Magazine | April 18, 2011, Issue

Charlie Sheen Writ Large

Manning Up: How the Rise of Women Has Turned Men into Boys, by Kay S. Hymowitz (Basic, 248 pp., $25.99)

‘Are men necessary?” Maureen Dowd famously asked in a book title. Who needs men, when, as Manhattan Institute scholar Kay Hymowitz writes in her new book, “young women are reaching their twenties with more achievements, more education, more property, and, arguably, more ambition than their male counterparts”? What do women want, as they live urban, graduate-degreed lives of independence? Good luck with answering these questions, if you’re a young man in America today — never mind figuring out what a man is supposed to be in the first place.

Even before Charlie Sheen’s recent notoriety as the “Malibu Messiah” with “tiger blood,” the popularity of his sitcom Two and a Half Men was broadly attributed to his bad-boy character on the show. Women, it has been argued, weren’t entirely turned off by the crude rudeness of the hard-drinking jingle writer he played. What he lacked in personal responsibility he made up in domination. Any attraction women may have had to the show’s Charlie speaks to the paradoxical reality of modern life. Men have been deconstructed and emasculated and yet are expected to somehow ooze masculinity, even when they’ve been told it’s something akin to a hate crime; as Hymowitz writes, “provider husbands and fathers are now optional, and the character qualities men had needed to play their role — fortitude, stoicism, courage, fidelity — are obsolete and even a little embarrassing.”

What remains of masculinity is not infrequently the Charlie Sheen caricature of it, the loser-slackers played by Seth Rogen, or, at best, the overgrown-child characters of many a successful Adam Sandler movie. The insistence that irresponsibility, childishness, and the attention of “goddesses” is what defines “winning” is perversely related to the feminist notion that “a woman needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle”: Societal insistence on ignoring and forcibly rewiring the natural complementarity of the sexes has condemned men and women to a prolonged “preadulthood.” Consider the magazine cover headlining Jennifer Aniston’s latest insistence that, at 42, divorced, and childless, she is absolutely happy. Her audience doesn’t seem to buy it — perhaps because they know their own lives.

“Not so long ago,” writes Hymowitz, “average mid-twentysomethings, both male and female, had achieved most of the milestones of adulthood: high-school diploma, financial independence, marriage, and children.” Nowadays, though, “they hang out in a novel sort of limbo, a hybrid state of semi-hormonal adolescence and responsible self-reliance.” This preadulthood isn’t all bad, “but it seems about time to state what has become obvious to legions of frustrated young women: It doesn’t tend to bring out the best in men.”

This preadulthood is “a momentous sociological development,” which comes as no surprise to anyone who has been born and raised in its midst. The Girl Project of the last decades — complete with Take Your Daughter to Work Day — has not only neglected boys, but raised a We Girls Can Do Anything cadre of females with every conceivable goal except being a wife and mother. And so the daughters of the Project now “graduate from college in greater numbers than men, with higher grade point averages; more extracurricular experiences, including study abroad; and, as most professors tell it, more confidence, drive, and plans for the future. They are aggressively independent; they don’t need to rely on any man, that’s for sure.”

#page#Their brothers and boyfriends are often child-men, “the fun house mirror image of the alpha girl”: “If she is ambitious, he is a slacker. If she is hyper-organized and self-directed, he tends toward passivity and vagueness. If she is preternaturally mature, he is happily not.” The contrast between underachieving Bart and overachieving Lisa Simpson in pop culture pretty well captures it. The Simpsons are in suspended animation and so would Bart and Lisa be in real life. Bart and his friends wouldn’t grow up and Lisa wouldn’t admit she’d actually like them to, because she both wants and needs men as an integral part of her life. Generally, she doesn’t articulate any of this, and neither does the culture. Neither do the traditional community-support systems — because often, in the midst of Sex and the City–like urban life, they’re not there in the first place.

Books like Are Men Necessary?, The Decline of Males, and Is There Anything Good About Men? are responses to the reality that, in Hymowitz’s words, “men are not thriving in today’s cultural and economic environment.” They’re not thriving because they’ve been cheated and been mistreated. The feminists who played no small role in getting us here have left us with a great irony: “On the one hand, the well-raised, middle-class young man learns that marriage should be a partnership of equals. He will share the cooking, cleaning, feeding, and driving so that his wife can make partner or meet her book deadline too. But he learns something else as well, something that doesn’t square with that first message. He learns he is dispensable and possibly even a drag on family life.”

They are stuck in preadulthood in part because preadults “don’t know what is supposed to come next. They’re not sure what the gender scripts are, if there are any.” They’re still “pre” because they don’t even know what “adult” means.

Preadulthood simply doesn’t work. It’s a limbo that has “confounded the primordial search for a mate. It has delayed a stable sense of identity, dramatically expanded the pool of possible spouses, mystified courtship routines, and helped to throw into doubt the very meaning of marriage.” Young people are getting married later, having children later. And it’s “an uneasy standoff with human biology, culminating in an unintended set of medical, economic, and social consequences, including more child-men, single mothers, and fatherless homes.”

This isn’t, of course, entirely the doing of the feminists, but they’ve certainly played a key role. The birth-control pill made the faux independence the sisterhood sold seem plausible. But so did economic and technological shifts, especially the development of a “knowledge economy” that “multiplies opportunities in such fields as law, media, public relations, fashion, graphic and product design, book publishing, communications, and retail, where the few women who had pursued careers in the past had generally gravitated.”

#page#This “profound demographic shift” is here to stay, Hymowitz warns, because “the economic and cultural changes are too embedded” to reverse. “And so while women will continue to pursue careers and independence, they also have to wake up to and be at peace with nature. The female body imposes certain limits.”

A main lesson the book draws from the ongoing chaos of the sexes is that there are limits to individualism. That won’t be news to any discerning person of faith, member of the military, or team player. But it’s a reality and we need to wake up to it. Hymowitz writes that what’s around us shapes our “understanding of the possibilities of how to live. . . . People don’t order or create a meaningful life out of whole cloth. They use the cultural materials available to them. The materials available to young men are meager, and what is available often contradicts itself. At bottom, they are too free.” Kay Hymowitz’s Manning Up is a five-alarm siren for a society in denial as it looks to be falling off a demographic cliff.

Can America rediscover adulthood? There are some signs of hope — chiefly in the fact that many college-educated men and women do grow out of this unprecedented stage that is preadulthood. But that’s an unreliable trend, given current bad habits and attitudes. As Hymowitz writes:

Between his lack of familial responsibilities, his relative affluence, and an entertainment media devoted to his every pleasure, the single young man can live in pig heaven — and he often does. He has plenty of time — at least he thinks so from his sad little apartment — to become a mensch. Women put up with him for a while, but then in fear and disgust they either decide to change their plans and give up on the husband and kids or they go to the sperm bank and get the DNA without the troublesome child-man attached. They’re probably not thinking about it this way, but their choice only legitimizes the guy’s attachment to the sandbox. Why should he grow up? No one needs him anyway. He has nothing he’s got to do.

Might as well grab the remote and have another beer.

Perhaps some of those married survivors of preadulthood — who have charted their own course out of the dating and mating scene — can truly be adults, helping those behind them along the way. Perhaps, through demonstration, encouragement, and even admonishment, they can work toward reissuing those tried and tested age-old civilizational scripts, adapted for new educational and economic opportunities. But until then, good luck, guys, figuring out whether to hold the door or not, pay the bill or not — be a man or not. And good luck, gals, with your “navel-gazing, wisecracking child-men” when what you’re really needing is an “unhyphenated, unironic” one. It’s a social jungle out there. Charlie Sheen, on screen and off, isn’t the only casualty of it.

Diane KatzKathryn Jean Lopez is the former editor and current editor-at-large of the widely read and cited daily webzine, National Review Online, where she has written and edited for more than a ...

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

Replacement Plan

On health care, Republicans have unified behind a slogan rather than a policy. The slogan, “repeal and replace,” describes what they want to do to the Democrats’ health-care law, also ...


Politics & Policy

Tocqueville and the Tube

Television makes us fat, lazy, inattentive, unsociable, mistrustful, materialistic — and unhappy about all of that. It cheapens political discourse, weakens family ties, prevents face-to-face socializing, and exposes kids to ...
Politics & Policy


President Obama’s use of military force in Libya has come under intense criticism across the American political spectrum. There is widespread disagreement over what U.S. objectives should be, and many ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

Light of the World

If the Vatican Observatory were to begin broadcasting Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence–style signals into space, and the Catholic Church went looking for a single story capable of introducing to an ...
The Straggler

Decline and Fall

There is a school of psychology called Situationism that pooh-poohs the notion of individual character. This line of thought began with some experiments by Stanley Milgram of Yale in the ...
Politics & Policy

The Parent Trap

When Andrew Ferguson attended Occidental College in the 1970s, colleges were already moving away from fussy old requirements like American history, English composition, and foreign languages, and towards the anything-goes ...
Politics & Policy

TR’s Goal-Line Stand

Baseball may still try to market itself as our national pastime, but there’s little doubt that football is our national passion. By any measurement, the popularity of college and professional ...


Politics & Policy


Who Will Review the Judicial Reviewers? In his reply to Pamela K. Grow’s letter concerning nullification, Allen C. Guelzo states, correctly, “If the founders had wanted to grant nullifying power — ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ To be fair, Obama is right: Nowhere in the Constitution does it say that Congress has to declare kinetic military action. ‐ The Congressional Budget Office released an analysis of ...
The Long View

NSA Document Extract

NSA Document Extract POTUS Secured Communications 03.24.11 09:33EDT Begin Extract Static. Ringing. Unidentified Male Voice: Hello? POTUS: Mr. President? It’s Barack Obama. UMV: Well hey. Hey! Barack Obama. Lemme just — Barb, can you turn that down? ...
Politics & Policy


WINDOW SHOPPER’S IVORY The grand and opulent curve – the tusk from a beast long gone; now observed held firm, upon its dark, exotic wooden base. At first glance, the surface appears merely uneven; but a ...
Happy Warrior

Esprit de l’Escalier

Wandering round this great republic predicting the apocalypse, I’m often asked by audience members why it is I’m being quite so overwrought if not an hysterical old queen about the ...

Most Popular

Film & TV

The Manly Appeal of Ford v Ferrari

There used to be a lot of overlap between what we think of as a Hollywood studio picture (designed to earn money) and an awards movie (designed to fill the trophy case, usually with an accompanying loss of money). Ford v Ferrari is a glorious throwback to the era when big stars did quality movies about actual ... Read More
Politics & Policy

ABC Chief Political Analyst: GOP Rep. Stefanik a ‘Perfect Example’ of the Failures of Electing Someone ‘Because They Are a Woman’

Matthew Dowd, chief political analyst for ABC News, suggested that Representative Elise Stefanik (R., N.Y.) was elected due to her gender after taking issue with Stefanik's line of questioning during the first public impeachment hearing on Wednesday. “Elise Stefanik is a perfect example of why just electing ... Read More
White House

Trump vs. the ‘Policy Community’

When it comes to Russia, I am with what Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Vindman calls the American “policy community.” Vindman, of course, is one of the House Democrats’ star impeachment witnesses. His haughtiness in proclaiming the policy community and his membership in it grates, throughout his 340-page ... Read More
Law & the Courts

DACA’s Day in Court

When President Obama unilaterally changed immigration policy after repeatedly and correctly insisting that he lacked the constitutional power to do it, he said that congressional inaction had forced his hand. In the case of his first major unilateral move — “Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals,” which ... Read More
White House

Impeachment and the Broken Truce

The contradiction at the center of American politics in Anno Domini 2019 is this: The ruling class does not rule. The impeachment dog-and-pony show in Washington this week is not about how Donald Trump has comported himself as president (grotesquely) any more than early convulsions were about refreshed ... Read More