The Corner

Re: Thomas & Scalia

I generally concur with Andrew, with a few caveats or clarifications. I generally see both Thomas and Scalia as textualists first, and then proponents of original meaning (as opposed to original intent) second. Thomas is certainly less wedded to precedent than Scalia, and is more willing to apply abstract principles where a clear, easy-to-apply rule of decision is absent. Thus, for example, Thomas is likely to be more open to arguments seeking to revive the protection of economic liberty or non-delegation doctrine than Scalia. For Thomas, this could be required by the text. For Scalia, this is simply an opportunity for judicial mischief. (Think Judge Bork’s dismissal of the Ninth Amendment as an “inkblot.”)

I also think Baude’s statement that “Thomas . . . sees himself as a staunch defender of the classically liberal vision of the country’s founders” is defensible. Thomas is much more willing than Scalia to appeal to the principles of the Declaration of Independence, particularly on quetions of race. As I understand it, Thomas was heavily influenced by Harry Jaffa and others who see the Reconstruction Amendments as the perfection of the Constitutional project insofar as they realized the founding principles that all men are created equal and endowed with natural rights. This is not simply an abstract proposition to Thomas, but a constitutional principle that can be applied in proper cases. For more, see Thomas’ speech to the Claremont Institute’s 1999 Lincoln Day dinner.

Jonathan H. Adler — Jonathan H. Adler is the Johan Verhiej Memorial Professor of Law and Director of the Center for Business Law and Regulation at the Case Western Reserve University School of Law.

Most Popular

U.S.

The Inquisitor Has No Clothes

This is a column about impeachment, but first, a confession: I think I might be guilty of insider trading. At this point, I would like to assure my dear friends at the SEC that I do not mean this in any actionable legal sense, but only in principle. Some time ago, I was considering making an investment in a ... Read More
U.S.

The Present American Revolution

The revolution of 1776 sought to turn a colony of Great Britain into a new independent republic based on constitutionally protected freedom. It succeeded with the creation of the United States. The failed revolution of 1861, by a slave-owning South declaring its independence from the Union, sought to bifurcate ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Shaming Women Who Vote Right

Some progressives have decided that rather than convincing women that their candidates and policy proposals are better than those of conservatives, they will shame women who fail to vote for the Left by defining them all as racist and self-loathing tools of the patriarchy. Think I’m exaggerating? See this ... Read More