Magazine | October 1, 2012, Issue


On Recess Appointments

Ramesh Ponnuru’s “Obama vs. the Constitution” (September 10) is absolutely appropriate for consideration by intelligent voters come November 6. However, I believe he was imprecise in describing the recess-appointments power of the president.

Specifically, Mr. Ponnuru, in commenting on the four recess appointments that President Obama made on January 4, 2012, three to the National Labor Relations Board and one to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, cites the president’s power as arising “when the Senate is not in session to provide its advice about and consent to his nominations.” But that summary misses the mark when, as in the case of these four appointments, the positions were empty before the Senate went into recess.

The Constitution gives the president the “power to fill up all Vacancies that may happen during the Recess of the Senate” (emphasis added). The four vacancies in question did not happen during the recess; the positions were vacant before the Senate ever convened. The CFPB position, being new, had never been filled.

As I see the matter, a first order of business for (hopefully) a new Republican Senate in 2013 is a return to the original understanding of the recess-appointments power, so that these constant battles (games?) about whether the body is in recess can be made rare events, given the rarity itself of an already-filled position’s becoming vacant during what appears to be a recess of the Senate.

Ted Baumgardner

Winter Park, Fla.


Ramesh Ponnuru Replies: Michael Rappaport, a professor at the University of San Diego School of Law, has argued that the original meaning of the recess-appointment clause allows the president to fill only those vacancies that arise between Senate sessions. Under this interpretation, the president’s power is very limited, and almost all modern uses of it have been unconstitutional. I think Rappaport’s argument has real force. Even on the more expansive modern understanding, however, President Obama’s use of the power was an abuse. If Rappaport’s theory is correct, it is merely a further and worse abuse of the power.


A Dose of Free Speech

In “Scholars with Spine” (August 27), Jay Nordlinger mentions Princeton-in-Beijing, an intensive summer Mandarin course held in China’s capital. Nordlinger suggests that, after China stopped giving visas to Perry Link, a co-founder of the program, in retaliation for his translation and publication of documents relating to the Tiananmen Square massacre, Princeton might have relocated the course to Taiwan. Indeed it might have, and perhaps it should have. But there is a small consolation. I attended Princeton-in-Beijing in the early 2000s and can report that the course materials included a number of Chinese newspaper articles and editorials on politically sensitive issues. The program’s director, a Taiwanese man, said this was good for language-learning: Students were more likely to take an interest if the topics were controversial. It seemed clear, however, that another of his motives was to expose the Chinese instructors to criticisms of their government — the inevitable outcome, since students often dissented from Beijing-approved views. He also invited victims of oppression during the Cultural Revolution — for example, the son of a famous poet — to speak to the students and teachers about their memories of that time.

Situ Jie

Via e-mail

Members of the National Review editorial and operational teams are included under the umbrella “NR Staff.”

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

Risky Choice

Watching the Democratic convention in Charlotte, at least in the hours before the networks started covering it, one might have gotten the impression that the chief threat to the common ...


Politics & Policy

Obama’s Truth

More than any Democratic president since Franklin Roosevelt, Barack Obama in his writings and speeches has worked out an impressive interpretation of American history that culminates in modern liberalism. It ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

Out of the Gulag

North Korea’s continued existence is a blot on the consciences of the United States and other Free World nations. It is indeed “hell on earth,” as Melanie Kirkpatrick’s new book ...
Politics & Policy

Know the Terrain

Some 70 years ago, the Dutch-American geopolitical writer Nicholas Spykman observed that “geography is the most fundamental factor in foreign policy because it is the most permanent.” The physical setting ...


Politics & Policy


On Recess Appointments Ramesh Ponnuru’s “Obama vs. the Constitution” (September 10) is absolutely appropriate for consideration by intelligent voters come November 6. However, I believe he was imprecise in describing the ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ Reading the papers, it looks like Republicans are running the most lowdown, dishonest campaign since the last time they won. ‐ In his speech to the Democratic convention, President Obama ...

Political Science

The president of the United States can’t figure out an iPhone. Millions of Americans use iPhones every day, but when confronted with this elemental, intuitive device, he stabbed it with ...
The Long View


TO: Polling staff FROM: Stats department RE: New polling questions To All: As you know, it’s “silly season” in our business, and if there’s one thing we can count on, it’s that whatever poll ...
Politics & Policy


STAR BRIGHT Each soul is the last of its kind, the last of the Mohicans, the singular Tom Jones of the time, the everyman of fable, legend, and history. Whatever comes into the world, however changed by the ...

Most Popular

White House

Out of Order

A  question in the spirit of Donald Trump’s tweets this morning might be: Who’s trying harder to crash U.S. markets, the president of the United States or the president of China? After Federal Reserve chairman Jerome Powell didn’t forecast the loosening of monetary policy that Trump craves and China ... Read More
Film & TV

Netflix Debuts Its Obama Manifesto

This week’s widespread media blitz heralding Netflix’s broadcast of its first Obama-endorsed presentation, American Factory, was more than synchronicity. It felt as though U.S. publicists and journalists collectively exhaled their relief at finally regaining the bully pulpit. Reviews of American Factory, a ... Read More
Politics & Policy

Capital versus Tucker Carlson

Advertisers do not advertise on Tucker Carlson’s show to endorse the views of Tucker Carlson. They advertise on his show for the same reason they advertise elsewhere: a captive audience — in Tucker’s case, the second-largest one in cable news — might spare thirty seconds of attention that will, they hope, ... Read More
Natural Law

Are Your Sexual Preferences Transphobic?

Last year, a study exploring “transgender exclusion from the world of dating” was published in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships. Of nearly 1,000 participants, the overwhelming majority, 87.5 percent, irrespective of their sexual preference, said they would not consider dating a trans person, ... Read More