Magazine | December 17, 2012, Issue

A Hidden-Hand President

A review of Lincoln

A confession: When I saw the trailer for Steven Spielberg’s Lincoln, it filled me with a creeping dread. There is a flavor of historical schmaltz that only Spielberg can brew up: Sometimes he does so in small doses, as in the sentimentalized codas attached to otherwise fine films such as Saving Private Ryan and Schindler’s List, but sometimes he makes a batch large enough to drown an entire movie, and the result is a pious disappointment such as Amistad or a corny tearjerker such as last year’s War Horse.

In trailer form, Lincoln looked like it might be Amistad II: Judgment Day. The slo-mo battlefield scenes, the backlit shots of Honest Abe, the swelling chords, the bewigged men in darkened rooms arguing about equality, the Gettysburg Address voiceover — with such ingredients, how could Spielberg resist the tug of sentiment, the pull of piety, the urge to carve a straightforward morality play through history’s cunning passages?

As it turns out, he couldn’t resist completely, but in the course of Lincoln he resists enough to make the film succeed. The story lumbers, but it also breathes; the American past is sometimes a picture book of lessons for the present, but just as often it feels like a lived reality in its own right. The dialogue, courtesy of Angels in America author Tony Kushner, includes some of the intellectualized, pleased-with-itself bushwah that Kushner too often features in his plays, but mostly the script strikes the right balance between the plainspoken, the rhetorical, and the kind of half-imaginary 19th-century slanginess that David Milch perfected in Deadwood. The treacle and hagiography is mostly confined to the beginning and the end: Shave off the first and last five minutes, and you’ve shaved off the worst of Spielberg’s lapses into schmaltz.

Oh, and Daniel Day-Lewis is remarkable as the Great Emancipator. That was predictable enough, since Day-Lewis’s being remarkable — especially in a role that requires him to inhabit some figure out of the American past — is one of the few things that a filmgoer can consistently expect in a world of flux and change. But the trick with his acting is that you don’t know exactly how he’ll decide to dazzle us, and here the unexpected (though also the historically accurate) thing is how soft and high and gentle he makes Lincoln’s speaking voice, and then how perfectly that voice turns out to fit the unusual provincial who emerged to save our republic.

Gentle, prodding, rueful, performative, deceptive, Day-Lewis’s Lincoln is a persuader in a sea of congressional bombast, a front-porch talker in a city of would-be Roman orators, an autodidact shrewd enough to either outsmart or seduce all the politicians who think themselves his better. This is not a performance intended to throw open the mysteries of the inner man: The Lincoln of intimate life is mostly the same Lincoln we see interacting with his cabinet, his generals, the Congress, and the voters, and we’re meant to see the unhappiness of his personal relationships (with Sally Field as Mary Todd, and Joseph Gordon-Levitt as his eager-to-join-the-army son) as evidence that there’s an essential hiddenness required of great politicians that makes them difficult and disappointing in domestic life. And the nature of political greatness is what Day-Lewis is ultimately out to show us — what America saw in Lincoln, and what he was able to accomplish for us with those gifts.

#page#It helps that Spielberg and Kushner have chosen the time frame for their story very cleverly. Lincoln is set in the waning days of the war, between Atlanta’s fall and Lee’s surrender, and its subject is the legislative battle over the 13th Amendment, which the president pushed through a reluctant House of Representatives in January 1865, winning over just enough Democratic votes to make the end of slavery look modestly bipartisan.

This setting has two virtues. First, it foregrounds the gritty, impious business of legislating, balancing the Spielbergian tendency toward mythmaking with the more Machiavellian pleasures of horse-trading and vote-buying (mostly accomplished by two seasoned fixers, played with a twinkle by James Spader and John Hawkes).

Second, it takes us to a moment in the conflict when the politics were messy but the moral stakes were relatively uncomplicated. Whereas earlier in the war there was a real tension between abolitionism and Lincoln’s quest to preserve the union, by 1865 the inevitability of military victory more than justified postponing peace negotiations — the hardest decision we see the movie’s Lincoln make — until slavery’s extinction was assured. And then the cinematic story ends, with Lincoln’s life, before the realities of occupation and southern resistance intruded on the joy of legal emancipation.

More complicated realities are acknowledged, or at least hinted at — in foreshadowings of Reconstruction’s morass, in reminders that the more abolition-minded Republicans had good reasons to distrust the Lincoln White House, and in references to Lincoln’s many extra-constitutional wartime moves.

But mostly the filmmakers have pulled off an impressive artistic trick. They’ve made a film that’s being hailed for its clear-eyed and realistic portrait of democracy in action, using a chronological frame that makes us feel good by keeping a lot of darker and more compromised action just offstage.

It’s a trick, I suspect, that a master politician like Lincoln would respect. In art and politics alike, what you don’t reveal matters as much as what you do.

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

Wife and Soldier

Over the course of 40 years, Natalia Solzhenitsyn worked hand in hand with her husband, Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn. He died in 2008, at almost 90. Mrs. Solzhenitsyn continues to work. She ...


Politics & Policy

Against Empathy

Just before the election, the Washington Post fluttered about what it described as “Barack Obama’s empathy edge.” The equally hardboiled reporters at Psychology Today pondered: “Is Obama empathetic to a ...
Politics & Policy

Fighting for Words

In September, a rather crude video titled “Innocence of Muslims” provoked riots across the Muslim world, resulting in several deaths, many more injuries, and considerable property damage. Almost seven years ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

A Political Man

Thomas Jefferson is not in vogue. His Democratic descendants long ago abandoned his philosophy of limited government, Republicans rarely invoke him, and scholars tend to focus on the gulf between ...
Politics & Policy

The Final Roar

Very many Americans came to admire Winston Churchill through the first two volumes of William Manchester’s The Last Lion series, namely Visions of Glory (1983) and Alone (1988). They were ...
Politics & Policy

Why Caravaggio?

The announcement this July of the discovery of nearly 100 hitherto unidentified paintings by Caravaggio caused an international stir. The paintings, stored for centuries in a castle in Milan, where ...
City Desk

Stormy Monday

Old maps show what the city was like before man got to work on it. The islands on which it rests were ringed with coves, marshes, beaches, and the mouths ...


Happy Warrior

Who Are We?

In my last column, I argued that culture trumps politics, since when many readers have demanded to know what exactly I meant. Well, look no further than the very first ...
Politics & Policy


Winning the Middle Class I happened across “The Party’s Problem,” by Ramesh Ponnuru (December 3), while browsing online articles about the recent election. I am a lifelong liberal Democrat (68-year-old Caucasian male) ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ The First Scold must be secretly pleased about the demise of Hostess: Wicked Witch, the Ding-Dong is dead. ‐ As the fiscal cliff draws nearer, with its automatic tax increases ...

The Unisex Child

A Swedish toy catalogue has made a decision to go “gender neutral” for Christmas: boys with baby dolls, girls with guns. Possibly hermaphrodites with Magic 8 Balls that say only ...
Politics & Policy


LONG TRAIL You can spot the better hikers by the lightness of their steps, and how their packs seem much too small. They’ve learned they shouldn’t try to carry their whole lives upon their ...

Most Popular


My American Dream

This morning, at 8 a.m., I did something I’ve wanted to do for as long as I can remember: I became an American. I first applied for a visa in early 2011, and since then I have slowly worked my way through the system — first as a visa-holder, then as a permanent resident (green card), and, finally, as a ... Read More

The Gun-Control Debate Could Break America

Last night, the nation witnessed what looked a lot like an extended version of the famous “two minutes hate” from George Orwell’s novel 1984. During a CNN town hall on gun control, a furious crowd of Americans jeered at two conservatives, Marco Rubio and Dana Loesch, who stood in defense of the Second ... Read More

Billy Graham: Neither Prophet nor Theologian

Asked in 1972 if he believed in miracles, Billy Graham answered: Yes, Jesus performed some and there are many "miracles around us today, including television and airplanes." Graham was no theologian. Neither was he a prophet. Jesus said "a prophet hath no honor in his own country." Prophets take adversarial ... Read More