The Corner

Politics & Policy

UN Committee Tries to Save ‘French Terri Schiavo’

Terri Schiavo with her mother Mary Schindler in 2001. (Handout via Reuters)

Vincent Lambert was catastrophically injured in an automobile accident in France in 2008. He has been diagnosed as in a persistent unconscious condition. But he apparently only requires tube feeding to maintain life — and according to European Center for Law and Justice, has regained his swallow reflex.

A family is deeply divided about whether to pull his feeding tube so he dehydrates to death. His wife and siblings want all sustenance stopped, which means he will die slowly over 14 days. His parents and half siblings want it continued.

Sound familiar? Yes, the facts and resulting bitterness are very similar to the Terri Schaivo imbroglio that tore our country apart more than a decade ago.

The French and EU courts have ruled that the feeding tube can be pulled. But the Committee on the Rights the Rights of Persons with Disabilities at the United Nations has intervened, and demanded that the dehydration be delayed pending its further study. From the European Center’s report about the case:

It is not one but two decisions that have already been taken by the Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) regarding the Lambert case: firstly they registered the application lodged by the parents of Vincent Lambert and secondly they requested interim measures.

The request was first examined by the Secretary-General of the CRPD which considered that it fulfilled the “preliminary criteria” of admissibility and consequently registered and communicated it to the French Government (Article 56 of the Rules of procedure of the Committee). This is a first step that already shows that the request is well formulated and falls within the scope of the Committee.

The French Government now has six months to answer the charges against the French medical and judicial decisions, both on the admissibility and the merits of the request.

France ratified the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Lambert’s legal representative claim that means the dehydration must be delayed pending further proceedings by the Committee. France’s Health Minister said the country is not legally bound to comply but that there would be an official response.

I don’t know the legalities here, but my sympathies are with the parents. There is no question that — just like Terri Schiavo — the pulling of the feeding tube will lead to a slow and cruel death by dehydration. That’s the point of pulling the tube!

The media have called this a right to die case. I think of it actually as a no right to live case. Lambert wouldn’t be considered an end of life circumstance but for the plan to withdraw all food and fluids.

The European Center calls the action euthanasia. Technically and legally, it is removing medical treatment. But in food and fluids cases such as this, that distinction sure seems blurry as — in contrast to, say, withdrawing breathing assistance or antibiotics — there can only be one outcome!

If a convicted mass murderer was denied sustenance onto death as a means of execution, people would rightfully be up in arms. That so many of the population support taking the medically unnecessary act of dehydrating people with profound cognitive disabilities to death, illustrates precisely why the Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities recognized the need to intervene.

Most Popular

U.S.

A Look at the Reinfection Rate

On the menu today: unraveling those ominous claims that people can get reinfected with the coronavirus merely weeks or months after they think they’ve beaten it; the governor of Mississippi explains why he doesn’t think “herd immunity” is a realistic option, while some New York neighborhoods offer some ... Read More
U.S.

A Look at the Reinfection Rate

On the menu today: unraveling those ominous claims that people can get reinfected with the coronavirus merely weeks or months after they think they’ve beaten it; the governor of Mississippi explains why he doesn’t think “herd immunity” is a realistic option, while some New York neighborhoods offer some ... Read More
White House

Don’t Blame Fauci

The president’s relationship with Anthony Fauci, who directs the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases and has played a very public role in the country’s COVID-19 response, has gotten especially rocky. Fauci has expressed concerns about reopening and bluntly contradicted some of the ... Read More
White House

Don’t Blame Fauci

The president’s relationship with Anthony Fauci, who directs the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases and has played a very public role in the country’s COVID-19 response, has gotten especially rocky. Fauci has expressed concerns about reopening and bluntly contradicted some of the ... Read More
Media

Bari Weiss and the Malignancy at the New York Times

Bari Weiss resigned today from the New York Times, five weeks after the Times essentially forced out editorial page editor James Bennet for publishing an op-ed by Senator Tom Cotton. Bennet had hired Weiss, and his departure for allowing a U.S. Senator to advocate the use of longstanding presidential powers was a ... Read More
Media

Bari Weiss and the Malignancy at the New York Times

Bari Weiss resigned today from the New York Times, five weeks after the Times essentially forced out editorial page editor James Bennet for publishing an op-ed by Senator Tom Cotton. Bennet had hired Weiss, and his departure for allowing a U.S. Senator to advocate the use of longstanding presidential powers was a ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The Wrong Governors

Pretend for a moment that you are a journalist with a strong leaning in favor of progressivism and the Democratic Party, and you wish to make the argument that Democratic governors are doing a great job of mitigating the spread of the coronavirus. If you use the measuring stick of fewest cases per million ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The Wrong Governors

Pretend for a moment that you are a journalist with a strong leaning in favor of progressivism and the Democratic Party, and you wish to make the argument that Democratic governors are doing a great job of mitigating the spread of the coronavirus. If you use the measuring stick of fewest cases per million ... Read More