The Corner

Re: My First Question

Not so fast Ramesh. I asked: “Other than the unfairness of validating the efforts of the lawbreakers, is there a conservative public policy objection I am missing to creating a guest worker program?”

Your answer, it seems to me, is based entirely on political and pragmatic grounds. Fair enough. But that’s not really what I asked, or intended to ask.

Moreover, in almost all of your posts you use the word “amnesty” as a stand-in for “Bush’s plan.” The premise of my question was that we take Bush & Co. at their word that this is not an amnesty but a guest-worker program.

Indeed, you yourself have intimated — as have others — that amnesty is unpopular with almost everybody, including Hispanics. So maybe the Bushies don’t actually think this is an amnesty? Maybe they’re sincere, believing that allowing people to work here legally for a while and then requiring them to leave is a fair compromise. Maybe, they think that’s a way to win some of those anti-amnesty Hispanic votes I keep hearing are out there while at the same time seeming “compassionate” and level-headed on the issue? You steal a base, it seems to me, when you say “If amnesty is the way [to win votes] why should we expect deportation to be doable?” while so many of Bush’s immigration opponents have been saying that amnesty is in fact not the way to win votes. So if it’s not the way to win votes, maybe Karl Rove actually knows that — which is why he came up with a guest-worker program instead?

Second, I probably made a mistake raising the possibility of Bush’s proposal making guest workers (formerly illegal immigrants) easier to find. It really isn’t relevant to my question. But let’s concede that it certainly wouldn’t make the guest workers harder to find.

So again, as a matter of public policy, what’s wrong with a guest worker program that actually does what it’s supposed to do: Allow immigrants in to work and then sends them packing when they’re done.

Most Popular


If Amy Wax Is Wrong, Let’s See the Data

Regarding the kerfuffle Jason Richwine addressed here earlier, the economist Glenn Loury has posted an impassioned plea to his Facebook page. Loury, you may recall, hosts the video blog where Wax made her controversial claim that black students at Penn Law School rarely graduate in the top half of the ... Read More
Politics & Policy

San Francisco Bans Fur Sales

San Francisco has banned the sale of fur. From the CBS-SF story: San Francisco has become the first major U.S. city to ban the sale of fur clothing and products. Tuesday, the Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a measure that prohibits the sale of fur clothes, accessories, even souvenirs in stores and ... Read More

For the First Time in Weeks, Relief Sweeps over Austin

Making the click-through worthwhile: The Austin bomber is done in by one of his own devices; some new numbers suggest that a small but significant portion of Trump voters are tiring of the chaos and aren’t showing up to support other Republicans in 2018; and the mixed news for conservatives coming out of the ... Read More

The Baleful Effect of #MeToo on Campus

Remember the series of hurricanes that pounded the Caribbean last summer? Something like that has been occurring on college campuses, as they're hit by one destructive mania after another: diversity, Title IX, anti-speech protests. Now it's the #MeToo Movement. In this Martin Center article, British academic ... Read More
Politics & Policy

A Time for Choosing

This year’s Conservative Political Action Conference was controversial. Invitations to European nationalist populists such as Nigel Farage and Marion Maréchal-Le Pen (the niece of Marine Le Pen) caused many longtime conservatives to question whether they still belong to the conservative movement. Vocal critics ... Read More