Jonah, I’m not religious enough to be an atheist, so I have no no-God in this fight, but I was a little surprised by Ed Feser’s comments. I want to be careful about what I say about them because you may well have only have extracted a small part of what he wrote to you. Equally I see he’s written a book that, I presume, covers this ground in much more detail. Nevertheless the comments you have posted contain, so far as I can see, absolutely nothing by way of argument, but a great deal of assertion. Come to think of it, that approach sounds a little familiar . . .