Magazine | June 11, 2012, Issue

Diverse Like Me

Our Mexican writer reflects on the Cherokee Senate candidate

Once, not too long ago, when I was hiring writers for a television show, a network executive called me up.

“We’re really hoping you’ll keep diversity in mind when you make your choices,” he said. “It’s sort of company policy to hire as many diverse writers as possible.”

How a writer — or anyone — can be described as “diverse” is a mystery to me. But when someone says something I don’t understand, my general policy is to simply agree with it and move on. Asking for clarification, in my experience, always leads to one of two undesirable outcomes — either I end up even more baffled, or, worse, I end up knowing exactly what was meant. Not a great result either way.

So I agreed to the general goal — “Sure, sure, very important, very important” — and then ended up hiring the writers I wanted to hire. The conversation about diversity, as with almost every other aspect of contemporary liberalism, was an exercise in kabuki theater: The guy has to call me and say the word “diversity” a few times, I have to pretend to listen, everybody’s happy.

That was, as I said, a few years ago. Things have changed a bit since then. Everyone is a little hipper to the game.

Two months ago, when I was again hiring a staff of writers, I tried the old agree-and-move-on trick and was brought up short.

“We’re really committed to diversity hires, Rob,” the executive said. “In fact, we run a whole program for young diverse writers.”

“Sure, sure, very important, very important.”

“No, I mean, seriously. We’re sending over a list of writers who qualify as ‘diverse.’ We’d really like you to hire one of them.”

In the end, I ran out of money in the budget for writers. And if there’s one thing networks care about more than diversity, it’s money. But before I was allowed to shut down the exercise, I was also warned that many writers — sometimes through their agents — will claim to be “diverse,” but that when you get them in a room face to face, there’s less diversity there than you were expecting.

“We get a lot of people claiming to be half-Asians,” I was told. “And pretty much everybody is claiming to be part Hispanic.” But then, apparently, when they arrive at your office with roundish blue eyes sparkling and blond hair waving, it’s awfully hard to square with the “Caribbean-Asian” checkbox.

In other words, people lie about stuff in order to get a job.

Lying about your qualifications is a time-honored job-hunting tradition — which is why in the old days, in order to get a job as a secretary, you had to pass a typing test. And why, even now, Google administers a series of brain-teasers to folks who want to work there. The trouble is, since the single most important qualification a job-seeker can boast of, when going for a position in such frivolous and irrelevant institutions as movie studios, government bureaucracies, and major universities, is ethnic and racial background — diversity, in other words — applicants have to find an ethnicity they can claim without eliciting laughter.

#page#Now, speaking as someone who, if family lore is to be believed, has more than a hint of Tabasco in his background, I get the problem. Personally, I’m way too ruddy and freckly to pull off “Hispanic mix” in a racial-background questionnaire — I usually decline to fill these out, by the way — despite being able to back it up, should it come to that. But I am who I am, and there’s some Mexican in the family tree, and though good taste — and pink skin — have kept me from using it to my advantage, I’m rethinking that.

Elizabeth Warren, who is, if possible, even whiter than I am, is running against Scott Brown for the Massachusetts Senate seat. She’s also, according to her, about 1/32 Cherokee Indian, which is something she’s been dining out on for years. Listed in faculty directories as a minority, fulfilling diversity quotas, getting invited to lunches — her Native American heritage has been a pretty good career move. Even at 1/32 Cherokee — which by my shaky math means that one of her great-great-great-grandparents was a feather-wearer — she hits the right diversity notes. She wouldn’t pass muster with a television network’s HR-defined meaning of the word — they operate, you’ll recall, on the basis of a visual inspection — but then, universities are a lot looser about that stuff. A gal shows up with blond hair and blue eyes claiming to be Cherokee, and Harvard Law School says, “Me smoke-up peace pipe.”

(I can make jokes like that. I’m Hispanic.)

In fact, claiming Cherokee heritage is a pretty perfect way to go for an enterprising academic. In the first place, there is no spot more like an Indian reservation than a college campus, with its subsidized lifestyle, taxpayer support, separate-seeming nationhood, and heavy alcohol use. And more important, at a ratio of one part Cherokee to 31 parts Scot (or whatever), you’re getting a terrific diversity bang for a low-risk Anglo-Saxon buck. And as long as no one ever matches the name of Elizabeth Warren, Cherokee, with a photo of Elizabeth Warren, she’s all set.

But someone did. And now she’s in trouble. Because Massachusetts voters — who, remember, tend to vote pretty liberal — didn’t like the idea of an Obama-administration bureaucrat, a white-skinned Harvard Law professor, a person who by all measures and metrics is a powerful member of the ruling American establishment, claiming some kind of special protected status.

They don’t like the multiple — and feckless — explanations coming out of the Warren campaign. That she just wanted to make friends and get invited to “lunches.” That she’s from Oklahoma, where everybody is part Injun. That it didn’t count anyway. And when it was pointed out that it did count, at least to Harvard, that she’s a proud Cherokee with cookbook entries to prove it. None of that seemed plausible. All of it seemed laughable.

Put it this way: If Elizabeth Warren is Native American, then I’m Cantinflas.

(And I can make jokes like that.)

When liberalism collapses — and it will, won’t it? — it may not be because we conservatives out-argued it. It may not be because of the sum-total columns of our rational, reasoned dissent. We may not persuade a single lefty that we’re right.

What may happen — and what’s happening, I think, in Massachusetts — is that it will descend into farce. Liberalism may slip on its own banana peel. Let’s all stay out of the way when it does.

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

Canadian Crackdown

A considered and empathetic opposition to same-sex marriage has nothing to do with phobia or hatred, but that doesn’t stop Christians, conservatives, and anybody else who doesn’t take the fashionable line ...
Politics & Policy

Tea-Party Prequel

The three-plus years of the Obama administration have been something of a roller coaster for the Republican party and the broader conservative movement. On one hand there was Scott Brown’s ...
Politics & Policy

Getting Irreligion

There was a time when American politicians could condemn godless heathens almost anywhere in the country and expect nothing but lusty applause. Now, however, there are large swathes of the ...
Politics & Policy

Diverse Like Me

Once, not too long ago, when I was hiring writers for a television show, a network executive called me up. “We’re really hoping you’ll keep diversity in mind when you make ...


Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

The Odd Couple

Both the subtitle of Richard Aldous’s book — “The Difficult Relationship” — and its foreword proclaim it to be an exercise in historical revisionism. Justifying this, he quotes Sir Nicholas ...
Politics & Policy

The Scholar

Bernard Lewis is far and away the single most influential commentator in the English language on the Muslim world past and present. In the course of a long lifetime, he ...
Politics & Policy

Running Deep

The problem awaiting any author seeking to define introversion is that, in essence, it is about not needing, and not particularly liking, people. This is a felony in America, so ...
Politics & Policy

Tame Tyrant

During the spring television season, my wife and I became strangely fascinated by the Manhattan real-estate agent Fredrik Eklund, who is featured prominently in Million Dollar Listing: New York, one ...
City Desk

In the Know

‘You are in the seat the cardinal sat in when we had dinner here.” We were three, expecting a fourth. The fourth would be a lady, so we had already ...


Politics & Policy


A Childish Question In “The Empty Playground and the Welfare State” (May 28), Ramesh Ponnuru proposes increasing the child tax credit. Much of the argument is compelling, but I found one ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ A prisoner took 40 percent of the vote in a Democratic presidential primary against Obama. We see the makings of a John Edwards comeback. ‐ President Obama has renewed his ...

To Boldly Politick

It’s one thing to read that scientists are working on teleportation devices. It’s quite another to learn they not only got one to work but beamed something 143 kilometers between ...
Politics & Policy


Time and the River Time and the river have always their place in life as the essential things never to be brought home in triumph or in sorrow; never lost as they can never be possessed; and if ...
Happy Warrior

Eutopia, Limited

As the advanced social-democratic Big Government state sinks under a multi-trillion-dollar debt avalanche, the conventional wisdom remains all too conventional, and disinclined even to mount an argument. So much “progressive” ...

Most Popular


Is Tribalism Really on the Rise? Meh.

‘By now we all understand that America is in the grip of political tribalism,” Yale professor Amy Chua wrote in the February 22 New York Times. “We lament and condemn this phenomenon even as we voraciously engage in it.” It’s a familiar refrain, is it not? Chua’s widely discussed new book on the ... Read More
Economy & Business

Two Conservative Causes, in Conflict

Conservatives have argued for decades that the capital-gains tax should be indexed to inflation. When George H. W. Bush was president, some conservatives argued that he could interpret the tax laws in a way that let him adopt this policy without a vote of Congress. Now that Larry Kudlow is director of the ... Read More

If Amy Wax Is Wrong, Let’s See the Data

Regarding the kerfuffle Jason Richwine addressed here earlier, the economist Glenn Loury has posted an impassioned plea to his Facebook page. Loury, you may recall, hosts the video blog where Wax made her controversial claim that black students at Penn Law School rarely graduate in the top half of the ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Nazis, Rap Songs, and McDougals

In 1991, Edwin Edwards, a Democrat, and David Duke, a Republican, ran for governor of Louisiana. There was a memorable bumper sticker: “Vote for the Crook, Not the Nazi.” The crook, in fact, won -- beating the Nazi (and Klansman) by about 61 percent to 39 percent. I thought of this when contemplating ... Read More
Politics & Policy

San Francisco Bans Fur Sales

San Francisco has banned the sale of fur. From the CBS-SF story: San Francisco has become the first major U.S. city to ban the sale of fur clothing and products. Tuesday, the Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a measure that prohibits the sale of fur clothes, accessories, even souvenirs in stores and ... Read More