Magazine | February 25, 2013, Issue

Movie Crazy

A review of Silver Linings Playbook

Over a lifetime of moviegoing, I’ve seen more heartwarming flicks about the mentally ill than I care to admit, but until now I’m not sure I had ever seen one where the main character seemed like he might have been based on the director. Artistic motives are a complicated thing, and maybe something else attracted David O. Russell to the script for Silver Linings Playbook, which has become this year’s entrant in the Oscar bracket reserved for quirky, low-budget character studies. But the parallels between Russell’s Hollywood career and his protagonist’s trajectory are part of what makes the movie interesting.

Bradley Cooper plays Pat Solitano, a high-school teacher who catches his wife in flagrante delicto with a fellow pedagogue, beats his cuckolder savagely, breaks down, and lands in a mental institution. When he emerges eight months later, he has a shrink, a restraining order, medication, and a plan — the “look on the bright side” attitude that gives the movie its cumbersome title — to keep his rage in check. That optimism convinces him that he can save his marriage, and even though he isn’t allowed by law to see his wife, he hopes that he can win her admiration from afar by going back to basics — living with his parents in the Philadelphia suburbs, getting in shape by jogging every day, and reading his way through the classic novels that she teaches to her high-school students.

This story somewhat parallels Russell’s own career, which began with promising independent work, crested with 1999’s brilliant Gulf War movie Three Kings, and then was nearly undone by his own demons and anger problems. Russell was a nightmare on sets, screaming at cast and crew alike: He nearly had a fistfight with George Clooney, his star on Three Kings (Clooney called the filming “without exception, the worst experience of my life”), and after his vicious rant at Lily Tomlin during the making of 2004’s I Heart Huckabees hit YouTube, he didn’t release another movie for six years.

What saved him was a return to the simple, the straight-ahead, the conventional. Mark Wahlberg brought him on to direct 2010’s The Fighter, a feel-good, blue-collar, Boston-set boxing movie with no pretensions or indie fussiness, and it was a commercial and critical hit. Having succeeded once with squareness, Russell has gone back to the well: Silver Linings Playbook swaps Philadelphia for Boston, the Italians for the Irish, and a combination of dance and football fandom for boxing, but like The Fighter it’s an old-fashioned, upbeat, relatively predictable movie in which a white ethnic guy from a wacky, sports-obsessed family triumphs over adversity, winning the love of the right woman along the way.

#page#The difference is that in Silver Linings the hero is actually unbalanced, which lends the early part of the movie a stronger crackle of unpredictability but makes its happy ending feel a little bit more forced. The mental instability isn’t confined to Cooper’s Pat; it predominates among the nominally sane as well. His father, played by Robert De Niro, is a part-time bookmaker whose gambling looks like an addiction and whose Philadelphia Eagles fandom is shot through with OCD. Pat’s best friend, Ronnie (John Ortiz), is barely holding it together as he tries to live up to his chilly wife’s expectations and his new baby’s demands. And his love interest, Tiffany, is a head case in her own right: Played by Jennifer Lawrence, the satin-cheeked star of The Hunger Games, she’s a cop’s widow who dealt with her husband’s death by sleeping with every man who would have her (and some women), and who falls into a deeper relationship with Pat (and persuades him to become her partner for a dance contest) only because he’s too obsessed with winning back his wife to respond to her sexual advances.

That’s a lot of madness or near-madness to spin into a happy ending, and the strain of getting there ultimately shows. Silver Linings intends to be a crowd pleaser, and in a barren period for romantic comedies it’s nice to see the movie-star chemistry between Cooper and Lawrence supplemented with strong supporting performances and Russell’s spiky, clever script. But the first act, in which craziness eclipses happiness, does its work too well: While I enjoyed the movie’s arc, I never quite believed that the characters’ personal problems could actually be conquered by the gimmicks that the script falls back on in the second and third acts.

The best scene in Silver Linings Playbook comes relatively early, when Pat and Tiffany have their first night out together, and their respective pathologies unite to create an epic, dishes-smashing, all-too-public disaster of a date. It’s a rawer and more authentic moment — and one that’s truer, alas, to the realities of mental illness — than the Hollywood business of bets and dance contests that ultimately brings and keeps the couple together. And its presence in this movie is a reminder that while squareness and conventionality may have saved David O. Russell from career oblivion, he knows more about darkness than his last two movies would suggest.

In This Issue

Articles

Politics & Policy

Coal Meets Markets

While Mitt Romney’s 2012 presidential campaign fades in the rear-view mirror, the issues he ran on — particularly, his charge that President Obama is engaged in an economically disastrous “war ...

Features

Politics & Policy

Amnesty Anew

On consecutive days in January, two immigration proposals were put forward. The first was by Senators Chuck Schumer and Marco Rubio, representing the Gang of Eight — Democrats Schumer (N.Y.), ...
Politics & Policy

States of Conservatism

Inauguration Day 2013 was a moment of jubilation for conservatives. After four years of lackluster economic growth and a series of personal and policy mistakes, the incumbent chief executive, a ...

Books, Arts & Manners

City Desk

Iron Men

I see my trainer, Shawn, three days a week, and one day he told me something that had happened the last time he had been at the new Barclays Center ...
Politics & Policy

It’s Not about Bigotry

‘What we have come to call the gay-marriage debate is not directly about homosexuality, but about marriage,” declare the authors of this timely polemic. Few advocates of same-sex marriage will ...
Politics & Policy

Movie Crazy

Over a lifetime of moviegoing, I’ve seen more heartwarming flicks about the mentally ill than I care to admit, but until now I’m not sure I had ever seen one ...

Sections

Happy Warrior

Ghost Cities

In a dispute between Hamas and Fatah, it’s tempting to take the old Kissinger line re the Iran–Iraq War: It’s a shame they can’t both lose. But, in fact, only ...
Politics & Policy

Letters

Keeping Up with the Trapps My six-year-old daughter and I both enjoyed your reprint of Aloïse Buckley Heath’s piece on trying to emulate the Trapp family’s Advent activities. I, too, have ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ Chinese hackers penetrated the New York Times system. Maybe they wanted to be Tom Friedman for a day. ‐ Who is that, clinging to his shotgun? It looks like President ...
Athwart

The Magic Bullet

Why does President Obama want to put weapons of war into the hands of criminals? What sort of craven, stone-hearted monster can be so beholden to the cackling goblins of ...
Politics & Policy

Poetry

SMOOTH AS A WHISPER The North Star, being the one around which the others appear to circulate, is the one by which we actually navigate, and have for millennia. A deep-seated awareness of thunder in the distance will not ...

Most Popular

White House

The Problem Isn’t Just the GOP, Mr. Comey

During a CNN town hall on Wednesday night, James Comey alleged that the Republican party allows President Trump to get away with making inappropriate statements without holding him accountable. “If the Republicans, if they just close their eyes and imagine Barack Obama waking up in the morning saying someone ... Read More
Law & the Courts

‘Judges for the #Resistance’

At Politico, I wrote today about the judiciary’s activism against Trump on immigration: There is a lawlessness rampant in the land, but it isn’t emanating from the Trump administration. The source is the federal judges who are making a mockery of their profession by twisting the law to block the Trump ... Read More
White House

Trump’s Friendships Are America’s Asset

The stale, clichéd conceptions of Donald Trump held by both Left and Right — a man either utterly useless or only rigidly, transactionally tolerable — conceal the fact that the president does possess redeeming talents that are uniquely his, and deserve praise on their own merit. One is personal friendliness ... Read More
U.S.

Columbia 1968: Another Untold Story

Fifty years ago this week, Columbia students riding the combined wave of the civil-rights and anti-war movements went on strike, occupied buildings across campus, and shut the university down. As you revisit that episode of the larger drama that was the annus horribilis 1968, bear in mind that the past isn’t ... Read More
Culture

Only the Strident Survive

‘I am not prone to anxiety,” historian Niall Ferguson wrote in the Times of London on April 22. “Last week, however, for the first time since I went through the emotional trauma of divorce, I experienced an uncontrollable panic attack.” The cause? “A few intemperate emails, inadvertently forwarded ... Read More