The Corner

Re: Immigration and Wages

Douglas Holtz-Eakin mentions that Sen. Sessions has expressed concern about the impact of the immigration bill on the “working class,” and then responds in terms of national aggregates and the “middle class.” I suspect that what Senator Sessions has in mind is the impact on current legal residents of this country on the low end of the income scale. The CBO report does not attempt to estimate what impact the bill will have on their wages, although it does say that wage pressure from the bill will be concentrated at the low and high ends of the scale.

CBO did attempt to make an estimate during the 2006 version of this debate. Its conclusion:

the analysis suggests that the average weekly wages of workers [already in the U.S.] who had not completed high school (about 12 percent of all adults employed last year) would be about 4 percent lower, while the average wages of workers with at least a high school education would be about 0.4 percent lower. With complete adjustment by capital, there would be no impact on overall wages; the average wages of workers without a high school diploma would be lower; those of other workers would be higher.

That estimate may be wrong or outdated, of course, but at least it is actually relevant to what opponents of the legislation Holtz-Eakin calls “reform” are worried about.

P.S. Holtz-Eakin writes, ”In a globalized economy, labor competition is already fierce; it doesn’t change a thing when a worker moves across the street, state, or even the sea. One would expect the impact to be essentially zero.” What about services?

Ramesh Ponnuru — Ramesh Ponnuru is a senior editor for National Review, a columnist for Bloomberg Opinion, a visiting fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, and a senior fellow at the National Review Institute.

Most Popular


G-File Mailbag: The Results of a Bad Idea

EDITOR’S NOTE: The following is Jonah Goldberg’s weekly “news”letter, the G-File. Subscribe here to get the G-File delivered to your inbox on Fridays. Dear Reader (Including those of you just standing there eating Zarg nuts), I had a bad idea. It wasn’t a terrible idea, like asking a meth addict ... Read More
Politics & Policy

How Democrats Can Blow It in 2020

Donald Trump probably can’t win the 2020 presidential election, but the Democrats can lose it. What I mean is that in a contest between Trump and a generic Democrat, Trump would almost surely lose if the current political climate holds through 2020. According to a Fox News poll this week, 38 percent of ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The Collusion Scenario

It has become an article of faith in some quarters on the right -- well, most -- that the Mueller investigation has found no evidence of collusion with Russia and has accordingly shifted gears to process crimes like lying to the FBI or obstruction of justice. Having decided that this must be true, many have ... Read More

Democrats’ Border-Barrier Flip-Flop

Is steel more moral than concrete? House Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi of California said last week that she and other Democrats consider a border wall “immoral.” But some of the same Democrats who decry President Donald J. Trump’s proposed concrete wall as a 30-foot-tall human-rights violation actually ... Read More