I didn’t like the speech for many of the reasons that have been outlined already in this space. Here’s the real test, though: Is Gen. McChrystal in Kabul regretting that Obama didn’t strike a more Churchillian tone, or is he very glad to have the troops and the time–at least 18 months before the start of any draw down–to try to turn around the war? Surely, it’s the latter. I went back and looked at Bush’s speech announcing the surge. It holds up very well. It’s prescient even. But at the time, as a piece of rhetoric, it didn’t matter too much because basically no one was listening to Bush any more. It wasn’t the words that saved the war, it was the incredibly courageous troops who went–finally, in sufficient numbers and with the proper strategic goal–into Baghdad neighborhoods and cleared out al Qaeda and the Shia militias. Those troops changed the dynamic of the war on the ground, and nothing else was as important. Yes, the Petraeus testimony made a difference, but it was only persuasive to the extent he had the actual progress to talk about and he was perhaps even more restrained than Obama tonight when he made the case for the war. Likewise, the Afghan war will be won or lost on the ground and Obama has given McChrystal the basic tools he needs. About that we should be very glad.
There was a low bar for Joe Biden in the first debate, given his cognitive challenges. Because he exceeded that pessimism, he won momentum. In opposite fashion, there was similarly an expectation that a disruptive Donald Trump would turn off the audience by the sort of interruptions and bullying that ... Read More
Editor’s Note: The following essay was adapted from remarks delivered to the annual dinner of the Lincoln Club of Orange County, in California, on October 4. Every American heart must break when lies are told to boys and girls, who then grow up to think the worst about their past: that the American ... Read More
Senators Susan Collins (R., Maine.) and Lisa Murkowski (R., Alaska) voted on Friday against moving the Senate into an executive session to allow McConnell to expedite the final confirmation vote that is expected to seat Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court. The Senate ended up approving the move to ... Read More
‘You have been identified by our group as being a Trump supporter.” Thus begins the text of threatening letters recently sent to homeowners with Trump yard signs in New Hampshire. The letters continue, “We recommend that you check your home insurance policy and make [sure] that it is current and that it ... Read More
Republican Senator Lisa Murkowski expressed concern Tuesday with Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell's promise of “total coordination” with the White House on the Senate's impeachment trial strategy. “In fairness, when I heard that I was disturbed,” the Alaska Republican told Anchorage’s NBC ... Read More