The Corner

Oscar Nominations: The Year of Sentimental Populism

What an unusual list of Oscar nominees for Best Picture — sentimental and populist. Among the nominated films, there are no movies with big social or political statements, nor are there the usual films with dark themes. There is nothing to rival Brokeback Mountain, The Kids Are All Right, Milk, or even Black Swan, Precious, or Winter’s Bone. Oscar took a pass on the politically charged Iron Lady, even if Streep received an inevitable nod for Best Actress. Also overlooked was Girl with a Dragon Tattoo, the remake of a Swedish film, featuring grisly sexual violence, a decent murder mystery investigation and an all too predictable discovery as to the source of the evil.

Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close, The Help, Hugo, and War Horse are all quite accessible films that hope to uplift and inspire. Moneyball, a terrific fact-based story that is about much more than baseball, is also an uplifting film in its own way. A silent film wouldn’t seem to fit the trend I’m describing, but The Artist manages to combine wit, charm, and romance in a hugely entertaining story. George Clooney’s The Descendants is about as quirky as this year’s list gets, but in the end it is about reconnecting to family.

The remaining films are less populist, and perhaps it is here that this year’s Oscar’s list distinguishes itself. Woody Allen’s latest, Midnight in Paris (which remained in theaters a lot longer than any of his other recent films), is a number of love stories in one: love between men and women, love of old Paris, and love of art and great writing.

The least populist of the films on this year’s list, Tree of Life, became notorious for reports about viewers walking out on its obscure plot. Its attempt to weave a story of familial loss into a myth about the beginning of the universe, leading with a quotation from the Book of Job, led some to call it pretentious. But it is a story of hope in the midst of suffering and in this a noticeable contrast to another film that bridges the cosmic and the personal but which was passed over in this year’s Oscars: Lars von Trier’s deeply cynical Melancholia.

Oscar might be accused of going a bit soft and sappy on us this year. Sentimentality — sometimes effective, sometimes not — dominates in War Horse, Hugo, and Midnight in ParisThis is a big shift from just a few years ago, when everyone was surprised that the popular The Blind Side even received a nomination. Will this year’s nominees set a trend among Oscar voters? Unlikely, I think, but the shift this year is still worth remarking.

Thomas S. Hibbs — Thomas S. Hibbs is the dean of the honors college and distinguished professor of philosophy at Baylor University.

Most Popular


George Packer Gets Mugged by Reality

Few journalists are as respected by, and respectable to, liberals as The Atlantic’s George Packer. The author of The Assassin's Gate (2005), The Unwinding (2013), and a recently published biography of Richard Holbrooke, Our Man, Packer has written for bastions of liberal thought from the New York Times Magazine ... Read More
Politics & Policy

CNN: Everything but the News

For a while, we thought MSNBC had temporarily usurped CNN as the font of fake news — although both networks had tied for the most negative coverage (93 percent of all their news reports) of President Trump’s first 100 days in office. A cynic would argue that CNN had deliberately given Trump undue coverage ... Read More
Health Care

The Absurd Campaign against Vaping

There has been a burst of panicked news, competing claims, and unfounded fear related to “vaping,” the use of electronic devices to produce an inhaled vapor, usually containing nicotine, which has emerged as a common alternative to smoking. As is commonly the case, the controversy surrounding vaping ... Read More