Magazine | April 30, 2012, Issue

Youth Movement

Josh Mandel takes on Sherrod Brown

Dayton, Ohio — The first Senate candidate Senator Marco Rubio (R., Fla.) endorsed this year was Ohio’s state treasurer, Josh Mandel. On the day of his endorsement, Rubio explained to Fox News why he favored Mandel over his Democratic colleague, Senator Sherrod Brown. “We need . . . to tackle some of these issues like saving Medicare and Social Security,” he said. “We will not do that with the current bunch that is in charge right now. We will need to make some changes.”

A Senator Mandel would be quite the change. The 34-year-old, fresh-faced Republican is 25 years younger than the 59-year-old incumbent, who — as Mandel likes to remind voters — first ran for Ohio state representative in 1974, when Richard Nixon was president. The conservative Mandel also makes for a strong ideological contrast to Brown, whom National Journal ranked the fifth-most-liberal member of the Senate.

Mandel, profiled in these pages by John J. Miller (“Buckeye for Promotion,” December 19, 2011), is a rising star in the GOP. Raised in Beachwood, a suburb of Cleveland, he played quarterback for his high-school football team. He majored in communications at Ohio State University, where he served two terms as student-government president and enlisted in the Marine Corps Reserve. He went on to receive a law degree from Case Western Reserve University.

During his eight years in the Reserve, Mandel served two tours in Iraq as an intelligence specialist. The experience gave him “a heightened sense of personal responsibility,” he tells National Review. For his appreciation of freedom, he credits his grandparents, one of whom was imprisoned in Auschwitz while another served in the Army Air Corps during World War II. Mandel also credits his law professor Arthur Austin, who “under the umbrella of teaching contracts, really advocated for the free-enterprise system” — and found a receptive pupil.

Mandel’s legislative career bears the marks of these influences. In 2003, he won a seat on the city council of Lyndhurst, Ohio, where he engineered the first property-tax cut in local history. In 2006, he won a seat in Ohio’s state legislature and caused a stir when he proposed a bill to divest the state’s pension funds from companies that did business with Iran. After winning reelection in 2008, he successfully ran for state treasurer in 2010. In that office, he cut over $1.2 million from the state budget. He is pro-life and pro–traditional marriage.

In the fickle suburbs of Cleveland and Cincinnati, however, ideological consistency counts for little. Instead, Mandel is emphasizing the economy — and his opponent’s fumbling attempts to revive it. From 2001 to 2011, the Buckeye State lost 345,600 jobs in manufacturing, pushing its unemployment rate to 10.6 percent in August 2009. In February, it stood at 7.6 percent, while Brown’s focus in Washington remained on liberal proposals, such as Obamacare and EPA greenhouse-gas regulations, that would do little if anything to create jobs.

Mandel thinks jobs are the key issue, and that’s evident in his campaign schedule. On this Monday morning, he takes a tour of Staub Manufacturing Solutions, a metal-fabrication shop in Dayton. In a gray warehouse populated by blue-polo-clad workers, owner Steve Staub shows Mandel his equipment — big machines with names such as the “Trumatic L 3060.” Under the dangling lights and stencil-letter signs, Mandel listens, with sympathetic nods of the head, as Staub recounts the obstacles his company has overcome. Manufacturing comes with large start-up costs; consider that the Trumatic L 3060 costs $850,000.

“It’s not an easy business anybody can jump into,” Staub says. In 2007, he had 34 employees, but in 2009, the recession shaved his work force to ten. Today, he employs 20 people, but he doesn’t consider the federal government’s policies responsible for his recovery. The feds need to “help us,” Staub argues, “not continually add regulations that are going to strangle us.” For instance, were he to have four 55-gallon drums of Windex on his grounds, he would be out of compliance with environmental regulations, according to which the cleaner is a toxic chemical.

In his first bid for the state legislature, Mandel earned a reputation for his sneaker-punishing work ethic. He knocked on 19,000 doors, raised $400,000, and won in a district where Democrats outnumber Republicans by two to one. Even at this early-morning campaign stop, Mandel operates at full speed: shaking everybody’s hand, chatting briefly with a reporter from the Dayton Daily News and a camera crew from the local station WHIO-TV, and receiving an endorsement from the tea-party group FreedomWorks, all before jumping in his Jeep for the next event.

#page#In front of a group of Staub’s associates who have assembled in the warehouse, Mandel gives his stump speech. With his hair closely cropped and his red tie taut, he looks fresh out of Sunday school. “I’m 34 years old for those of you wondering,” he says, to laughs. His voice brims with energy. He promises to eliminate the regulations that are hurting small businesses and preventing the extraction of natural gas from the Utica and Marcellus shale formations. “We trust families and small businesses more than faceless bureaucrats in Washington, D.C.,” he concludes, provoking applause.

Mandel will face a tough fight and a ruthless opponent in Brown. The Democrat’s campaign is trying to portray Mandel as a young man in too much of a hurry. Brown’s aides have dug up video of Mandel saying he would like to serve four years as treasurer and labeled it a broken promise. They’ve complained that Mandel has attended almost none of the Board of Deposit meetings, which the treasurer is supposed to chair. (The other two members of the board, the attorney general and the state auditor, usually don’t attend either; like Mandel, they send representatives.) They also have made hay of an unremarkable finding by the Dayton Daily News that Mandel hired inexperienced campaign staffers for key posts. (The problem for Mandel is he criticized his predecessor for a similar practice.)

On a car ride to West Chester, Mandel responds to these charges with a fusillade of points: “We’re running one of the most effective and efficient treasurer’s offices in America. While Standard & Poor’s downgraded the credit rating for the United States . . . we earned the highest rating we could earn — a AAA rating — for the $4 billion investment fund I manage. . . . We’ll take that and stack it up against Washington and Sherrod Brown any day of the week.”

Mandel can be brash, but he is also cautious. When asked what he thinks of Congressman Paul Ryan’s proposed budgets, Mandel responds, “I don’t have a position on any of the Ryan plans.” He promises to unveil his own proposals before Election Day. In interviews, he dodges questions about Brown’s proposal to levy tariffs on tires made in China, usually noting simply, “I believe in free markets.”

He’s completely frank, however, in his condemnations of the president’s foreign policy. “I can’t stand President Obama’s blame-America-first approach,” he says. “I wish he was as publicly angry about the U.S. servicemen who were killed in the wake of the Koran burnings [as] he was about the Afghanis that were killed in that unfortunate incident by the staff sergeant.”

He opposes the president’s timeline for withdrawal from Afghanistan: “We can’t stay there forever, but it needs to be on the timetables set by our military commanders, and they shouldn’t be public.” And he’s crystal clear on his views regarding that country’s eastern neighbor: “We should cut foreign aid to Pakistan. I don’t think American tax dollars should be sent to a country whose military academy is five minutes from where Osama bin Laden was living for many years.”

Mandel’s campaign believes he will win because of his biography and his grunt work. He’s raised $5.8 million so far, with $4.3 million in cash on hand — not too far behind Brown, who has raised $6.5 million, with $5.2 million in cash on hand. The campaign also contends that Mandel has crossover appeal. He cut his political teeth in Democrat-heavy Cuyahoga County, where he was the only statewide Republican executive candidate to win more than 40 percent of the vote in 2010. Hold your losses there under 100,000 votes, Republican Buckeyes believe, and success is assured.

There’s reason to believe them. In a recent poll by Rasmussen Reports, Mandel tied Brown with 43 percent of the vote. Other polls have shown Brown leading, but much of that gap is attributable to Mandel’s still-low name recognition across the state.

“In order to change Washington, we need to change the people we send there,” Mandel says in a summation of his campaign. And though he sounds similar to other Republicans, he sounds very different from the incumbent: He’s young, plucky, and conservative. It was enough to win him a vote of confidence from Florida’s junior senator. Come November, we’ll see whether it’s enough to win him the Buckeye State’s.

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

On Judicial Review

It’s a good thing that President Barack Obama was not writing his law-school exams when he attacked judicial review. The administration is reeling from the Supreme Court’s tough questioning of ...
Politics & Policy

Youth Movement

Dayton, Ohio — The first Senate candidate Senator Marco Rubio (R., Fla.) endorsed this year was Ohio’s state treasurer, Josh Mandel. On the day of his endorsement, Rubio explained to ...


Politics & Policy

Big &#%!ing Joker

An August 26, 2008, Politico story began: “During his first full day of solo campaigning, newly minted Democratic vice presidential candidate Joe Biden showed some of the flashes of the ...

Books, Arts & Manners


Politics & Policy


Fiery Defense In the April 2 issue’s “Week” section, you comment that the Chevy Volt had an “annoying habit of bursting into flames.” Two Volts did burst into flames, but both had ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐Okay, now can we see his Harvard Law transcript? ‐ Even before Rick Santorum dropped out of the primary, Mitt Romney, President Obama, and political journalists were all acting as though ...

Hunger Strike

I don’t mind Arby’s. It’ll do. The last time I ate there I thought, Hey, I’m not regretting this. Some red sauce, some white sauce, a bun that doesn’t taste ...
The Long View


TO: FROM: RE: Drink? Keith! Darling! I wish I could get together this week. Just totally crazy with everything. But quickly, before I forget, no, we don’t have any plan to do ...
Politics & Policy


  Patience of Dreams A dream arrives with the comforting aura of the mists of morning; a time without shadow or warnings, as I, as horseman, unbridle and release the animal into a broad ...
Happy Warrior

Middle-Class Mick

Midway through a Julie Burchill column in the Guardian bemoaning the Queen’s Diamond Jubilee, I was startled to learn the following: Although fewer than 10 percent of British children attend ...

Most Popular


The Gun-Control Debate Could Break America

Last night, the nation witnessed what looked a lot like an extended version of the famous “two minutes hate” from George Orwell’s novel 1984. During a CNN town hall on gun control, a furious crowd of Americans jeered at two conservatives, Marco Rubio and Dana Loesch, who stood in defense of the Second ... Read More
Law & the Courts

Obstruction Confusions

In his Lawfare critique of one of my several columns about the purported obstruction case against President Trump, Gabriel Schoenfeld loses me — as I suspect he will lose others — when he says of himself, “I do not think I am Trump-deranged.” Gabe graciously expresses fondness for me, and the feeling is ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Students’ Anti-Gun Views

Are children innocents or are they leaders? Are teenagers fully autonomous decision-makers, or are they lumps of mental clay, still being molded by unfolding brain development? The Left seems to have a particularly hard time deciding these days. Take, for example, the high-school students from Parkland, ... Read More
PC Culture

Kill Chic

We live in a society in which gratuitous violence is the trademark of video games, movies, and popular music. Kill this, shoot that in repugnant detail becomes a race to the visual and spoken bottom. We have gone from Sam Peckinpah’s realistic portrayal of violent death to a gory ritual of metal ripping ... Read More