Magazine October 4, 2010, Issue

Film: Total Immersion

Violante Placido and George Clooney in The American (Giles Keyte)
A review of The American

At times, it can feel as though television’s auteurs are making the movie industry irrelevant. Fifty years after phrases like “idiot box” and “vast wasteland” entered the American vocabulary, the long arc of a TV serial has officially proven itself a better vehicle for conveying psychological depth and sociological complexity than the 100-odd minutes available for the typical feature film. And from The Sopranos and The Wire to Breaking Bad and Mad Men, our small-screen storytellers have been exploiting this advantage to the hilt, turning out human dramas that put most of their cinematic competitors to shame.

So why go to the movies at all, when you can sit home with HBO and AMC, Netflix and iTunes, and experience the closest imitation of a great novel’s richness that visual culture can offer? Well, there’s spectacle, of course: that James Cameron rush, that Michael Bay high. But there’s also immersion: the sense of being surrounded and enveloped, sealed away completely from the real world, seeing only what the director intends for you to see. For all of television’s dramatic potential — and yes, for all the advances in flat-screen technology and surround sound as well — this is still something that rarely happens in your living room. It takes a movie theater, and it takes a movie maker.

Anton Corbijn, the Dutch-born director of The American, is such a man. A former photographer and music-video director (his debut film, Control, elegized the suicidal Joy Division frontman Ian Curtis), Corbijn’s first mainstream effort is a thriller in which very little happens, starring a movie star, George Clooney, who is never once allowed to bare his famous smile. This is a way of saying that The American is a very European film: It’s set in Sweden and Italy, features a great deal of nudity and characters with names like Pavel and Mathilde, and bathes the audience in a distinctively Continental mix of paranoia and ennui.

Clooney plays an aging hit man (he goes by “Jack” and sometimes “Edward”) who holes up in a Tuscan hill town after a snowbound shootout with unnamed Swedes, waiting for the coast to clear. His handler, the aforementioned Pavel (Johan Leysen, with a face like the Badlands), eventually gives him an assignment: He’s to build a gun for another assassin, a mysterious woman who needs a potent, quiet rifle for an undisclosed job. In between mechanical improvisations, Clooney’s character finds time to have pregnant conversations with a wise old priest (Paolo Bonacelli) and tender sex with a gorgeous prostitute played by Violante Placido. (If Placido looks familiar, it’s because her equally lovely mother played Michael Corleone’s doomed Italian bride in The Godfather.) And then he waits, and waits, for his enemies to find him, and for the film’s slowly built suspense to finally spend itself in violence.

#page#The American is not, by any stretch of the imagination, a perfect film. It’s pretentious and predictable, using narrative reticence (who is our hero? who are his enemies? who knows?) to disguise the slightness of its story. The lead role is a variation on the conflicted fixer Clooney played, to good effect, in Michael Clayton, but there his charisma was allowed freer rein, whereas here he looks too often like a repressed suburban father mourning a beloved pet. And if the plot sounds hackneyed, well, that’s because it is. The script is self-aware, at least, about the debt it owes to a hundred aging-gunslinger films before it: At one point, Clooney’s character wanders into a bar playing spaghetti Westerns on its television, and there on the screen, dubbed into Italian, is Clint Eastwood’s original Man With No Name. But its self-awareness doesn’t make it any less derivative. If you’ve seen those movies, then you know how this one goes. (Clooney’s character falls hard for the prostitute, decides that the current job will be his last, and so on down the checklist.)

But Corbijn knows what the movies are good for, and that knowledge covers a multitude of weaknesses. They’re good for conveying a mood, an atmosphere — twilit, existential, with occasional flashes of revelatory beauty. They’re good for intertwining dread with frustrated anticipation — for discovering the menace in an empty town square, the danger lurking in a flowered hillside, and then denying the audience the satisfaction of seeing that menace translated into actual violence. And they’re good for finally, finally giving the viewer that release, suddenly and almost ecstatically, in a choreographed burst of movement and gunfire, gunfire and movement, that makes all the waiting feel worthwhile.

Above all, they’re good for giving the world the big-screen close-up it deserves. This can mean the mazed streets of an Italian hill town, or the snowbound stillness of a Scandinavian lakeside. It can mean the interlocking gears of a high-powered rifle, the crags and jowls of old men, the life-changing smile of a beautiful woman. It can mean anything and everything that a skilled filmmaker wants his audience to see. And that skill can be enough, even in a film where the substance is unequal to the style, to remind us of why we go to the movies in the first place.

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

Beyond Sanctions

The U.S.-led financial-sanctions campaign currently under way against Iran is biting, but it isn’t enough. To change the Iranian regime’s nuclear calculus, the administration and the international community need to ...
Politics & Policy

Dim Idea

Arriving late one night into Tokyo, I checked into my hotel room to discover the world’s most complicated toilet. There were hoses and nozzles where hoses and nozzles probably shouldn’t be, ...


Politics & Policy

The Great U-Turn

Admirers and detractors of the United States agree on one point: This country is unusually resistant to the social consensus and set of structures broadly known as “social democracy” or ...
Politics & Policy

Obama’s U.N. Record

Barack Obama will make his second address as president to the opening of the United Nations General Assembly on September 23, and engage in the customary ceremonies, social events, and ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

Laws of Thought

On entering the Catholic Church earlier this year, Hadley Arkes explained that he had become convinced that the Church was fundamentally a truth-telling institution. He arrived at this judgment after ...
Politics & Policy

Film: Total Immersion

At times, it can feel as though television’s auteurs are making the movie industry irrelevant. Fifty years after phrases like “idiot box” and “vast wasteland” entered the American vocabulary, the ...
Politics & Policy

Bliss Was It . . .

The 1924 presidential election was, on the face of it, a snoozer. The major-party candidates were Calvin Coolidge (Republican) and John W. Davis (Democrat). Both were conservative — sensationally so ...
Politics & Policy

Moot Causes

Where did the idea come from that, if a black student studies hard in school, he is “acting white”? Stuart Buck — a Harvard Law graduate who is currently a ...


The Bent Pin

Fed Up

Optimists don’t mind if you eavesdrop on them. They welcome it, in fact, because it helps them spread their fiendish gospel. Here is what the one behind me in the ...
The Long View

“How We Can Help Improve Your Image”

Notes to a PowerPoint presentation to: The Islamic Faith By ImageSpinners, LLC Slide 1: Photo of the Planet Earth from space morphing into ImageSpinners logo. “Who We Are” ImageSpinners, LLC, is a New York–based public-relations ...
Politics & Policy


GREAT LAKE WINTER A crack in ice will join as well as rend. In every ear that thinks it’s safe from harm, The snap can clearly cause, or not, alarm. But those who hear ...

The Teat Eternal

The New York Times Sunday magazine is where you find nice glossy ads for expensive consumer goods alongside 10,000-word stories on why expensive consumer goods do not make us happy. ...
Politics & Policy


Ayn Rand, Christian Soldier? “The Greatly Ghastly Rand” (August 30), by Jason Lee Steorts, analyzes Ayn Rand and her writings accurately and not altogether without sympathy. Allow me to add my ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ Soon the Republicans may be able to claim the first nonwhite Speaker of the House. ‐ President Obama’s long-stated view is that his predecessor’s tax cuts for the middle class ...

Most Popular