The Corner

P. J. O’Rourke’s Defense of Truthiness

I noted below U.S. District Court judge Timothy Black’s ruling yesterday striking down an Ohio law that allowed the state election commission to censor “false” political speech.

The judge’s decision is a good one, but the best reading in the case is an amicus curiae brief filed on behalf of the plaintiff — by none other than right-wing humorist P.J. O’Rourke. “The case concerns amici,” he writes, “because the law at issue undermines the First Amendment’s protection of the serious business of making politics funny.”

Co-written with the Cato Institute, the brief manages both to argue and to entertain (with barbs aplenty at both Left and Right). Borrowing Stephen Colbert’s notion of “truthiness” — “a ‘truth’ asserted ‘from the gut’ or because it ‘feels right,’ without regard to evidence or logic” — O’Rourke makes the case that Ohio’s law chills the speech not just of politicos but of anyone who might care to make a political point by way of a joke — not just O’Rourke, of course, but outlets such as the Onion. When it comes to political deception, he says, “a crushing send-up on The Daily Show or The Colbert Report will do more to clean up political rhetoric than the Ohio Election Commission ever could.”

“Criminalizing political speech is no laughing matter” — but the case against it can certainly be funny. Two choice tidbits that conservatives will enjoy:

Driehaus voted for Obamacare, which the Susan B. Anthony List said was the equivalent of voting for taxpayer-funded abortion. Amici are unsure how true the allegation is given that the healthcare law seems to change daily, but it certainly isn’t as truthy as calling a mandate a tax. . . .

While President Obama isn’t from Kenya, he is a Keynesian—so you can see where the confusion arises.

There is much more — for “pinko-communist flag-burners” and “assault weapon-wielding maniacs” alike. You can read O’Rourke’s brief in full here. (And don’t miss the footnotes.)

Ian Tuttle — Ian Tuttle is the former Thomas L. Rhodes Journalism Fellow at the National Review Institute.

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

Did Flynn Lie?

At the outset, let’s get two things straight: First, there is something deeply disturbing about the Obama administration’s decision to open a counterintelligence investigation on retired lieutenant general Michael Flynn while he was working on the Trump campaign — and, ultimately, about the Justice ... Read More
Law & the Courts

Where Is the Flynn 302?

Better late than never (I hope), my weekend column has posted on the website. It deals with the question whether General Michael Flynn actually lied to the FBI agents — including the now infamous Peter Strzok — when they interviewed him in the White House on his third day on the job as national security ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Who’s in Charge Here?

In the run-up to the 2016 presidential election, Donald Trump was asked on many occasions whether he would “accept the results” of the election if he were to lose. Democrats and their media allies demanded that he make a solemn vow to “accept the results.” It was never entirely clear what anybody thought ... Read More