Magazine | November 12, 2012, Issue

We the People

You never get the debate performance you want, do you? A young man at a town-hall meeting stammers out a plaintive bleat about poor job prospects for college grads, and you know the candidates will screw off the cap of the bottomless Jug of Empathy and pour it on like syrup over a stack of Eggos. What you want is something blunt and quick: Toss the kid an M-1 rifle and shout, “Soldier up, egghead. Uncle Sam’s always hiring. Next!”

But no. The undecideds must be courted and flattered, their indecision held up as a badge of intellectual rectitude, even though they’re like people in a troubled airplane looking at the oxygen masks hanging down and thinking, “Now what the heck are those for?” Enough! Abolish the town halls. Even though the questions are supposedly balanced, somehow it always works out like this:

Question for Romney: “I’m a gay pregnant Iraq War–veteran teacher who can’t get insurance because I have Münchausen syndrome. Why do you hate me?” Afterwards, in the interest of balance, the moderator gives the president two minutes to explain why Mitt Romney hates the questioner.

Question for Obama: “I have a son with leprosy. We were thinking of lowering him through a hole in the roof of the Oval Office so you could lay your hands on him. Does noon tomorrow work for you?” The moderator steps in to fact-check: “Mr. President, just to clarify, you’ll have to cut a hole in the roof, is that not correct?”

Here’s an idea: Don’t screen the questions. Let America see the true face of the Undecided Voter. Let them meet some guy with a white beard and 25 political buttons on his suspenders and a straw boater: “My name is Treefrog Holistic, and I’m a laid-off unemployment counselor. I voted for Obama because he had more vowels in his name, but now I’m wondering which candidate can convince McDonald’s to have that Shamrock Shake all year, instead of just around St. Patrick’s Day. They are delicious.”

The candidate responds: “Thank you for coming. That’s an important question, and thank you for letting me answer it here in this hall, and thanks to the people who built this hall for letting me come here tonight, and also for the use of the sidewalk to get in, which is not technically part of the hall but, I believe, a very important part of it. Now. We’ve been struggling with unemployment for far too long, and we need to ask ourselves what needs to be done to move forward in a positive direction, either up or north, that’s something the Congress and my administration will work on, but the real question is whether year-round Shamrock Shakes would increase the decrease in unemployment overall, or provide a quick fix. But let me be clear: Making Shamrock Shakes is the kind of green job that will put us ahead in the 21st century.”

#page#The only sensible response: “Really? That’s your question? Please stay home on Election Day. They’re running a SpongeBob marathon on cable. Look into it.”

Could the debates be improved? Yes. First: Replace the moderator with a dressmaker’s dummy that fires Taser darts at anyone talking after four minutes. That would let them mix it up, but would keep them focused. Second: Each candidate gets one chance to drop a Cone of Silence over his opponent, so he can finish his point. (Drawback: Both of them would save it for the other’s closing statement.)

Third: Base all the questions on the campaign ads. Most of the Democratic ads have been designed to prove how Mitt Romney wants to harvest Grandma’s organs so his rich friends can ride around the Cayman Islands on gold-plated rickshaws, caning orphans for sport. The president would’ve been required to trot out the $5 trillion–tax cut shibboleth, and cited an economist who believes Romney’s plan would require the transmutation of lead into gold. Romney would have replied with specifics that show the president’s ads are a steaming heap of ordure sprinkled with the spent casings of class warfare.

Of course, class warfare works, with some. Half the country apparently believes national greatness is defined by the number of people who get signed up for food stamps while having an abortion on a light-rail train. To them, President Obama is totally awesome because he has organized a bucket brigade from the Free Money Geyser that makes sure teachers have free phones and birth control.

And hair weaves! Twitter was ablaze for a day when some excitable citizens heard rumors: Mitt Romney wanted to ban hair weaves, because of China or something, and he wanted to ban the dollar menu at McDonald’s. It fit the mindset of the mindless: Decades of accumulated interaction with the welfare state has taught them that government’s power is absolute and arbitrary, so naturally the president could order crew cuts with a stroke of the autopen. Never mind that big-city liberal busybodies overregulate hair-weave parlors to extract juicy license fees; never mind that big-city liberal scolds are heck-bent on stamping out the dollar menu because it keeps people from chewing a head of lettuce for supper.

If you think that Mitt Romney threatens your hair or your hamburger, nothing in the debates will help. No election will change your mind. No recovery that follows from an application of fiscal restraint will penetrate your adamantine brainpan. These are the people who scoff at Romney’s desire to put people back to work.

Work? For what? The same stuff we get now for free? What kind of deal is that?

– Mr. Lileks blogs at

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

Let the Bell Toll

There’s a kind of catholicism among journalists. We’re as susceptible as anyone to petty jealousies and hatreds of colleagues, but at the same time, we denizens of the print realm ...
Politics & Policy

The Fire Next Time

Will it be impossible to prevent a reelected President Obama from transforming America into something resembling a European welfare state? Or will citizens rise to decisive action in defense of ...
Politics & Policy

Mitt and Marriage

Mitt Romney isn’t exactly the dream candidate of social conservatives. Though no one doubts that the former Massachusetts governor is a devoted family man and a committed lifelong member of ...


Politics & Policy

Tax Talk

For much of the fall campaign, the major domestic-policy debate between the presidential candidates has concerned taxes. In that debate Obama has taken a position he probably does not believe, ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

Star System

Ever wonder why political pollsters ask us which candidate we would most like to have a beer with? Which one best understands “people like me”? Which one is like me? ...
Politics & Policy

Emotional Rescue

As a new-minted star in 1997, standing alongside Matt Damon and hoisting their screenwriting Oscar for Good Will Hunting, Ben Affleck seemed to embody Hollywood as we all wish it ...


Politics & Policy


Freedom from Government Education . . . I just read Kevin D. Williamson’s article on homeschoolers, “The Last Radicals” (October 15), and thought it perfectly articulated the way I feel about ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ How could President Obama not know that the Benghazi raid was a terrorist attack? He must read the New York Times. ‐ In the second and third debates, Mitt Romney ...
The Long View

Harvard University Memorandum

TO:         Prof. Barack Obama FROM:  Dean, Faculty of Arts & Sciences IN RE:    Fall Semester 2013 Student Evaluations Summary Dear Professor Obama: Of course, everyone on the Government Department faculty is thrilled to have ...

We the People

You never get the debate performance you want, do you? A young man at a town-hall meeting stammers out a plaintive bleat about poor job prospects for college grads, and ...
Politics & Policy


ROSES AND THORNS Our neighbor died as winter ended. Across the street from the rose bush, rich with blooms, is a new for-sale sign, and grass that needs cutting. His wife died almost ten years ...
Happy Warrior

The Court Predator

Jimmy Savile is entirely unknown to Americans. Which is as it should be. He was a British disc jockey and children’s-TV host, but, even by the debased standards of those ...

Most Popular

Economy & Business

Two Conservative Causes, in Conflict

Conservatives have argued for decades that the capital-gains tax should be indexed to inflation. When George H. W. Bush was president, some conservatives argued that he could interpret the tax laws in a way that let him adopt this policy without a vote of Congress. Now that Larry Kudlow is director of the ... Read More

If Amy Wax Is Wrong, Let’s See the Data

Regarding the kerfuffle Jason Richwine addressed here earlier, the economist Glenn Loury has posted an impassioned plea to his Facebook page. Loury, you may recall, hosts the video blog where Wax made her controversial claim that black students at Penn Law School rarely graduate in the top half of the ... Read More
Politics & Policy

San Francisco Bans Fur Sales

San Francisco has banned the sale of fur. From the CBS-SF story: San Francisco has become the first major U.S. city to ban the sale of fur clothing and products. Tuesday, the Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a measure that prohibits the sale of fur clothes, accessories, even souvenirs in stores and ... Read More

For the First Time in Weeks, Relief Sweeps over Austin

Making the click-through worthwhile: The Austin bomber is done in by one of his own devices; some new numbers suggest that a small but significant portion of Trump voters are tiring of the chaos and aren’t showing up to support other Republicans in 2018; and the mixed news for conservatives coming out of the ... Read More

The Baleful Effect of #MeToo on Campus

Remember the series of hurricanes that pounded the Caribbean last summer? Something like that has been occurring on college campuses, as they're hit by one destructive mania after another: diversity, Title IX, anti-speech protests. Now it's the #MeToo Movement. In this Martin Center article, British academic ... Read More
Politics & Policy

A Time for Choosing

This year’s Conservative Political Action Conference was controversial. Invitations to European nationalist populists such as Nigel Farage and Marion Maréchal-Le Pen (the niece of Marine Le Pen) caused many longtime conservatives to question whether they still belong to the conservative movement. Vocal critics ... Read More