Magazine | March 24, 2014, Issue

Multiply and Be Fruitful

Last May, Harvard economic historian Niall Ferguson stepped on a cultural landmine. He joked that sainted liberal economist John Maynard Keynes supported deficit spending because he was gay. Spoken by an “effete” childless homosexual, Keynes’s famous bon mot “In the long run, we are all dead” takes on a special meaning, Ferguson mused. Why not live — and spend — for today?

As I wrote at the time, Ferguson’s mistake was to have missed the fact that the statute of limitations had expired on such observations, never mind that — unfair to Keynes or not — the thought had been utterly mainstream not long before. Conservative intellectual historian Gertrude Himmelfarb and left-wing economic journalist William Greider both speculated similarly. In his 1946 obituary of Keynes, no less than Joseph Schumpeter wrote that Keynes “was childless and his philosophy of life was essentially a short-run philosophy.”

But Schumpeter’s jab, to be fair, wasn’t aimed at homosexuality but at childlessness or, to be more accurate, what he called the “decline in philoprogenitivity” — the desire to have as many kids as God or nature will allow. This desire was deeply tied up in an “extra-rational” worldview of bourgeois morality that, according to Schumpeter, was responsible for the success of capitalism. Capitalism wasn’t born from the discovery of credit, surplus capital, the rule of law, underpants gnomes, or even private property — as various theorists, of varying quality, have surmised. What created capitalism was the sudden social acceptance of the nobility, or at least respectability, of the entrepreneur and the innovator. Starting in the 1700s, writes maverick Schumpeterian economist Deirdre McCloskey, “a great shift occurred in what Alexis de Tocqueville called ‘habits of the mind’ — or more exactly, habits of the lip. People stopped sneering at market innovativeness and other bourgeois virtues.” (The Oxford English Dictionary didn’t even allow a positive sense of “innovation” until well into the 19th century.)

Schumpeter noted that such men were driven by a romantic and heroic — not necessarily a rational — desire to build up, and provide for, a sprawling philoprogenitive home. “Economists have not always given due weight to this fact,” Schumpeter observed. “When we look more closely at their idea of the self-interest of entrepreneurs and capitalists we cannot fail to discover that the results it was supposed to produce are really not at all what one would expect from the rational self-interest of the detached individual or the childless couple who no longer look at the world through the windows of a family home.” The economists assumed Homo economicus was selfish Randian Man, when he was in fact romantic Family Man.

#page#But there’s an ironic catch. Perhaps Schumpeter’s most brilliant insight was to notice how the capitalistic Family Man tended to breed the anti-capitalistic Ungrateful Man (or ungrateful brat, if you prefer). The successful businessman’s children don’t become businessmen; they become lawyers, journalists, poets, social workers, writers, teachers, academics, activists, and the like — in short, the intellectuals. They can do this because education guarantees a nice minimum income. Risk-taking is where the real money is, but risk-taking is by definition risky. Lawyers move out of the house; failed inventors never leave the basement.

Intellectuals are the storytellers of civilization, and in capitalist societies the stories they tell are usually some variant of Balzac’s dictum that “behind every great fortune lies a great crime.” The richer the body politic gets, the more intellectuals it creates, much the same way the human body produces more and more of the bad kind of cholesterol. The result is the same. The arteries harden.

The New Class long ago achieved class-consciousness, recruiting the best and brightest even from the ranks of the poor and disadvantaged, teaching them to reject capitalism for a better way. The fruits of this effort have been well chronicled in these pages and elsewhere: a wave of rent-seeking, cronyism, and corporatism has been unleashed to the point where the greatest profits lie in the manufacture not of things but of laws. “Stakeholders” are rewarded for their subservience to the state by being permitted to circle the wagons against the innovative Huns. A new kind of noblesse oblige holds that we must in effect socialize health care in order to liberate workers from paying jobs so they can become, in the words of Nancy Pelosi, “poets.” And, as the family continues to melt away, the state acts in loco parentis for the Julias left behind.

President Obama is a throwback not so much to Marxism but to the old norm of sneering at innovativeness and the bourgeois virtues. As a politician, he has use for the language of bourgeois dignity but, as a member of the New Class, he has very little passion for it. The passion is reserved for sneering comments like “You didn’t build that.” He recalled his one stint in the private sector as working “behind enemy lines.” His wife is quite fond of boasting how she turned her back on the big money of the private sector, preferring the fairly large money of the public sector. (Again: The New Class takes care of its own.)

The capitalist revolution happened exactly once in human history. On that timeline it is very young indeed. And during its brief time on this earth it has alleviated more poverty than all the systems that ever came before it. The problem, as Friedrich Hayek noted, is that “capitalism depends upon values that it did not create and cannot replace.” The burning question is whether the culture outside of capitalism is capable of replenishing capitalism. If it’s not, then Keynes was right: Live for today, for in the long run we’re all dead.

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

We Few, We Very Few

Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel’s proposed Defense Department budget for fiscal year 2015, unveiled in late February, has set off a firestorm of outrage, and for good reason. Of course, in one ...
Politics & Policy

The Greatest

‘Even before Liston had become world heavyweight champion,” Muhammad Ali recounted in The Greatest: My Own Story, “I knew he was the fighter I would have to beat if I ...


Politics & Policy

Cross Purposes

The good news coming out of the just-concluded legislative battle in Arizona is that religious freedom remains what it has been there, undiminished by Governor Jan Brewer’s veto of a ...
Politics & Policy

Oil Flowing Freely

Mexico City — ‘Although the neoliberal dogma was already forgotten in other countries, including those that imposed it decades ago,” writes Jesús Ortega, editor of a prominent Mexican left-wing magazine, ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

The Master

Since its publication last October, Charles Krauthammer’s Things That Matter has been a runaway bestseller. As of this writing, it has spent 17 weeks on the New York Times bestseller ...
Politics & Policy

Message Movie

In this authoritative telling of the making of Sidney Lumet’s widely admired 1976 film Network, Dave Itzkoff leaves no stone unturned. Included are endlessly detailed accounts of every stage of ...
Politics & Policy

Brick House

Contemporary Hollywood is built around projects that studio types like to describe as “pre-sold,” meaning that they have titles and stories that prospective audiences instantly recognize, and brands that require ...


Politics & Policy


Seeger Singing If I were sure that more than 10 percent of National Review readers were fully aware of the range of contributions to music by Pete Seeger — his reputation ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ Maybe the president should visit Alaska: He can’t quite see a credible Russia policy from his house. ‐ Following the path of least resistance, Republicans have decided on a 2014 ...
The Long View

NSA Surveillance

Document Extract: Telephone intercepts, Oval Office   10:43 Begin Extract: POTUS: “Hello?” Unidentified Female Voice: “Yes? Hello? Who is this please?” POTUS: “May I speak to Mr. Putin, please?” UFV: “Oh, no, no. Mr. Putin is ...
Politics & Policy


LEGACY Let God persuade you What it’s going to mean, How thoroughly You will be off the scene; And hand it over now: The shade you chose For the walls, your coffee maker, Climbing rose. No archive and no Velvet ...
Happy Warrior

Multiply and Be Fruitful

Last May, Harvard economic historian Niall Ferguson stepped on a cultural landmine. He joked that sainted liberal economist John Maynard Keynes supported deficit spending because he was gay. Spoken by ...

Most Popular


Holy Week with Saint Paul

Just the other day, I ordered a replacement copy of The Passion of the Christ -- it can be so impactful for Holy Week meditation. In the years since its release, it’s become something of required Lenten viewing for me. But this year, there is a new movie to help with prayer, Paul, Apostle of Christ, released ... Read More

Heckuva Job, Paul and Mitch

As Thursday's editorial makes clear, the omnibus spending bill is a disgrace. That may be why about 40 percent of Republicans (and 40 percent of Democrats) voted against it. Apart from the absence of a DACA/Dream amnesty, the immigration portions represent a comprehensive victory by the anti-enforcement crowd. ... Read More
White House

Bill Clinton Redux

Stormy Daniels could have stepped right out of the 1990s. She would have been a natural in a Bill Clinton scandal, and, in fact, all the same means would have been used against her. Donald Trump’s tactics in these cases are almost indistinguishable from the Clintons’. The effort to shut down the ... Read More
Politics & Policy

California’s Pro-Nuclear Renegade

If California’s upcoming gubernatorial race gets decided solely by money, Michael Shellenberger doesn’t have a chance. The latest campaign filings show that Shellenberger, an environmentalist from Berkeley, has about $37,000 in cash on hand. The frontrunner in the June 5 California primary, Lieutenant ... Read More

Encouraging Signs in Iraq

Last year, relations between the Iraqi central government and the Kurds reached what was possibly an all-time low when the Kurds held an independence referendum in which 93 percent of voters opted to secede. The timing was no coincidence: Iraqi forces had retreated from Kurdish territory in 2014 as the Islamic ... Read More