It’s all about vision,” Beto O’Rourke tells me, standing tall upon the Texas prairie, or brush, or whatever this high hilltop area is supposed to be called. We’re watching the ... Read More