The Corner

Law & the Courts

Noncitizen Voting Has Not Been ‘Debunked’

In criticizing Donald Trump’s unsupported claim that millions of noncitizens swung the popular vote, the media have gone too far in the other direction, dismissing legitimate — albeit merely suggestive — evidence that significant noncitizen voting does occur in American elections. Take the much-discussed study [pdf] by Jesse Richman, Gulshan Chattha, and David Earnest, published in the journal Electoral Studies. Based on a national survey, the authors found that a small percentage of noncitizens do report voting — roughly 6 percent in 2008 — and that their votes might be enough to affect very close elections, such as the Minnesota Senate race between Al Franken and Norm Coleman.

The Richman-Chattha-Earnest study was immediately criticized for overinterpreting what might be just measurement error in the citizenship variable. (In other words, citizen voters may have accidentally labeled themselves noncitizens in the survey.) But subsequent robustness tests by the authors show that at least some of the self-identified noncitizen voters in the authors’ dataset really do appear to be noncitizens. I looked into this debate in some depth recently, and I came away feeling that there is still too much uncertainty to draw strong conclusions, but the Richman-Chattha-Earnest study is certainly a valuable contribution.

At Politico, Brent Griffiths apparently disagrees. After a Trump spokesman cited the Richman-Chattha-Earnest study, Griffiths reported it as “debunked” and “refuted,” without mentioning the authors’ responses to the supposed debunking. He even incorrectly characterized their study as focusing on illegal immigrants, when the subjects of the study (and of Trump’s claim) were noncitizens in general.

To its credit, the Washington Post fact-checker at least quotes Jesse Richman, the first author of the study, and gives his side of the story. Nevertheless, the Post warns that the Trump team must stop citing the study — lest Trump draw the fact-checker’s cruel wrath again, presumably.

There are two lessons here. First, politicians and media figures must do a better job of accepting uncertainty. If there is any overarching theme to my writing, it is that people are much too confident in their beliefs about the world. Advocates will seize the mantle of Science with the flimsiest of evidence, then quickly dismiss contrary data as “debunked.” Sooner or later, a false consensus develops around ideas that were never firmly established — in this case, that illegal voting is nothing to worry about. In their rush to shout “Pants on fire!” the media seem to have forgotten the value of admitting “We just don’t know.”

The second lesson is that liberal dominance of the social sciences continues to pay dividends in the media. Once the Richman-Chattha-Earnest study was released, it met immediate hostility from experts intent on debunking it. This seems to happen whenever any academic study provides political ammunition (intentional or not) to conservatives. And yet the media landscape is suffused with junk science purporting to prove all sorts of liberal political claims: Diversity makes people smarter, same-sex marriage improves public health, only 2 to 8 percent of rape accusations are false, and so on. The media often treat these dubious claims as factual, but who can blame them when there is no army of debunkers they can learn from? I don’t pretend to know how to fix this imbalance, but keep it in mind the next time someone cites a “consensus.”

PS. Here’s a message for the next Census Bureau director. A simple tweak of the Current Population Survey could shed a lot of light on noncitizen voting. The November supplement asks respondents whether they are registered and whether they voted in the most recent election. Unfortunately, it asks those questions only of respondents who have already said they are citizens. Ask about voting before establishing citizenship, and let’s see what that turns up.

Jason Richwine is a public-policy analyst and a contributor to National Review Online.

Most Popular

Culture

What We’ve Learned about Jussie Smollett

It’s been a few weeks since March 26, when all charges against Jussie Smollett were dropped and the actor declared that his version of events had been proven correct. How’s that going? Smollett’s celebrity defenders have gone quiet. His publicists and lawyers are dodging reporters. The @StandwithJussie ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The Lessons of the Mueller Probe

Editor’s Note: The following is the written testimony submitted by Mr. McCarthy in connection with a hearing earlier today before the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence on the Mueller Report (specifically, the first volume of the report, which addresses Russia’s interference in the 2016 ... Read More
Elections

Kamala Harris Runs for Queen

I’m going to let you in on a secret about the 2020 presidential contest: Unless unforeseen circumstances lead to a true wave election, the legislative stakes will be extremely low. The odds are heavily stacked against Democrats’ retaking the Senate, and that means that even if a Democrat wins the White House, ... Read More
World

Why Are the Western Middle Classes So Angry?

What is going on with the unending Brexit drama, the aftershocks of Donald Trump’s election, and the “yellow vests” protests in France? What drives the growing estrangement of southern and eastern Europe from the European Union establishment? What fuels the anti-EU themes of recent European elections and ... Read More
Energy & Environment

The Climate Trap for Democrats

The more the climate debate changes, the more it stays the same. Polls show that the public is worried about climate change, but that doesn’t mean that it is any more ready to bear any burden or pay any price to combat it. If President Donald Trump claws his way to victory again in Pennsylvania and the ... Read More
White House

Sarah Sanders to Resign at End of June

Sarah Huckabee Sanders will resign from her position as White House press secretary at the end of the month, President Trump announced on Twitter Thursday afternoon. https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/1139263782142787585 Sanders, the daughter of former Arkansas governor Mike Huckabee, succeeded Sean ... Read More
Politics & Policy

But Why Is Guatemala Hungry?

I really, really don’t want to be on the “Nicolas Kristof Wrote Something Dumb” beat, but, Jiminy Cricket! Kristof has taken a trip to Guatemala, with a young woman from Arizona State University in tow. “My annual win-a-trip journey,” he writes. Reporting from Guatemala, he discovers that many ... Read More