Magazine February 22, 2010, Issue

Senator Tea Party

(Roman Genn)
In Jim DeMint of South Carolina, the conservative resurgence finds an ally

Jim DeMint wasn’t looking forward to his conversation with Arlen Specter last spring, but he didn’t want to avoid his Senate colleague, either. The Republican from South Carolina had decided to endorse Pat Toomey, who had launched a GOP primary bid against Specter in Pennsylvania. “I wanted to tell Arlen face to face, before it became public,” says DeMint.

On April 23, in a room just off the floor of the Senate, DeMint approached Specter and let him know. “I was going to explain my reasoning,” says DeMint, but Specter cut him off. “I’ve heard enough,” he muttered, and walked away. Five days later, Specter abandoned the GOP itself. He became a Democrat.

“I’m not going to take credit or blame for that,” says DeMint today. “I think he had already made up his mind to switch.” Even so, plenty of Republicans seemed eager to denounce behavior such as DeMint’s for shrinking the party. “Some conservatives would rather lose than be seen as compromising on what they regard as in­violable principles,” grumbled Texas senator John Cornyn, who heads the National Repub­lican Senatorial Committee (NRSC). Sen. Olympia Snowe of Maine contributed an op-ed to the New York Times. GOP moderates, she warned, “often get the distinct feeling that [they’re] no longer welcome in the tribe.” Even DeMint’s fellow travelers at the editorial page of the Wall Street Journal piled on: “Republicans shouldn’t follow South Carolina Senator Jim DeMint and welcome Mr. Specter’s defection as an ideological cleansing.”

If DeMint once looked like a crotchety conservative who was satisfied to serve in a dwindling and disgruntled minority, he now appears more like the prophet of a coming resurgence. Until recently, many Republicans would have been content to pick up a mere handful of Senate seats in the midterm elections this year. With Scott Brown’s startling special-election victory in Massachusetts, however, there’s talk of sweeping gains not just for the GOP in general, but specifically for the conservatives within it.

Even if Republicans don’t take control of the chamber — a hard task, even in a favorable political environment — they could give Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and other Democrats a genuine scare. DeMint’s particular gamble in Pennsylvania may pay off handsomely: In January, a Rasmussen poll of likely voters showed that Toomey has surged from underdog to favorite. He leads Specter by nine points and Specter’s Democratic primary opponent, Rep. Joe Sestak, by eight points.

“This is part of an American awakening,” says DeMint. “If people want to take back their government, they can do it. No state is out of play.” DeMint is now positioning himself as the Great Awakener — a national leader of a highly decentralized tea-party movement whose activist energy may hold the key to turning 2010 into another 1994 for the GOP.

The 58-year-old DeMint grew up in Greenville, S.C., with a single mother who operated the DeMint Aca­demy of Dance and Decorum in their house. When one of her students lacked a partner, his mother would ring a bell. This was to summon DeMint, who would have to fill in, even if it meant dancing with a man. “Scarred me for life,” he jokes. Later, DeMint became the drummer for a rock-and-roll cover band called Salt & Pepper, so named because half of its members were white and half were black — a bit of integration in a South Carolina that was still escaping the legacy of Jim Crow. “I could have been a rock star, except I had no voice or talent,” says DeMint. He did, however, have a first-rate cackle: When his band performed the beach-rock classic “Wipe Out,” originally re­corded by the Surfaris, DeMint provided the wild laugh that kicks off the song.

DeMint earned degrees at the University of Tennessee and Clemson, joined an advertising company, and eventually founded his own marketing firm. He says he was too busy to think about politics — it rarely entered his mind. “I had kids and a business,” he says. “I didn’t even know who my congressman was.” Then, toward the end of the 1980s, he ran a focus group that asked the residents of a public-housing development to describe the challenges they faced. “One woman told us, ‘Stop paying our babies to have babies,’” he recalls. It dawned on him that many social ills were the unintended consequences of government policies.

A few years later, in 1992, Bob Inglis walked into his office. They didn’t know each other, but Inglis was thinking about running for Congress, and he sought DeMint’s advice. They struck up a friendship, and DeMint became an adviser. Inglis won and served three terms. When he stepped down in 1998, DeMint decided to pursue the vacant House seat. “I was 47 years old and I had never run for anything,” he says. (The memoir-like first chapter of his recently published book, Saving Freedom, is called “From Normal to Politician.”) During the GOP primary, he campaigned for abolishing the tax code, privatizing Social Security, and passing a right-to-life amendment. He finished second — and did well enough to force a runoff, which he won against a candidate who was seen as a favorite of religious conservatives.

#page#In the House, DeMint earned a reputation as a free trader, even though he hailed from a state whose representatives traditionally had pushed for textile protectionism. He says that his trade votes — for presidential trade-promotion authority and closer ties with China — were some of the most difficult he has cast. “Voters had a very negative perception of trade,” he says. “I took a lot of heat.” This regional apostasy earned him a primary challenger in 2002. DeMint survived that threat and made good on a promise to serve no more than three terms.

In 2004, he ran for the Senate. Once again, he finished second in the GOP primary, behind former governor David Beasley, and went on to win a runoff. Then he captured the seat that retiring Democrat Ernest Hollings had occupied for nearly four decades. This year, DeMint is running for re-election and does not appear to face serious opposition.

As a senator, DeMint has compiled one of the most conservative voting records in Washington. The American Conservative Union gives him a lifetime rating of 98.4 percent. No other sen­ator has a higher mark. In August, a reporter for the New York Times sneered at him as “a back-bencher with little influence in Washington’s corridors of power” — a sure sign that his influence was in fact growing. The criticism came in the wake of a mini-controversy in which DeMint demonstrated a knack for getting under the skin of Democrats, including President Obama.

Last summer, on a conference call with conservative activists, DeMint discussed ways to block the nationalization of health care. “If we’re able to stop Obama on this, it will be his Waterloo, it will break him,” he said. An audio clip of the comment became a sensation on left-wing blogs. The White House had a fit — or at least thought it had found a useful villain. Obama quoted the line in a speech and condemned it as an example of irresponsible Republican obstructionism. A few of DeMint’s colleagues suggested that he stick to a script that called for criticisms of congressional leaders such as Reid and Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, but not Obama, who at the time was seen as bulletproof. DeMint ignored their advice. “My point was that we could break his momentum, his rampaging agenda toward overspending and debt,” he says. “I wanted to stop the president so that he would work with us rather than steamroll us.”

The skirmish over this metaphor seems only to have energized the South Carolinian. On September 12, when a swarm of tea-party activists descended on Washington, DeMint was the only senator to address them. “Welcome to Waterloo!” he said to a cheering crowd. “We must stop this government takeover of health care.”

DeMint has opened other fronts in his fight against the Obama administration. One is in Honduras, where a constitutional crisis led the military to depose the president last summer. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton called it a “coup.” DeMint, who serves on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, wasn’t so sure. But he didn’t have any special expertise in Honduras or its laws. A member of his staff suggested that he contact a Honduran-American whom many conservatives in Washington already knew, at least by reputation: Miguel Estrada. President Bush had selected him for the federal bench in 2001, but Democrats filibustered his nomination. Estrada, a U.S. citizen, lived in Honduras until he was 17. Now a lawyer in private practice, he was following events in his native land closely.

DeMint and Estrada had not met previously, but soon Estrada found himself in the senator’s office. They pored over Honduran legal documents, which Estrada had located on government websites and translated. Estrada persuaded the senator that the Hondurans had ousted their president legally, in order to prevent a despotic power grab. “We did our homework,” says DeMint. Yet the Obama administration continued to criticize what had taken place. DeMint responded by blocking confirmation votes on a pair of nominees: Arturo Valenzuela for assistant secretary of state for Western-hemisphere relations and Thomas A. Shannon for ambassador to Brazil.

Then, in September, DeMint planned his own fact-finding mission to Honduras — only to find himself thwarted by Sen. John Kerry, the Massachusetts Democrat who heads the Foreign Relations Committee. Even though the committee’s Democrats had spent record amounts on their own international travel (according to a Boston Globe analysis), Kerry refused to release funds for DeMint’s trip. DeMint went anyway, under the auspi­ces of Senate minority leader Mitch McConnell, a Kentucky Republican. “When we got down there, it was obvious that this was no military coup,” says DeMint. “We didn’t see soldiers patrolling the presidential palace.” The spat with Kerry generated additional publicity for DeMint and his views on what was happening in Honduras.

#page#The story has a happy ending. Hillary Clinton and the State Department eventually came around, however grudgingly. DeMint let the votes on Valenzuela and Shannon go forward. Honduras held new elections in November and inaugurated a new president in January, with the approval of the U.S. government. “The senator kept the administration honest,” says Estrada. “He was invaluable.”

DeMint’s next dustup with the White House came in the aftermath of Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab’s failed attempt to blow up a Detroit-bound jetliner on Christmas. DeMint had prevented a vote on Erroll Southers, Obama’s nominee to head the Transportation Security Administration (TSA), on the grounds that Southers had refused to answer questions about plans to unionize airport screeners. After the bomb plot, liberals hoped DeMint would cave in to a public that demanded the swift confirmation of a TSA chief. DeMint went through another round of criticism from all of the usual sources — a New York Times editorial called his position “wrongheaded” and “destructive” — but he held firm. On January 20, Southers pulled his name from consideration.

This was the day after Brown’s victory in Massachusetts. If the timing wasn’t a sheer coincidence, it was an early indication of how much Washington’s political dynamics changed when the GOP cracked the Democrats’ 60-vote supermajority in the Senate. In the months ahead, DeMint probably will pick new battles with the Obama administration — but his greatest influence may come in shaping the course of the 2010 Senate elections. His objective is not merely to defeat Democrats, but to elect conservatives.

He’ll do it through the Senate Conservatives Fund (SCF), the political-action committee he founded in response to recent GOP failures. “I was one of the top fundraisers for the NRSC,” says DeMint. “But when I’d make phone calls, people kept telling me that they weren’t going to give another dime until Republicans started acting like Republicans.” DeMint figured they would give to conservatives, however, and he was right: In 2009, the SCF raised more than $1.3 million, which it is now directing toward conservatives within the Republican party, often to the consternation of the GOP’s Washington establishment.

The first sign of DeMint’s willingness to buck his more cautious colleagues came when he decided to support Toomey over Specter. A few weeks later, on the day the NRSC formally endorsed Florida governor Charlie Crist for his state’s Republican Senate nomination, DeMint met with Marco Rubio, who had already announced his candidacy. “When I heard Marco talk about his principles, it was clear to me that this was someone we would want here in the Senate,” says DeMint. Crist, by contrast, had warmly endorsed Obama’s stimulus spending and even hugged the president at a political rally. Rubio was little known, even though he had served as speaker of the house in Florida’s legislature. One survey showed him trailing Crist by 35 points. DeMint endorsed him anyway. “A lot of people thought I was crazy, but I may have caused others to give Marco a look,” he says. That’s exactly what happened. Rubio grabbed the spotlight in a primary contest that Crist thought he had locked up. Polls now show Rubio and his rival running neck and neck.

DeMint has ruffled feathers in two other campaigns. In Cali­fornia, he backs Chuck DeVore, a GOP state assemblyman, even though many Republicans have gotten behind former Hewlett-Packard CEO Carly Fiorina. (Former congressman Tom Camp­bell is also in the race.) In Texas, DeMint has called for the election of Michael Williams in the event that Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison, currently a candidate for governor, makes good on a promise to resign from her office. He’s searching for other opportunities as well. It’s possible to imagine the SCF backing insurgent Republicans in Colorado, Delaware, Kentucky, New Hampshire, and possibly elsewhere. “In November, the country will move back toward conservative principles,” says DeMint. “We don’t have to settle for milquetoast Republicans who don’t care about anything but getting elected — and we’ll be kicking ourselves if there are states in which we don’t run real conservatives.”

A year ago, Republicans were despondent about their electoral prospects. Last summer and fall, they turned hopeful. Now they’re bullish. If 2010 turns out to be the kind of year they currently anticipate, Jim DeMint and his conservative allies may enjoy the last laugh. Don’t be surprised if it sounds like the manic start to that song he used to play years ago — “Wipe Out.”

John J. Miller is the national correspondent for National Review and the director of the Dow Journalism Program at Hillsdale College. His new book is Reading Around: Journalism on Authors, Artists, and Ideas.

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

‘Not True’

From all of the uproar surrounding the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, you would think that an activist Court had excised the Bill of ...
Politics & Policy

Docs and Doctorates

A report from the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) lists 29 state studies that warn of looming physician shortages. Twenty-one specialty-specific studies and at least six national reports characterize ...
Politics & Policy

Professor of Contempt

With Howard Zinn, contemporary American academia found its court historian. Zinn, who died January 27 at 87, was like a gigantic echo chamber, accurately reproducing — and actively re­inforcing — ...


Politics & Policy

The Way of the Whigs?

Scott Brown’s improbable win in the Mas­sa­chu­setts Senate election is the latest and most dramatic evidence of the Republicans’ greatly improved electoral outlook. As polls have shown dissatisfaction with President ...
Politics & Policy

Fatted Leviathan

The collapse of the housing market has been an object lesson for America. Households and banks borrowed too much on expectations of continuing appreciation in real-estate prices. This extra borrowing ...
Politics & Policy

Senator Tea Party

Jim DeMint wasn’t looking forward to his conversation with Arlen Specter last spring, but he didn’t want to avoid his Senate colleague, either. The Republican from South Carolina had decided ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

Men of Letters

Dubious legend has it that the world’s first letter was written by Queen Atossa of Per­sia, daughter of Cyrus the Great, in the sixth century B.C. We do know that ...
Politics & Policy

Back to Basics

For many today, the American Revolution was primarily a mil­itary campaign. But the “real American Revolution,” John Adams insisted, “was in the minds and hearts of the people,” transforming their ...
Politics & Policy

Unhappy Returns

There’s a fine line between be­ing a crazy, paranoid, violence-obsessed genius, and just being plain old crazy. In the first half of the 2000s, Mel Gibson managed to stay (just ...
The Straggler

Second Childhood

‘All those years we thought we were building Com­mu­nism! Actually they’ve built Communism right here in the U.S.A.!” This gets the biggest laugh of the evening. All seven of us in ...


Politics & Policy


The Book of Heston In “The Week” of National Review’s February 8 edition, the editors write that “people came to think that foreign slaves built the pyramids” because they were “influenced ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ Air America has ceased operations: Talent on loan from God still trumps talent on loan from Al Franken. ‐ Scott Brown, a dodgy economy, deficits big as the Rockies: The ...
The Long View

From the Pelosi inbox . . .

TO: FROM: RE: I’m hungry Hey Dianne . . . Hate to bother you, but I’m sitting here in my office and suddenly craving something sweet. Can you handle this? Thnx . ...
Politics & Policy


AT THE RECEPTION Up there, the braids were dark and round. The skirt was slanting from the ground. So suavely rocked she, swift but still, Bride like a bell tower, like God’s will. How strangely ...
Happy Warrior


I’m not sure I’m the go-to guy for a disquisition on The Catcher in the Rye, but I confess I was always intrigued by the J. D. Salinger lifestyle, at ...

Most Popular


COVID’s Comeback

We’re living in Groundhog Day. For the second time this year, COVID-19 is sweeping the country and we don’t have any great options for dealing with it. We didn’t squander the past four months, exactly, but we demonstrably failed to get to a place where we can enjoy an open society without the virus taking ... Read More

COVID’s Comeback

We’re living in Groundhog Day. For the second time this year, COVID-19 is sweeping the country and we don’t have any great options for dealing with it. We didn’t squander the past four months, exactly, but we demonstrably failed to get to a place where we can enjoy an open society without the virus taking ... Read More

On the Letter

I thought it right to congratulate John MacArthur and Harper’s magazine on putting together an open letter in defense of intellectual liberty — including the liberty to make mistakes -- as a necessary component of social justice. And further congrats on assembling its broad church of signatories. MacArthur ... Read More

On the Letter

I thought it right to congratulate John MacArthur and Harper’s magazine on putting together an open letter in defense of intellectual liberty — including the liberty to make mistakes -- as a necessary component of social justice. And further congrats on assembling its broad church of signatories. MacArthur ... Read More