The Corner

Re: Reason, Religion, & Natural Selection

Peter: Well, I read Wieseltier’s review of Daniel Dennett’s book (which I have not read), and it left me thinking what I always end up thinking after reading Wieseltier’s pieces: That the man is a bag of wind, who understands squat about science.

His argument is a strong form of the reification of reason–unusual for someone from a Jewish background, as one more often encounters this from Catholic intellectuals. It leaks like a sieve. If natural selection could come up with legs, fins, eyes, and guts, it’s hard to see why it shouldn’t come up with advanced intellectual faculties like reason. To say: “Well, it couldn’t have, because look, we’re reasoning about it!” is just fatuous.

That’s not to say we know reason did emerge from natural selection. We don’t know that, and Dennett’s certitudes are, in my opinion, misplaced. Dennett has a nice little gig going as a polemical God-basher, and he’s mining it for all it’s worth. Good luck to him. He treats lots of open questions as closed, though, which is not honest. Did Something predate matter? And is reason an attribute of, or derived from, that Something? These seem to me like open questions, not unconnected to the one posed by Martin Gardner: Back in the Jurassic, when two dinosaurs wandered down to the water hole and met two other dinosaurs drinking there, were there then four dinosaurs at the water hole? But Wieseltier isn’t engaging with that stuff, he’s just an Eng Lit blowhard gassing off.

If you want to read something REALLY thought-provoking about science and religion, try this (which is also a chapter in this).

Most Popular

PC Culture

America Is Intolerably Intolerant

When you think of the sheer vindictiveness of what happened to Oklahoma quarterback Kyler Murray, it takes your breath away. On the very night of his greatest career triumph, a reporter dug up his old tweets (composed when he was a young teenager), reported on the most offensive insults, and immediately and ... Read More
Film & TV

The Mob Gets Kevin Hart

This week, shortly after being tapped to host the Oscars, Hollywood star Kevin Hart found himself on the wrong side of the woke social-justice warriors. His great sin: Years ago, he tweeted jokes referencing homosexuality. More egregiously, in 2010, he did a comedy bit in which he discussed not wanting his son, ... Read More
Film & TV

Clint Eastwood’s Unforgettable Curtain Call

At 88, Clint Eastwood seldom appears on screen anymore and last acted in a movie in 2012’s mediocre Trouble with the Curve. So the final images of The Mule may be the last we see of him at the movies. If so, what an exit: understated perfection, with a playful hint of subverting his screen image. The Mule is ... Read More