Magazine | December 31, 2011, Issue

Ancient Echoes

The End of Sparta: A Novel, by Victor Davis Hanson (Bloomsbury, 464 pp., $28)

The setting of The End of Sparta is antique, but the book has  contemporary resonance. By the end of its opening chapter, we have learned that “decline [is] a choice, a wish even,” and that the nature of civilization’s enemies is that “only the spear arm stops them. Nothing else. They won’t parley, won’t surrender, won’t stop — until killed.”

That these warnings about the perennial nature of the threats to liberty appear so early on is no accident. The author, classicist and regular NR contributor Victor Davis Hanson, is a fervent believer in classical education as a path to understanding the continuity between the past and the present, and, like conservatives of all stripes, is well aware that, when it comes to life’s fundamentals, nothing really changes. The struggle for freedom is never-ending, and this novel provides a timely reminder of this and other enduring truths.

Tall in the long identity parade of history’s villains stand the Spartans. It is their malfeasance, ambition, and downfall — and, by extension, the glory of those who would stand up to tyrants — that Hanson makes the subject of his first novel, and it is particularly refreshing to see an explicit rejection of the recent pop-cultural glorification of Spartan morality. The adventures of warrior-cults may lend themselves well to graphic novels, but they are not especially beneficial to civilization. Sparta was a city-state that deserved emasculation.

As the book opens, the Thebans are living under constant threat of raids and invasion from neighboring Sparta. Hungry to expand Laconia — the empire of slave farms that fed their dominance of the Greek peninsula — the Spartans wanted to roll both Thebes and the Boeotian farms into their realm, and their hoplite armies had a nasty habit of coming, seeing, and conquering, leaving devastation in their wake. The situation looks unchangeable until Epaminondas, a forgotten Great Man of History who would be described by Cicero as “the first man of Greece,” steps up to the plate.

Overcoming his own reservations, and the better judgment of some of his lieutenants, Epaminondas comes slowly and unexpectedly to the conclusion that the only way to guarantee lasting peace and protect Thebes is to offer battle, thoroughly to vanquish the Spartan army, and to free the 100,000 or so Messenian helots who, with their ancestors, have been enslaved for over 200 years since their defeat in the Messenian War. In achieving their liberation, they win a larger battle, namely the smashing of the considerable influence and prestige Sparta has held in Greece since the Peloponnesian War, and the removal of the slave farms that have served as bases for the projection of Spartan power. The Thebans’ victory dramatically redraws the political map.

The freedom of the helots is, thus, bound up with the freedom of all. It is impossible not to note the parallel here with recent American involvement in the Middle East: Amid the sweeping democratic fervor, one can hear echoes of Pres. George W. Bush making his case for preemptive action, and insisting both that peace is not just the absence of violence but the absence of the threat of violence, and that freedom is a universal value.

#page#Epaminondas’ undertaking was not an easy one. With Athens weak, the farmer-soldiers at his disposal were more likely to end up as arrow-fodder than to be elevated as conquering heroes. The Thebans were — fatally for Sparta, as it turned out — underestimated by the Spartans as “pigs.” But this hubris was understandable: On paper, the Theban cause did appear hopelessly lost. The Thebans’ victory at the Battle of Leuctra in 371 b.c., when the odds were so heavily stacked against them, raises an inevitable question: Why, when Athens had failed for 27 years to defeat Sparta, did Epaminondas manage this feat in just two? It is obvious that Hanson admires the nascent Theban system of government — sitting as it did between the two extremes of Spartan martial discipline and Athenian hyper-democracy — and considers it a contributing factor to Theban success. To adapt the apocryphal phrase often attributed to Alexis de Tocqueville, Thebes was great because Thebes was good.

In telling his story, Hanson is forced to practice the deft skills of the reconstructive surgeon, filling in the detail with his imagination when confronted with a dearth of evidence. (The book’s hero, Epaminondas, in particular has been to some extent excised from history, first by a bitter Xenophon, and then by the loss of Plutarch’s biography of him.) The result is a rich fiction, woven neatly around the skeleton of the few solid details we have at our disposal. This task forced the author to delve more deeply into the minds of his subjects than a writer might ordinarily have to. Their internal conflicts center on the tensions between Pythagorean rationalism and the more romantic polytheism that was ubiquitous in Greek society, and on the ultimate question of whether security or liberty is preferable (these issues were debated long before Benjamin Franklin voiced his famous maxim).

Wisely, Hanson avoids telling the story solely from the perspective of aristocrats and key players, as has been the tendency of many academics in the classical field. Epaminondas may be the hero, but we see most of the action through the eyes of Mêlon, a veteran farmer-soldier whose humanity shines through even to the extent of frustrating us with many of his decisions and attitudes, and those of his two slaves. This decision on Hanson’s part is instrumental in allowing readers to take the lie of a land with which most are likely unfamiliar. Mêlon is emblematic of the uninterrupted nature both of the Spartan threat to Thebes prior to the Battle of Leuctra, and of the inveterate necessity of fighting oppression: He has fought the Spartans before and was crippled for his troubles; his father was killed. Mêlon’s testimony and perspective demonstrate the depth to which Theban society was devastated by Spartan hegemony.

In other places, though, Hanson’s character development can be lacking. Some of the characters are clearly included solely to carry philosophical discussion, and this makes it hard to develop an emotional stake in them and their fates. Likewise, Hanson’s need to discuss abstract ideas occasionally puts his characters into unrealistic positions: It is a little hard to believe, for instance, that Mêlon can think so deeply and clearly about metaphysics while desperately fighting to stay alive, or that he would enjoy such a cinematic view of the battlefield.

This shortcoming is more than made up for by the musically resonant descriptions of battle. As in his academic work, this is where Hanson shines. The old adage about portraits is that the eyes should follow the viewer around the room; Hanson’s battles surround the reader and are brought to life with a claustrophobic realism that can veer roughly into discomfort. There is a level of detail unusual for a novel — we are informed how much a spear weighs, for example — but the inclusion of such minutiae is necessary rather than superfluous; most of us know little of the ancient world’s quotidian detail, and need such description in order to make sense of the scene.

Relatively little is definitively known of the period, and Hanson has to fill in gaps with both imagination and scholarly deduction. What he has achieved is a realistic portrait of an ancient world troubled in much the same way as our own; and in this respect, The End of Sparta slips the surly bonds of Greece to touch the face of a deeper truth.

– Mr. Cooke is an editorial associate at National Review.

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

The String-Pullers

Barack Obama initially ran for president invoking Abraham Lincoln, then looked to Franklin D. Roosevelt and even appealed to Ronald Reagan. He began campaigning for reelection as Harry Truman running ...
Politics & Policy

An Unavoidable Challenge

Our political calendar and one of our nation’s greatest threats have synchronized. In the upcoming year, the American people will render their judgment on Barack Obama’s presidency. Meanwhile, if the ...
Politics & Policy

The Z-Word

A few weeks ago, a Labour MP in Britain, Paul Flynn, expressed displeasure with his country’s ambassador to Israel. “I do not normally fall for conspiracy theories,” he said, “but ...


Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

Tintin Triumphant

I first encountered Tintin, the Belgian comic-book artist Hergé’s immortal reporter-detective, while trailing behind my parents in one of the many pretentious secondhand shops that clutter up southern New England. ...


Politics & Policy


Send Drones, Not Soldiers Jamie M. Fly’s “Retreat — But Whose?” (December 19) turned me from a supporter of the war in Afghanistan to a skeptic. If these are the best ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ President Obama told 60 Minutes that mending the economy “probably takes more than one president.” Hey, we’ve been saying that since January 2009. ‐ Obama, having tired of performing his ...
The Bent Pin

Tingling for Camelot

That barometer of our jejune times, Chris Matthews’s oh-so-sensitive leg, is all aquiver with a brand new thrill. Four years ago it was Obama’s oratory that triggered the hot-cold sensations that ...

Crude Ethics

A website aimed at design professionals had a piece this month about keeping your ethical character snow-white when asked to work for dubious clients. Star profile: a young fellow who ...
The Long View

The President’s Schedule

Dec. 13, 2013 (All times approximate.) 6:30 a.m. President and Mrs. Gingrich wake to soothing white-noise generator. Closed Press. 7:00 a.m. President and Mrs. Gingrich attempt “Downward Facing Dog” yoga pose. Pool Spray ...
Politics & Policy


JANUARY Why comes the winter with its bitter winds, its drifts of snow and ice that run too deep, as though the Earth the summer’s warmth rescinds and kills the rose we tried past ...
Happy Warrior

The Mutant Present

Flipping channels in my hotel room the other night, I caught ten minutes of Hitchcock’s North by Northwest, a film I like enormously. It’s an “old” movie, from the Fifties, ...

Most Popular


Understanding the Mind of Modern Atheists

‘Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will not pass away” (Matthew 24:35). Anthony DeStefano uses this Bible quote toward the end of his new book Inside the Atheist Mind: Unmasking the Religion of Those Who Say There Is No God, pointing to the resiliency and truth of Christianity. “You can hide it, ... Read More
Economy & Business

How the Constitution Limits State Taxes

Must a company have a physical presence in a state for that state to require it to collect taxes? The Supreme Court is considering that question, which has grown more important as online sales have taken off. The Competitive Enterprise Institute has submitted an excellent brief arguing that the answer is yes, at ... Read More

Off the Shelf: Suicide of the West

Editor’s Note: Every week, Michael Brendan Dougherty writes an “Off the Shelf” column sharing casual observations on the books he's reading and the passing scene. Before social media, Jonah Goldberg would respond to obstreperous emails from a much younger version of me with a characteristically light ... Read More

The Scholarship/Activism Balance — A Rejoinder

The Martin Center recently published an article by sociology professor Fabio Rojas, in which he argued that professors should maintain the right balance between their teaching and scholarship on the one hand, and activism on the other. In today's article, the Center's Jay Schalin pushes back somewhat. Schalin ... Read More