Magazine | March 7, 2011, Issue

Jailbreak Conservatives

Sometimes the answer is fewer prisons

To hear state representative Jerry Madden describe it, his effort to shrink Texas’s sprawling, 170,000-inmate prison system was pretty simple. “I figured we could either speed people coming out, or slow them down going in,” says the hulking, always-smiling engineer-turned-legislator. “We chose to slow them down going in, and that’s saved $2 billion for taxpayers.” Madden’s formula for reforming America’s second-largest state-prison system has had a great influence on conservative Republicans around the country.

As recently as 15 years ago, conservatives almost uniformly called for building more prisons, increasing criminal penalties, extending the length of prison sentences, and eliminating programs that allowed offenders to remain outside of penitentiaries. Now that’s changed, and leaders with sterling right-of-center credentials have embraced new thinking about crime and prisons that picks up on many concerns once more closely associated with the Left. The new approach, organized around a loose coalition called Right on Crime, emphasizes stricter parole and probation in return for shorter sentences, the reform of sentencing practices, diverting low-level offenders away from prison, involving victims in offenders’ lives, in-prison drug-treatment and literacy programs, faith-based rehabilitation, a reduction in the overall number of criminal laws, and a slower pace of prison construction.

Conservatives, in short, have come to realize that ever-increasing prison populations and ever-harsher penalties are wasting taxpayers’ money and destroying lives. While some of these new policies may seem relatively “soft on crime,” a look at the results, and at the circumstances that gave rise to them, reveals an embrace of conservative principles, not an abandonment of them.       

There’s no doubt that the nation’s corrections systems have changed in the past several decades, and changed most drastically under conservative leaders. According to the Pew Center on the States, in 2009, for the first time since 1972, America’s state-prison-inmate population (about 1.4 million) declined slightly. Reform efforts have taken place in every part of the country, mostly with leadership from Republicans popular with the party’s conservative base. Beyond Texas’s $2 billion reduction in its corrections budget, South Carolina under former governor Mark Sanford trimmed about $241 million from the state corrections budget, while conservative governors including Indiana’s Mitch Daniels and Louisiana’s Bobby Jindal have announced sweeping initiatives to change sentencing laws, reform probation, and stem the growth of prison systems. Even in California, where harsh sentencing laws and powerful corrections unions created the nation’s biggest prison system, the total inmate count declined 2.5 percent between 2008 and 2009 as total prison spending fell. During the same period, only one of the ten largest states, Pennsylvania, saw its jail and prison population grow faster than its overall population.

#page#Newly elected governors including Kansas’s Sam Brownback and Florida’s Rick Scott have ambitious plans to move their states in the same direction. And conservative heavyweights such as Americans for Tax Reform president Grover Norquist, Newt Gingrich, and former drug czar Bill Bennett have signed on to a Right on Crime statement of principles endorsing the new direction in criminal justice.

By and large, conservatives calling for corrections reform have made a convincing case that the project comports with efforts to shrink government while continuing to carry out its core functions. “Prisons are just another government spending program; we should treat them like that,” says Pat Nolan of Charles Colson’s Prison Fellowship ministry. Nolan, a former minority leader of the California assembly who spent 25 months in federal prison after a bribery sting operation, has not always taken this view. “When I was a legislator, I was tough on bureaucracy, whether it was CalTrans or CalEPA. But when it came to the prison system, I handed them a blank check,” he says.

Conservative reformers today are not falling prey to the canard that criminals are victims of society. Rather, a crime rate that has fallen every year but one since 1994 has made it possible for them to retreat from the reflexive “lock ’em up” mentality that once helped win elections. “The focus is on the victims, not the offenders,” says Marc Levin, who coordinates the Right on Crime Coalition through the Austin-based Texas Public Policy Foundation. “Punishment should matter, and certain people need to be locked up. We don’t deny that there was a point when states needed more prisons — it’s just that the point has passed.”

Different states have accomplished similar goals in different ways. South Carolina achieved its reforms with sweeping legislative packages that eliminated sentencing disparities between people charged with possession of crack and powder cocaine, changed community-supervision requirements, and worked to reduce recidivism among released convicts. Other states, such as Texas, have taken incremental approaches involving dozens of different actions through the legislative and executive branches. Indiana governor Mitch Daniels’s proposed reforms to sentencing policies — which would vastly increase judges’ discretion in imposing sentences, cut some penalties outright, and give new incentives to localities to divert low-level offenders — may be the most sweeping serious proposal on the table. But not all reforms have been limited to big legislative moves: Mississippi’s Haley Barbour has concentrated on improving corrections systems through budget measures, executive orders, administrative reforms, and symbolic actions such as commuting the sentences of two sisters given life in prison for an armed robbery that netted $11. (The sisters had become a cause célèbre for the NAACP and dozens of other groups, and were released on the condition that one donate a kidney to save the other’s life.)

If conservatism is truly what Russell Kirk described as the “negation of ideology,” then it ought to evolve with the facts on the ground and should not pursue unchanging policies under changing circumstances. For all the good that it has done in reducing crime, America’s ever-growing prison industry is an instrument of the state that deserves real suspicion. Efforts to stop squandering money and human potential on less-effective approaches to criminal justice deserve the Right’s support.

– Mr. Lehrer is vice president for Washington, D.C., operations at the Heartland Institute.

Eli Lehrer — Eli Lehrer is president and co-founder of the R Street Institute, a free-market think tank. He oversees R Street’s central headquarters in Washington, D.C., as well as its field offices in ...

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

Jailbreak Conservatives

To hear state representative Jerry Madden describe it, his effort to shrink Texas’s sprawling, 170,000-inmate prison system was pretty simple. “I figured we could either speed people coming out, or ...


Politics & Policy

Pawlenty to Like

Kevin Krawczyk is disappointed. A manager at the Family Christian Store chain, he is hosting a book-signing for Tim Pawlenty in Lombard, Ill. “We were expecting more,” he says. The ...
Politics & Policy

A Frightful Democracy

What if the fundamental terms of our debate over Egypt’s revolution are wrong? Supposedly, the revolt that toppled Egyptian president Hosni Mubarak presented American policymakers with an agonizing choice: Do ...
Politics & Policy

With the Warriors

Patrol Base Fires, Sangin District, Helmand Province, Afghanistan The view from this platoon outpost in southern Afghanistan is unobstructed, both visually and strategically. On all sides stretch flat, bare, ...

Books, Arts & Manners

City Desk

Usable Past

I first started buying other people’s pasts when I wore second-hand clothes. Wide silk ties, tweed pants heavy as iron, cabana sets made “for the Stars of Hollywood” — I ...


Politics & Policy


Against the Seventeenth Amendment In an otherwise excellent article about the U.S. Senate (“The Sense of the Senate,” February 21), William Voegeli errs in saying that “the Lincoln–Douglas debates were the ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ People do have a lot of false ideas about Obama. Some of them think he’s a moderate. ‐ The guiding theme of President Obama’s new budget is “more.” Compared with ...
The Bent Pin

The Middling Class

When American Anglophiles need a fix our drug of choice is Masterpiece Theatre, but the days of savoring Edwardian class hierarchies may be over. Our all-time favorite, Upstairs, Downstairs, needed ...
Politics & Policy


SAYING NOTHING ON WALNUT STREET For once thinking of the right Thing to say, not later on: At a Beckett play at Annenberg A Penn student snapped open A can as the second act started And ...

Most Popular


Joy Reid Denies Writing Homophobic Blog Posts

MSNBC personality Joy Reid's former blog, The Reid Report, published a series of anti-gay posts, which she claims were added to the site after it was shut down, by a hacker intent on destroying her reputation and nascent cable-news career. Reid, who discontinued the blog roughly a decade ago, apologized in ... Read More

The Lure of Outsiderism

In a Wall Street Journal piece this weekend recounting his brief and harrowing recent experience at The Atlantic, Kevin Williamson ably notes a common pattern in this moment in our national life. Discussing a panel he attended at the chic South by Southwest conference, he writes: Which brings us back to that ... Read More

Monday Links

A Supercut of Epic Movie Explosions. Can You Solve These 10 Medieval Riddles? The cost to make a Margherita pizza: $1.77. How much restaurants charge on average for a pizza: $12. The actual costs of restaurant foods. Vintage animation lessons -- how to make things cute. London's "Great ... Read More

On Trade, No One Is Waiting for Washington

President Donald Trump’s flips and flops on trade are now as ubiquitous as his 5:00 a.m. tweets. Many predicted that trade-expansion efforts would come to a standstill and world commerce would suffer amidst all the uncertainty. Instead, the precise opposite has happened. In the last few months, it’s become ... Read More
National Security & Defense

Trump’s Syria Quandary

President Trump raised eyebrows recently when he ended a tweet lauding the airstrikes he’d ordered against chemical-weapons facilities in Syria with the words “mission accomplished.” The phrase, of course, became infamous in the aftermath of the invasion of Iraq, when President Bush used it in a speech ... Read More

Confirm Pompeo

What on earth are the Democrats doing? President Trump has nominated CIA director Mike Pompeo, eminently qualified by any reasonable standard, to be America’s 70th secretary of state. And yet the Senate Democrats, led by Chuck Schumer, have perverted the advice and consent clause of the Constitution into a ... Read More
PC Culture

The Dark Side of the Starbucks Stand-Down

By now the story is all over America. Earlier this month, two black men entered a Starbucks store in Philadelphia. They were apparently waiting for a friend before ordering — the kind of thing people do every day — and one of the men asked to use the restroom. A Starbucks employee refused, saying the restroom ... Read More