Magazine | June 20, 2011, Issue

Do the Jefferson

The marble temples of Washington enshrine our civic heroes in great stone cenotaphs, so that we may gaze up at their Olympian brows and connect with the virtues they embody. Or, if you’re there with your gullible kids, so you can tell fibs. That’s Abe Lincoln’s true size, you know. They say he ate five cows in a single sitting. His burial shroud was a circus tent. This is where the kid gives you a “Yeah, right” look. C’mon. They were just ordinary guys. Indeed: and that’s what makes them so extraordinary.

It’s not always easy to get into the contemplative mood, though; too many tourists, too much traffic noise, swampy D.C. weather, the occasional grunt and scream as the cops tackle people for illegal Monument Dancing. Yes, it happens: At the end of May on a fine spring day, five people were wrestled to the ground and arrested for dancing in the Jefferson Memorial. Cherry on the cake: They were protesting a ban on dancing in the Jefferson Memorial.

There’s something here for everyone, really. If you think personal expression is our most fundamental right, it’s an outrage: No doubt the founding fathers wanted us to trot a gavotte if the mood struck, and banning a two-step in a civic memorial is Puritanism in jackboots. If the founders hadn’t run out of ink, it would have been the Eleventh Amendment: The People shall have the Right to turn a Leg to any diverse Aire.

Others might grant that the police have more pressing issues, but tough toe-shoes, pal: If the law says Thou Shalt Not Jig, then jig not. If a cadre of narcissists bent on attention think they can spoil everyone’s moment of civic contemplation with some terpsichorean moves, then they’re twerps. Or twerpsichoreans, if you will. If they win, then dancing can break out anywhere and there’s nothing we can do about it. Envision the future, Winston: a ballet slipper treading on a human face — forever.

The dancers were originally busted back in 2008 on Jefferson’s birthday, and it’s taken until now for the case to work its way through the system. The court’s ruling said the dancing “stands out as a type of performance, creating its own center of attention and distracting from the atmosphere of solemn commemoration.” The decision was snorted at in the usual places: Dancing is banned? When did the country turn into Footloose? What’s next, puppetry? Mimes? You’re telling me someone can’t stand in the Jefferson Memorial in clownish whiteface, pretending to walk against the wind as a protest against the Patriot Act? And we call this America?

#page#It’s worth noting that some of the Jefferson Memorial Dancers are members of Code Pink, the Westboro Baptist Church of the Left, and believe they have the right to interrupt anyone doing anything with unintelligible shrieking, this being the most effective moral force on the planet. The recent interruption of Netanyahu’s speech to Congress by Code Pink is generally regarded as the impetus for the Jewish state’s decision to disband, for example. But just because they’re annoying doesn’t mean they don’t have a point. The Right may disapprove of protest dances, but what if they realize the only way to force the administration to adhere to the War Powers Act is to jitterbug along the top of the Vietnam Memorial? See how this comes back to bite you?

The memorial has known controversy before; when its design was announced, modernists sniffed at its classicism. Oh, more Roman frosting. How brave. The dead hand of the Roman past. Suppose they’ll want to dedicate the thing with a toe-tapping Sousa march too. It goes without saying that they’ll choose a traditional statue with the eyes on either side of the nose, too, as if Picasso never happened. Apparently the modernists wanted the 18th-century man to stand in something that looked like Buck Rogers’s summer home, wearing goggles and with a ray gun in one hand. A Moderne building would have been interesting, but people associate classical motifs with civic grandeur, and the sleek machine-like lines of Thirties architecture with WPA post offices. There are echoes of Jefferson’s own rotunda for the University of Virginia as well, and you suspect the fellow would have been happy to stand there.

Dancing in his honor is another matter. Jefferson reportedly discouraged celebrations of his birthday: “The only birthday I ever commemorate,” he told some well-wishers once, “is that of our Independence, the Fourth of July.” You can dance on the 4th if you want to, of course — as long as it’s outside. You just can’t boogaloo in the rotunda. Is that so much to ask?

Besides, if you really want to impose yourself on others, you can just yell. Years ago I paid a visit to the Jefferson Memorial in April. Cherry blossoms in full glory; the balm of spring in the breeze. The crowds shuffled through the rotunda, speaking in hushed tones, looking up at the Noble Founder’s Brow — and then a young woman on the stairs yelled OH MY GOD THE RADIO SAYS SAM KINISON IS DEAD! He was a squat long-haired comic who yelled a lot. To this day, Sam Kinison and Thomas Jefferson are welded together in my mind. I look at a two-dollar bill, I hear Sam Kinison scream. Especially when I consider how it doesn’t buy a gallon of gas anymore.

Anyone up for a protest dance over drilling? If Code Pink is on to this, it has to work.

– Mr. Lileks blogs at

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

War of Words

‘The Woman Who Stopped Us from Saying ‘Stewardess,’” read a headline last month. The article was a celebration of Kate Swift, who had passed away. She is credited with rooting ...
Politics & Policy

The Moderate

Richard Quinn, who has been working for Republican presidential candidates in South Carolina since 1980, thinks he has found a winner this time: “I think he’s the best I’ve seen, ...
Politics & Policy

Dangerous Disaffection

It is tempting to dismiss the Republicans’ recent loss in New York’s 26th congressional district. A “tea-party” candidate siphoned off conservative votes, and the Republican did not respond to the ...


Politics & Policy

Is Cain Able?

Herman Cain looked startled when Chris Wallace of Fox News quizzed him about the Middle East. “Where do you stand on the right of return?” asked Wallace on his Sunday-morning ...
Politics & Policy

Ages Apart

St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral in Manhattan is now known for the young-adult Mass, celebrated by Fr. Jonathan Morris, it hosts for a lively twentysomething Catholic community every Sunday at 7 ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

Growing Up

‘There’s a demon inside me,” Stu (Ed Helms) confesses to his best friend, Phil (Bradley Cooper), near the end of the redundant, repellent, and occasionally amusing The Hangover: Part II. ...
The Straggler

A Walk in Caria

It is always fun to gather first impressions of a foreign country. Turkey is, John O’Sullivan had explained to me, “upper-tier Third World.” That seems about right. The Third World–itude ...


Politics & Policy


In Memoriam As a friend of Bill Rusher’s for 45 years, I can say the vignettes by his friends and colleagues (“Remembering Bill Rusher,” May 16) accurately capture Bill, the man ...

Do the Jefferson

The marble temples of Washington enshrine our civic heroes in great stone cenotaphs, so that we may gaze up at their Olympian brows and connect with the virtues they embody. ...
Politics & Policy


CEMETERY HERD The cemetery was laid out in the 1850s. The headstones are of the differing styles fashionable over the many years of its operation, with paved pathways meandering their narrow course along the top of the ...
Happy Warrior


To be honest, I quite liked Obama’s “moat with alligators” crack. And, as it happens, the United States is building a moat on the border. The northern border, that is.       ...

Most Popular


On College Campuses, Where Are the Adults?

Last week, political scientist and author Charles Murray spoke at a dinner in Manhattan about the death, as he calledit, of the American Dream. The “Disinvitation Dinner,” is given annually by Lauren Noble’s William F. Buckley Jr. Program to honor a speaker who has been kicked off a college campus for ... Read More

Hurray for the NBA

Last month, just before the Final Four, I did a Q&A on college basketball with our Theodore Kupfer. Teddy K. is back, by popular demand, joined by two other experts: Vivek Dave, an old friend of mine from Michigan, who has long lived in Chicago, and David French, National Review’s Kentucky Kid, now ... Read More
Economy & Business

Trade Misunderstandings

I was distracted by other policy topics last week but not enough not to notice Peter Navarro’s article in the Wall Street Journal, headlined “China’s Faux Comparative Advantage.” Considering Navarro’s position in the White House, it is unfortunate that it demonstrates some serious misunderstandings ... Read More

Joy Reid Denies Writing Homophobic Blog Posts

MSNBC personality Joy Reid's former blog, The Reid Report, published a series of anti-gay posts, which she claims were added to the site after it was shut down, by a hacker intent on destroying her reputation and nascent cable-news career. Reid, who discontinued the blog roughly a decade ago, apologized in ... Read More

On Trade, No One Is Waiting for Washington

President Donald Trump’s flips and flops on trade are now as ubiquitous as his 5:00 a.m. tweets. Many predicted that trade-expansion efforts would come to a standstill and world commerce would suffer amidst all the uncertainty. Instead, the precise opposite has happened. In the last few months, it’s become ... Read More