The Corner

Law & the Courts

New York City Might Avoid Making Second Amendment History

A man inspects a handgun at the NRA annual meeting in Indianapolis, Ind., April 28, 2019. (Lucas Jackson/Reuters)

We gun nuts have long had our eyes on New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. New York City, a challenge to one of the Big Apple’s myriad limits on firearm ownership. The Supreme Court heard oral arguments on the case yesterday, and hopes run high for the new conservative majority — but the litigation could still end with a whimper.

Until recently, New Yorkers with “premises” licenses were hardly allowed to leave the house with their guns. They couldn’t even bring their weapons, locked and unloaded, to a second home, or to a shooting range outside the city. That would take a carry license, which is effectively impossible to get in New York without friends in high places.

The new case challenges those transportation limits, giving the Court a chance to start fleshing out the rules it laid down in Heller and McDonald about a decade ago. These opinions struck down some of the country’s worst gun bans but offered relatively little guidance about what other kinds of gun-control laws were allowed, especially laws regulating gun possession outside the home.

But New York saw the writing on the wall and made a tactical retreat. After the High Court agreed to hear the case, the city gave premises-license holders a somewhat broader ability to travel with their weapons, and the state government passed a law to keep the old policy from coming back. No one thinks these lawmakers have seen the light; they know they will lose before a conservative Court, thus setting a nationwide precedent, and would rather wait to fight the gun issue sometime in the future, with more liberal justices.

The legal aspect of this strategy is that for a court to weigh in on an issue, there has to be a live case or controversy. If the dispute has been settled by other means out of court, it’s “moot.” However, because we don’t want to allow governments to strategically stop and restart their unconstitutional conduct, they have to show they won’t resume their abuses once the case has been disposed of.

That issue took up a lot of time at oral argument. New York City has ended the policy and vows not to punish anyone for previous violations, and, as additional insurance that the abuse won’t continue, the state has banned it too. What’s left to argue?

There are a few ways the Court could decide there’s still a controversy here — those challenging the law could seek damages for past abuses, or the justices could make much of the fact that the new, revised rules don’t make all the concessions that the challengers could plausibly have won in court. But it’s far from clear that all five conservative justices can get behind these rationales, and unlikely any of the liberals would lend a hand.

Josh Blackman predicts the Court will find the matter moot, with at least John Roberts joining the liberals. If he’s right, there are two different ways this could play out. One, the Court could take the time to issue a written decision on the matter, ideally in a way that clarifies mootness doctrine for future cases. Or two, it could dismiss the case as “improvidently granted” and take up a new Second Amendment case almost immediately.

Most Popular

White House

The Damning Inspector General’s Report

It is hard to believe that the run-up to the presidential-election year has plumbed such a depth of farcical degradation. It must be that Trump’s influence has contributed to unserious responses, but he can’t be blamed for the unutterable nonsense of his opponents and the straight men of the political class ... Read More
White House

The Damning Inspector General’s Report

It is hard to believe that the run-up to the presidential-election year has plumbed such a depth of farcical degradation. It must be that Trump’s influence has contributed to unserious responses, but he can’t be blamed for the unutterable nonsense of his opponents and the straight men of the political class ... Read More
World

Present at the Demolition

Economists at the World Bank and International Monetary Fund must feel pretty lucky these days. They work for just about the only institutions set up in the aftermath of World War II that aren't in the middle of an identity crisis. From Turtle Bay to Brussels, from Washington to Vienna, the decay of the economic ... Read More
World

Present at the Demolition

Economists at the World Bank and International Monetary Fund must feel pretty lucky these days. They work for just about the only institutions set up in the aftermath of World War II that aren't in the middle of an identity crisis. From Turtle Bay to Brussels, from Washington to Vienna, the decay of the economic ... Read More
Elections

Diversity Panic Hits the Democratic Field

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before. An Asian guy, two black guys, three white women (one of whom spent much of her life claiming to be Native American), a Pacific Islander woman, a gay guy, a Hispanic guy, two elderly Caucasian Jews (one a billionaire, the other a socialist), a self-styled Irishman, and a ... Read More
Elections

Diversity Panic Hits the Democratic Field

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before. An Asian guy, two black guys, three white women (one of whom spent much of her life claiming to be Native American), a Pacific Islander woman, a gay guy, a Hispanic guy, two elderly Caucasian Jews (one a billionaire, the other a socialist), a self-styled Irishman, and a ... Read More
World

Well . . . .

So much for my prophecies of doom. Britain's Conservatives won, and they won with a very healthy parliamentary majority, breaking through Labour’s “red wall” across the industrial (and post-industrial) Midlands and the North. The BBC: Leave-voting former mining towns like Workington, which was seen as ... Read More
World

Well . . . .

So much for my prophecies of doom. Britain's Conservatives won, and they won with a very healthy parliamentary majority, breaking through Labour’s “red wall” across the industrial (and post-industrial) Midlands and the North. The BBC: Leave-voting former mining towns like Workington, which was seen as ... Read More
White House

The Costs of Trivializing Impeachment

Resorting to a vague “abuse of power” theory, the House Judiciary Committee Friday morning referred two articles of impeachment to the full House on the inevitable party-line vote. The full House will impeach the president next week, perhaps Wednesday, also on the inevitable party-line vote. The scarlet ... Read More
White House

The Costs of Trivializing Impeachment

Resorting to a vague “abuse of power” theory, the House Judiciary Committee Friday morning referred two articles of impeachment to the full House on the inevitable party-line vote. The full House will impeach the president next week, perhaps Wednesday, also on the inevitable party-line vote. The scarlet ... Read More
World

The U.K. Elections Were the Real Second Referendum

In the end, it wasn’t close at all. Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour party met a fate to which it has been accustomed for most of the last half-century. Once again, the British roundly rejected socialism. Boris Johnson and his conservatives will form the next British government. This was no slight rejection. Labour ... Read More
World

The U.K. Elections Were the Real Second Referendum

In the end, it wasn’t close at all. Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour party met a fate to which it has been accustomed for most of the last half-century. Once again, the British roundly rejected socialism. Boris Johnson and his conservatives will form the next British government. This was no slight rejection. Labour ... Read More