That’s the title of this excellent essay by Princeton professor Robert P. George, who addresses the “puzzle of [Obama’s] pro-life Catholic and Evangelical apologists” and finds their arguments “delusional”. (Disclosure: Professor George serves on the board of the Ethics and Public Policy Center, which I run.)
The essay also contains a fine explanation why the politically correct term “pro-choice” (which has corrupted a good English word) should be assigned to the rubbish heap.