Human Exceptionalism

The Deprofessionalization of Medicine

The alarming trend to deprofessionalize medicine continues apace.

Doctors are becoming less physicians and more “service providers.” Patients are now akin to customers. In Canada, this may soon require doctors to kill certain patients on demand.

This has many societal ramifications, brought up in a very good column in the LA Times about a controversy about a Catholic hospital refusing to sterilize a woman because it violates Catholic medical ethics. From, “Why a Catholic Hospital Shouldn’t be Obliged to do a Tubal Ligation,” by Fordham University bioethics professor, Charles A. Camosy:

When healthcare providers are forced by law to violate the values that make them who they are — because of the request of customers demanding goods and services in the free market — it signals the end of medicine as a professional practice.

It makes medicine just another exchange of goods and services, and puts patients in the role of customers, ordering whatever they want from physicians. In such a world, an orthopedic surgeon would be forced to cut off a patient’s perfectly healthy leg rather than insisting that his bodily integrity identity disorder be treated instead. Someone with only months to live could order a knee replacement. And nothing could stop those who are merely “tired of life” from demanding a prescription for a deadly dose of medication.

As I have been warning about for years, that is exactly where we are heading. 

The jurisdiction of healthcare is expanding from purely medical issues to what I call “consumerist” services, e.g., procedures using medical means for a not strictly medical purpose,such as to fulfill lifestyle desires or enhance happiness.

But Wesley, you oppose Futile Care Theory that allows doctors to refuse wanted life-sustaining treatment. Isn’t that deprofessionalization too?

No. Life sustaining treatment–keeping a patient alive when that is what she wants–is purely medical. It is not elective, but necessary to sustain life. (Hit this link for more details of the circumstances in which I think doctors should–and should not–be allowed to say, “no.”)

Camosy makes a strong appeal to allow Catholic hospitals to be Catholic:

If that [the above quote] sounds wrong to you, then you have to say there is no justification for refusing healthcare providers — including Catholic hospitals — the freedom as professionals to determine their own answers to these vexing questions.

If instead we single out religious hospitals and deny them this freedom, it would reveal that a very serious kind of discrimination is present in our culture. And it is the kind of discrimination that not only reveals contempt for the 1st Amendment, but also for the right of all to define and express their identity.

Here’s the thing. The secularists don’t think it is wrong to force doctors to participate in life-taking or religiously proscribed procedures.

They want to force their utilitarian values on all of healthcare–which is one purpose to which Obamacare is being put.

It is all part of the project to reduce the free exercise of religion it mere freedom of worship.

Most Popular

Books

The Maker of Middle-earth, in Gorgeous Detail

Oxford, England — After five months of ferocious and futile slaughter in “the Great War,” an Oxford undergraduate — knowing his deployment to the Western Front was inevitable — used his Christmas break in 1914 to cultivate his imagination. Twenty-two-year-old J. R. R. Tolkien began writing “The Story ... Read More
Culture

Road Trip

EDITOR’S NOTE: The following is Jonah Goldberg’s weekly “news”letter, the G-File. Subscribe here to get the G-File delivered to your inbox on Fridays. Dear Reader (Especially future contributors to my GoFundMe page), I am currently in the passenger seat of our family fun mobile, passing mile marker ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Answering my Critics

My post on Elizabeth Warren’s cynical/bonkers proposal to effectively nationalize every American firm with revenue of $1 billion or more has met with predictable criticism. I will address two points here. One, some have complained about the use of the word “expropriation,” or more broadly about ... Read More