The Corner

Law & the Courts

Update on Alfie Evans

Thomas Evans, father of Alfie Evans, attends Pope Francis’ Wednesday general audience in Saint Peter’s square at the Vatican, April 18, 2018. REUTERS/Max Rossi (Max Rossi/Reuters)

In the few hours since I sent in the piece below, a remarkable succession of events has occurred that paint the decision of the UK authorities in ever-bleaker colors. In the hospital, Alfie was removed from the respirator in accordance with the court’s decision. For the moment, however, he has continued breathing. He is under police guard to ensure that no one interferes with the process by, one supposes, supplying him with oxygen. This precaution is necessary because a crowd of sympathizers outside tried to break into the hospital but were held back by other police.

At this point, the controversy over Alfie is an international one. Alfie’s parents sought help from the pope, who appealed for solidarity with them, and they have arranged for a Rome hospital to receive Alfie and resume palliative care. And this evening, the Italian government unexpectedly intervened. Its foreign and interior ministers are reported to have extended Italian citizenship to Alfie with the intention of asking the British government to allow this new citizen to be repatriated to Italy for this treatment. A judge is said to be examining their unusual request that pits government against government in a struggle over whether or not to prolong the life of a dying child. It is like the closing sequence of a suspense thriller in which the Italian diplomats struggle to rescue the child before the police and the hospital succeed in protecting his slow inevitable extinction.

In a movie, Alfie would survive in the last final scene. It’s hard to believe that he will do so in life. We can understand the quite simple emotions that move Alfie’s parents, the crowds of sympathizers, and the Italian diplomats and their voters. But how are we to interpret the official UK decisions? It seems to me (partly on the basis of earlier such conflicts) that all involved will believe passionately that they are doing the right thing. But something else has taken over their thoughts and action: They are now determined to defend their claim to be Alfie’s real parents and their compassionate administration of his inevitable death without pain — against what they see as the primitive sentimentality of those trying to rescue him. They grit their teeth and get on with it, maybe feeling a little noble about it all. And they don’t realize that they are moving by baby steps towards the compulsory euthanasia of the weak and sick.

Most Popular

U.S.

Americans Are Royally Confused about Monarchy

Conventional wisdom regarding America’s relationship with royalty goes something like this: Americans have no time for monarchy as a political concept but can’t get enough of the British royal family. The American media’s round-the-clock coverage of the recent royal wedding certainly seems ample evidence of ... Read More
Elections

The Trump Rationale

Why exactly did nearly half the country vote for Donald Trump? Why also did the arguments of Never Trump Republicans and conservatives have marginal effect on voters? Despite vehement denunciations of the Trump candidacy from many pundits on the right and in the media, Trump nonetheless got about the same ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The Collapse of the Collusion Narrative

It is now clear that Russian attempts at interference in the 2016 election, though somewhat outrageous, were ineffectual, unconnected with any particular party, a small effort given what a country of Russia’s resources and taste for political skullduggery and chicanery is capable of, and minor compared with the ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Trump’s Superpower

President Trump has a magic power. No, it isn’t the ability to engage in four-dimensional chess, or even to mystically connect with the “common man.” It’s simply this: He can make Democrats defend anything. Democrats have increasingly defined themselves by opposing anything Trump does. Trump, unlike ... Read More