Magazine | August 29, 2011, Issue

Roads Not Taken

A review of Another Earth

Late summer, like midwinter, is a time of year when it’s best to shun the big studio releases. Any star-studded blockbuster or crowd-pleasing comedy that’s actually worth its budget (i.e., not Cowboys & Aliens or The Change-Up) would have elbowed its way into theaters between Memorial Day and July 4th; any drama with more than a hint of Oscar potential (i.e., not The Help) would have been saved for November or December. Moviegoers are better off seeking out the smaller releases instead, looking for the curious pieces of artistic driftwood that sometimes wash up in a season’s dying days.

Perhaps this year’s strangest such offering is Another Earth, a movie notable for its leading lady (about whom more anon) and its peculiar genre-bending premise. Late on a New England night, the teenaged and MIT-bound Rhoda Williams (Brit Marling) hears a radio report about a newly discovered Earth-like planet, drunkenly leans out her car window to stare up into the night sky, and plows into a college professor and his family, killing his wife and son and unborn daughter. The professor (William Mapother) is thrown into a coma, while Rhoda spends four years in prison. Then the movie leaps ahead to after they’ve both been released — him into grief, her into guilt — and tracks her attempts to forge some kind of connection with the man whose life she recklessly destroyed.

So far this probably sounds like a typical aftermath-of-tragedy melodrama, by turns wrenching and implausible. But there’s a science-fiction twist: That “Earth-like planet” turns out to be literally Earth-like, a carbon copy of our own world that suddenly looms up, moon and continents all, in the sky above Rhoda’s New Haven home. Moon and continents and people and all: When a SETI scientist tries to make radio contact with the mysterious new world, she ends up having a conversation with her doppelganger on Earth 2.

I just called this “science fiction,” but really it’s better to call it a Twilight Zone conceit, since no real scientific explanation is ever proffered for the doubled Earth, beyond vague references to hidden orbits and alternate universes. It’s the latter possibility — that the new world represents some sort of road not taken, where the same people might be living out very different lives — that makes the other Earth an object of obsession for Rhoda, and a destination that she begins plotting desperately to reach.

#page#If the symbolism here seems more than a little heavy-handed — well, it is. But Another Earth deserves points for owning its heavy-handedness and playing its genre mash-up completely straight, without a trace of sub–David Lynch surrealism or ironic self-awareness. One joke or wink, one suggestive dream sequence, one hint that the entire Earth 2 phenomenon might be happening inside Rhoda’s guilt-wracked mind, and the spell would be broken. Instead, the movie’s unwavering commitment to its premise lends Another Earth an interesting sort of integrity, and enables the movie to at least approach the mix of dread and wonder that the filmmakers are clearly aiming for.

The visuals help.Another Earth depicts New Haven — the faded brick-and-concrete city, not just the Yale oasis — as a kind of wintry limbo, all sunsets and blue-gray dawns, with the huge Earth 2 looming like a promise of paradise (or damnation?) overhead. In the New England farmhouse where the bereaved professor has hunkered down, the Earthlight washes in at all hours, like a searchlight sweeping over an Andrew Wyeth exhibit. The budget is obviously shoestring and the digital video sometimes feels a little ragged, but overall the movie has a strange beauty all its own.

But it’s the cast that really sells the story. Mapother (recognizable to fans of Lost and the 2001 indie darling In the Bedroom) has a great face for suffering, with sunken eyes and furrows like ravines. Marling has a great face, period: Long and luminous and expressive, with precisely the mix of loveliness and mystery that separates the potential movie star from the mere onscreen beauty. She’s in almost every scene, and she holds the film together: The melodrama may creak and the fantastic element may teeter on the edge of absurdity, but the audience never stops believing in Rhoda’s humanity, her anguish, or her heart.

Marling co-wrote Rhoda as well as bringing her to life. (The script for Another Earth is her collaboration with the film’s director, Mike Cahill, who’s also her ex-boyfriend.) I’m not sure if she should stick with screenwriting: This movie is too strange to tell us much about what its makers might be capable of writing next. But her acting is another matter. Whether Brit Marling keeps turning out scripts or not, every director in Hollywood should be lining up to make sure that she keeps on starring in them.

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

Making Believe

With trumpets and drum rolls, the White House has released a new policy paper on methods to prevent terrorism, a study said to have been two years in the making. ...
Politics & Policy

London Aflame

London – Yesterday, August 8, I was watching live looting footage — some of it from districts near mine or where friends were hunkered down behind locked doors — with ...


Politics & Policy

Gagging Us Softly

To be honest, I didn’t really think much about “freedom of speech” until I found myself the subject of three “hate speech” complaints in Canada in 2007. I mean I ...
Politics & Policy

Not a Race Card

A  number of states have recently passed voter-ID legislation — among them, Texas, Alabama, Kansas, South Carolina, Tennessee, Wisconsin, and Rhode Island. Two others, Georgia and Indiana, implemented such laws ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

Roads Not Taken

Late summer, like midwinter, is a time of year when it’s best to shun the big studio releases. Any star-studded blockbuster or crowd-pleasing comedy that’s actually worth its budget (i.e., ...
Politics & Policy

Something to Fear

  Decades ago, the historian Theodore Draper wrote about what he called the “minor academic industry” dedicated to resurrecting the reputation of the American Communist party. The industry’s ranks were composed ...


Politics & Policy


  SOUTHERN STORM To the east is subtropical fern Whose shadows imprint the trails to the springs, More ancient than the forests themselves. To the west of these too-deep predawn pools There are rolling fields and ...
Happy Warrior

Old Blighted

I had a new book out the other day. Usual doom and gloom, as the more alert reader may just about be able to discern from the subtle title: After America: ...
Politics & Policy


Lochner in Rehab Reading Joseph Tartakovsky’s review of David Bernstein’s Rehabilitating Lochner (“Rights Revisited,” July 4), I got the sense that both gentlemen embrace the proposition that the 1905 Lochner decision was ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ Who would have guessed that Moammar Qaddafi would outlive America’s AAA rating? ‐ Wisconsin Democrats have gone to extraordinary lengths ever since Republicans introduced legislation to scale back the collective-bargaining ...
The Bent Pin

The Virgin Mother

A new version of an old song is running through my head. “‘M’ is for the million threats against you. ‘O’ is for Orlando’s mounted cops. ‘T’ is for tattoos ...

The Empire Goes Hungry

We could spend our time together here detailing the ideas that separate the Right and the Left, but if Maureen Dowd has taught us anything, it’s that it’s more fun ...

Most Popular


The Gun-Control Debate Could Break America

Last night, the nation witnessed what looked a lot like an extended version of the famous “two minutes hate” from George Orwell’s novel 1984. During a CNN town hall on gun control, a furious crowd of Americans jeered at two conservatives, Marco Rubio and Dana Loesch, who stood in defense of the Second ... Read More
Law & the Courts

Obstruction Confusions

In his Lawfare critique of one of my several columns about the purported obstruction case against President Trump, Gabriel Schoenfeld loses me — as I suspect he will lose others — when he says of himself, “I do not think I am Trump-deranged.” Gabe graciously expresses fondness for me, and the feeling is ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Students’ Anti-Gun Views

Are children innocents or are they leaders? Are teenagers fully autonomous decision-makers, or are they lumps of mental clay, still being molded by unfolding brain development? The Left seems to have a particularly hard time deciding these days. Take, for example, the high-school students from Parkland, ... Read More
PC Culture

Kill Chic

We live in a society in which gratuitous violence is the trademark of video games, movies, and popular music. Kill this, shoot that in repugnant detail becomes a race to the visual and spoken bottom. We have gone from Sam Peckinpah’s realistic portrayal of violent death to a gory ritual of metal ripping ... Read More