The Corner

Privatizing Marriage

A law professor named Colin P.A. Jones published an article in the San Francisco Chronicle on January 22 called, “Marriage proposal: Why not privatize?” It is extraordinary. Libertarians and radical feminists often call for privatizing marriage. (See, for example, Michael Kinsley’s “Abolish Marriage.”) Rarely does anyone come up with a concrete plan to do so. Jones has a concrete plan alright.

Jones treats his privatization scheme as a way to preserve marriage. It looks to me like the effective end of marriage as an institution capable of protecting children. But by all means, see what you think of this real-life plan to privatize marriage. Certainly this scheme amounts to a de facto legalization of polygamy and polyamory. Fans of polyamory have long advocated corporate law as a way to accommodate the complexities of multi-partner unions. And this is exactly the approach Jones takes. Incest prohibitions don’t seem to survive in this scheme. In “Rick Santorum Was Right” I wrote about a pro-polyamory law professor who envisions a world with separate social clubs for polyamorists and monogamists. Jones shows how exactly that would flow from privatization.

One of the remarkable things about this article is the way it confirms so many points made by critics of same-sex marriage. For example, Jones agrees that the presumption of reproduction is a key feature of marriage as we know it, even if every marriage is not reproductive. Jones’ acknowledgment that a presumption of reproduction is a key feature of the current system is the key to some of his most radical proposals. Other than the acknowledgment that marriage does now presume potential reproduction, there is virtually nothing in here about children. Jones seems to treat marriage as something chiefly designed for the needs of adults.

In “Beyond Gay Marriage,”

I suggested that we might someday see heterosexual couples contract same-sex “marriages of convenience” solely to secure benefits like medical insurance. Jones says he has a heterosexual friend in Massachusetts contemplating just such a union, and he builds this possibility into his system.

Most remarkable of all, Jones is ultimately forced to put the government back into marriage. Although he says that he is trying to solve the controversy over same-sex marriage, in the end government still has to decide what sort of private unions merit benefits. So under this privatization scheme, we not only dissolve marriage as any sort of workable or effective social institution, we also get the same quarrels over social recognition that we got before privatization. What a solution! No doubt there are libertarians out there who will love this scheme. Yet to me, this proposal shows the disaster that privatization would actually be. I hope that when folks talk about privatizing marriage, they keep concrete proposals like this in mind. Apparently, a more detailed version of this scheme is going to be published in the Independent Review.

Consider that we are getting radical proposals like this even now. If same-sex marriage becomes legal, this sort of idea will be floated on a regular basis. I can see someone believing that the slope might not ultimately slip, but I can’t see how folks can dismiss it even as a possibility. That same-sex marriage will, at minimum, lead to long and bitter debates over radical proposals such as this seems beyond doubt. It is already happening.

Stanley Kurtz is a senior fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center.

Most Popular

World

How to Make China Pay

One of the big questions facing the international community today is how to hold China legally and politically accountable for all its dishonesty and harm to people around the world. According to reports, U.S. intelligence agencies have confirmed to the White House that China has deliberately understated the ... Read More
World

How to Make China Pay

One of the big questions facing the international community today is how to hold China legally and politically accountable for all its dishonesty and harm to people around the world. According to reports, U.S. intelligence agencies have confirmed to the White House that China has deliberately understated the ... Read More

The Trail Leading Back to the Wuhan Labs

It is understandable that many would be wary of the notion that the origin of the coronavirus could be discovered by some documentary filmmaker who used to live in China. Matthew Tye, who creates YouTube videos, contends he has identified the source of the coronavirus — and a great deal of the information that ... Read More

The Trail Leading Back to the Wuhan Labs

It is understandable that many would be wary of the notion that the origin of the coronavirus could be discovered by some documentary filmmaker who used to live in China. Matthew Tye, who creates YouTube videos, contends he has identified the source of the coronavirus — and a great deal of the information that ... Read More
World

WHO Failed

Since its inception 72 years ago almost to the day, the World Health Organization (WHO)  has been credited with the eradication of smallpox and the near eradication of other devastating illnesses, including leprosy and river blindness. This record of success makes the current corruption of the organization ... Read More
World

WHO Failed

Since its inception 72 years ago almost to the day, the World Health Organization (WHO)  has been credited with the eradication of smallpox and the near eradication of other devastating illnesses, including leprosy and river blindness. This record of success makes the current corruption of the organization ... Read More

The Eeyore Syndrome

In A. A. Milne's classic Winne-the-Pooh children’s tales, Eeyore, the old gray donkey, is perennially pessimistic and gloomy. He always expects the worst to happen. Milne understood that Eeyore’s outbursts of depression could at first be salutatory but then become monotonous. The outlook of the pessimist ... Read More

The Eeyore Syndrome

In A. A. Milne's classic Winne-the-Pooh children’s tales, Eeyore, the old gray donkey, is perennially pessimistic and gloomy. He always expects the worst to happen. Milne understood that Eeyore’s outbursts of depression could at first be salutatory but then become monotonous. The outlook of the pessimist ... Read More