Magazine | November 29, 2010, Issue

Four Governors

Keep your eye on these rising GOP stars

The 50 states may be “laboratories of democracy,” but sometimes their experiments go awry. Many of America’s newly elected governors will be inheriting severe budget deficits that demand root-canal fiscal adjustments. In several purple or blue states — including Michigan, Ohio, Wisconsin, and Maine — Republicans picked up the governor’s mansion and also gained full control of the legislature. The relative success or failure of the GOP governors in those states could have national implications. Here are four to watch.

Rick Snyder (Michigan). The 2000s were a lost decade for Michigan, a state that has become synonymous with Rust Belt decline. Prior to May 2010, it had registered America’s highest jobless rate for 49 consecutive months. Wolverine State policymakers cannot reverse the long-term structural forces that have reduced American manufacturing employment, nor can they undo the damage wrought by union excesses in the auto industry. But they can tackle the thorny issue of public-sector compensation — Mackinac Center scholar James Hohman and researcher Adam Rule have estimated that “Michigan’s state and local government full-time employees are getting $5.7 billion more in benefits than they would if they received benefits equal to those of private-sector employees” — and they can address the notorious Michigan Business Tax (MBT), which discourages investment.

Enter Rick Snyder, a wealthy venture capitalist who emerged from a crowded Republican gubernatorial field and then pummeled Democratic candidate (and Lansing mayor) Virg Bernero on November 2, winning election by more than 18 points. A moderate conservative who has jauntily labeled himself “one tough nerd,” the 52-year-old Snyder will take office with ambitious plans to transform the Michigan economy (and create “Michigan 3.0”) by promoting innovation and entrepreneurship. “He’s a businessman who knows how to delegate,” says veteran Michigan pollster Steve Mitchell. “He’s been very successful in everything he’s done.”

Snyder has proposed abolishing the MBT (which Mitchell calls “a really onerous tax”) and replacing it with a 6 percent corporate-income tax. “The MBT is a job killer,” he told the Detroit News in September. “It’s driven a lot of companies out of our state.” Yet implementing such a bold tax overhaul will be complicated by Snyder’s most immediate challenge: fixing a deep budget hole. The state deficit for fiscal year 2012 is projected to be anywhere from $1 billion to $1.6 billion. If Snyder can plug Michigan’s revenue gap and also establish a more business-friendly tax regime, that would be a monumental achievement.

John Kasich (Ohio). Michigan isn’t the only Rust Belt state that needs to revamp its tax system and curb its public-sector unions. In the Tax Foundation’s 2011 State Business Tax Climate Index, Ohio places a dismal 46th. A separate analysis shows that Ohio went from having the sixth-lowest combined state and local tax burden in 1977 to having the seventh-highest burden in 2008. (And for most of that period, there was a Republican governor in Columbus.) “The tax burden is the single most important obstacle to economic growth that the state government can deal with,” says Ohio University economist Richard Vedder.

Governor-elect John Kasich has signed Grover Norquist’s Taxpayer Protection Pledge (thereby vowing not to support tax hikes), as has incoming Ohio house speaker Bill Batchelder. Both are rock-ribbed conservatives. Kasich, 58, first gained national recognition during his tenure as House Budget Committee chief during the Clinton years, and he later worked as a Fox News host. Addressing a luncheon of lobbyists and special-interest bigwigs just days after his election, he delivered a stern warning: “We need you on the bus, and if you’re not on the bus, we will run over you with the bus. And I’m not kidding.”

Easier said than done. As the Columbus Dispatch notes, “More than 85 percent of the state budget is spent on Medicaid, K–12 education, higher education, prisons, local governments, and property-tax relief.” A massive fiscal shortfall ($8 billion) looms on the horizon, which means painful spending cuts are simply unavoidable. But the new governor will face huge resistance from Big Labor, and perhaps also some pushback from the GOP-controlled state senate, which will be, on balance, less conservative than Kasich and Batchelder. (“This is the national headquarters of RINO Republicanism,” jokes Vedder.) Buckeye conservatives hope that Kasich will become Ohio’s Chris Christie: an aggressive budget-slasher prepared to confront the unions.

#page#Scott Walker (Wisconsin). After George W. Bush came tantalizingly close to winning the Badger State in 2004, Barack Obama carried it handily (by 14 points) in 2008. Two years later, however, Republicans easily defeated Sen. Russ Feingold (a three-term incumbent), captured the governor’s mansion, and flipped both chambers of the state legislature. Governor-elect Scott Walker, the Milwaukee county executive, is a “policy geek” who will inherit “a perfect storm of opportunities,” says University of Wisconsin political scientist Ken Goldstein. Moreover, his state has “probably the most powerful governor’s office in the country,” and he will enjoy broad veto authority.

The 43-year-old Walker will need all the help he can get. Wisconsin is staring at a $3 billion deficit, and it ranks a lowly 40th in the State Business Tax Climate Index. Walker has already sent a clear message by opposing the completion of a high-speed train line that would connect Madison with Milwaukee, dismissing the project as “a short-term fix that will cost the taxpayers of our state millions into the future.” Given his wonkish tendencies and passion for education reform, he may turn out to be a Wisconsin Republican in the mold of Tommy Thompson, who governed the state from 1987 to 2001 and was a true policy pioneer on issues such as welfare and school choice.

“Scott Walker’s got a really tough job,” Goldstein says. “But if he pulls it off, he becomes an important national figure.”

Paul LePage (Maine). How long has it been since Maine Republicans simultaneously held the governorship and both legislative chambers? The last time those conditions obtained, LBJ was president, the inaugural Super Bowl had yet to be played, and Neil Armstrong was still a few years away from making his giant leap for mankind.

Starting in January, the Pine Tree State governor will be a French-speaking Tea Party conservative with a mind-blowing personal story. Several decades before Paul LePage, 62, received “businessman of the year” honors from the Mid-Maine Chamber of Commerce and became mayor of Waterville, he was a homeless child navigating the gritty streets of Lewiston. His journey from the poorhouse to Augusta is far more implausible than anything Horatio Alger could have conjured up. In 2010, he benefited from a three-way gubernatorial race and squeaked past independent candidate Eliot Cutler.

Given his roots, LePage has unique credibility on the issue of welfare reform, which he has identified as a top legislative priority. While Maine’s overall poverty rate is below the national average, there are enormous disparities between the wealthy tourist hubs along the coast and the hardscrabble communities littered across the state’s interior. Many areas are plagued by the sort of post-industrial decay chronicled in Empire Falls, Richard Russo’s Pulitzer-winning novel. The Maine Heritage Policy Center reports that nearly 30 percent of state residents are enrolled in at least one of three welfare programs (Food Stamps, Medicaid, and Temporary Assistance for Needy Families).

Speaking to the Waterville Rotary Club in August, LePage excoriated the Maine welfare system as “humiliating and degrading.” He hopes to tighten eligibility guidelines, boost work requirements, and realign incentives. He also wants to improve Maine’s business environment by cleaning up its cumbersome morass of regulations. In a 2009 survey published by the Mercatus Center, political scientists William Ruger and Jason Sorens calculated that Maine offers less economic freedom than any state except New York.

A final note about LePage: His election will probably bring significant changes to Maine’s “DirigoChoice” health-insurance scheme, an Obamacare-like program that has become a costly mess. Indeed, should the Republicans get their way, Dirigo will look “radically different, if it still exists at all,” says Tarren Bragdon, co-chairman of the LePage transition team. If the new governor makes substantial progress on welfare reform and/or health care, he is bound to garner (and deserve) national attention.

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

Political Economy

On November 2, Democrats suffered one of the worst midterm beatings in American history. The 65 House seats that they are now set to surrender represent the largest net loss ...
Politics & Policy

What to Cut

If the 2010 election produced any conservative mandates, they are to create jobs and to rein in soaring spending and deficits. Republicans should begin implementing this agenda by extending the ...
Politics & Policy

Thus Does It Grow

The American people did not give power to congressional Republicans; they took it away from congressional Democrats. Republicans now have an opportunity to prove that they deserve majority status — ...
Politics & Policy

Tax Extension

The 2001 and 2003 tax cuts are set to expire on December 31. In the months before the election, the White House pressed the case for permanently extending tax cuts ...
Politics & Policy

Four Governors

The 50 states may be “laboratories of democracy,” but sometimes their experiments go awry. Many of America’s newly elected governors will be inheriting severe budget deficits that demand root-canal fiscal ...
Politics & Policy

States Right

Voters obviously gave the president plenty to wince about on Election Day, so it is understandable that one particular irony escaped his notice: Barack Obama, whose most substantive political experience ...
Politics & Policy

Tea in 2012

Amid all the recriminations about the electoral ineffectiveness of some Tea Party–backed candidates, it’s easy to lose sight of a central fact: It’s doubtful that, without a newly emboldened grassroots ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

A Religious Journey

V.S. Naipaul is a gifted writer whose diction, imagery, and insight on postcolonial societies from the Caribbean to South Asia have won his work, both novels and narrative non-fiction, great ...
City Desk

Whoa, Dude!

When Sony stopped production of the Walkman, it had long been superseded by more advanced technology, but in the early Eighties, when it first caught on, it was a revolutionary ...
Politics & Policy

For God and Man

In this book, George Weigel maintains the very high standard he has long achieved of presenting controversial Roman Catholic subjects with the sympathy and insight of a committed adherent and ...
Politics & Policy

Mad Scientists

The English philosopher C. D. Broad once noted that “the nonsense written by philosophers on scientific matters is exceeded only by the nonsense written by scientists on philosophy.” You might ...


The Bent Pin


In baseball you can’t tell the players without a scorecard, but in political commentary you need a metaphor. As intellectually destitute as it was, the midterm campaign now blessedly drawn ...
The Long View

POTUS Communication Surveillance Transcript

National Security Agency POTUS Communication Surveillance Transcript BEGIN EXTRACT 12:03:55 [Static. Ringing.] UNIDENTIFIED MALE VOICE: Y’hello? POTUS: Bill? It’s Barack Obama. UNIDENTIFIED MALE VOICE: Hey! Greetings, Mr. President. POTUS: Did I call at a bad time? UNIDENTIFIED MALE VOICE: ...
Politics & Policy


TATTERS I see the garment of a grief and pain you no longer can feel, the sleeve of my own heart tugged at on this lost winter’s afternoon, cold and indecisive sun reflected in the eyes ...
Politics & Policy

From Defeat to Rout

They can’t say they weren’t warned. The polls showed independents beginning to turn away from President Obama in the spring of 2009. Town halls in the summer showed strong grassroots ...
Politics & Policy


U. Topia Up North Jonah Goldberg’s “U. Topia” (October 18) was a terrific piece, but his cheap shot at Canada — he says Canadians “think they’ve transcended international conflict when really ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ Sixty-five and counting: Nancy Pelosi does turn out to be a job creator. ‐ Soon-to-be-former Speaker Pelosi wants to stay on as minority leader in the new year. For now, ...

Most Popular

PC Culture

Hate-Crime Hoaxes Reflect America’s Sickness

On January 29, tabloid news site TMZ broke the shocking story that Jussie Smollett, a gay black entertainer and progressive activist, had been viciously attacked in Chicago. Two racist white men had fractured his rib, poured bleach on him, and tied a noose around his neck. As they were leaving, they shouted ... Read More

White Progressives Are Polarizing America

To understand how far left (and how quickly) the Democratic party has moved, let’s cycle back a very short 20 years. If 1998 Bill Clinton ran in the Democratic primary today, he’d be instantaneously labeled a far-right bigot. His support for the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, the Defense of Marriage Act, ... Read More
Politics & Policy

The Strange Paradoxes of Our Age

Modern prophets often say one thing and do another. Worse, they often advocate in the abstract as a way of justifying their doing the opposite in the concrete. The result is that contemporary culture abounds with the inexplicable — mostly because modern progressivism makes all sorts of race, class, and ... Read More
PC Culture

Fake Newspeople

This week, the story of the Jussie Smollett hoax gripped the national media. The story, for those who missed it, went something like this: The Empire actor, who is both black and gay, stated that on a freezing January night in Chicago, in the middle of the polar vortex, he went to a local Subway store to buy a ... Read More

One Last Grift for Bernie Sanders

Bernie Sanders, the antique Brooklyn socialist who represents Vermont in the Senate, is not quite ready to retire to his lakeside dacha and so once again is running for the presidential nomination of a party to which he does not belong with an agenda about which he cannot be quite entirely ... Read More
Film & TV

A Sublime Christian Masterpiece of a Film

‘There are two ways through life -- the way of nature and the way of grace,” remarks the saintly mother at the outset of The Tree of Life, one of the most awe-inspiring films of the 21st century. She continues: Grace doesn’t try please itself. It accepts being slighted, forgotten, disliked, accepts insults ... Read More
PC Culture

Changing Reality with Words

The reinvention of vocabulary can often be more effective than any social protest movement. Malarial swamps can become healthy “wetlands.” Fetid “dumps” are often rebranded as green “landfills.” Global warming was once a worry about too much heat. It implied that man-made carbon emissions had so ... Read More