Magazine | November 17, 2014, Issue

The Dangerous Era

Lies, Passions, and Illusions: The Democratic Imagination in the Twentieth Century, by François Furet (Chicago, 128 pp., $20)

By the time of his death in July 1997, at the age of 70 and just three months after being elected to the French Academy, François Furet had become one of the world’s leading historians of revolution. Much of his writing focused on the French Revolution, which he viewed, at least in its frenzied Jacobin period, as proto-totalitarian, foreshadowing the political fanaticisms of the 20th century. Furet’s careful scholarship, displayed in Interpreting the French Revolution (1981) and other books, countered the then-dominant Marxist reading of 1789 as an economically determined clash between a rising urban bourgeoisie and a decaying, agriculture-based ancien régime, marking the latest stage in an inexorable historical process that would culminate in a radiant classless society. In Furet’s Tocquevillian optic, political life wasn’t simply an automatic manifestation of the dynamics of class conflict, as the Marxists believed: Ideas and emotions mattered, and helped to shape history.

Furet presents the French Revolution as based on utopian hopes of a humanity fully democratized and equal, liberated from the past, and master of its destiny — hopes that no political regime could ever completely fulfill. His revisionist take on the revolution largely won the day in his native country, influencing a generation of historians — and made this former Marxist and lifelong man of the Left his share of left-wing enemies.

Furet, who taught at the School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences in Paris, the Committee on Social Thought at the University of Chicago, and other prestigious institutions, turned his attention to the 20th century in the last major work he published during his life. Released in 1995, The Passing of an Illusion: The Idea of Communism in the Twentieth Century is Furet’s masterpiece. A sober, nuanced obituary of Communism that seeks to understand its long-lived appeal, despite the murderousness and dysfunctionality of every regime that embodied it, Furet’s “interpretive essay,” ranging freely across intellectual milieus and conversant with seemingly everything ever written on Marxism, set off a Europe-wide controversy and sold hundreds of thousands of copies. The English translation, running to 600 pages, appeared in 1999, winning the author another round of critical attention.

For readers daunted by that book’s length and density of detail, the posthumously published Lies, Passions, and Illusions, ably translated by the author’s widow, Deborah Furet, provides a brisk overview of the earlier book’s key themes. Lies originated in a 1997 conversation between Furet and philosopher Paul Ricoeur on the 20th century’s totalitarian projects and what we can learn from them. Sadly, only Furet’s part of the dialogue is included; Ricoeur was working on his half when the historian died, and he didn’t want it to appear without his interlocutor’s approval. But editor Christophe Prochasson has smoothed Furet’s sections so that they read coherently, indeed elegantly. The book is a fitting coda to a remarkable intellectual career.

Communism’s power to seduce, Furet begins, was partly based on the mendacity of Marxist regimes and their followers. “Communism was certainly the object of a systematic lie,” he writes, “as testified to, for example, by the trips organized for naïve tourists and, more generally, by the extreme attention the Soviet regime and the Communist parties paid to propaganda and brainwashing.” Yet these lies were exposed quickly and often, almost from October 1917 on. They wouldn’t have remained so effective for so long without the emotional pull of the grand illusions that they served: that the Bolsheviks were the carriers of history’s true meaning, and that Communism in power would bring about true human emancipation. One can find little evidence that the Communists, right up to Mikhail Gorbachev, were ever purely cynical, even when they were lying; they continued to believe, or at least seemed to believe, in the illusions. Describing Communism as a secular religion isn’t an exaggeration.

#page#Still, once opened to even a little bit of liberty, “real” socialism “collapsed like a house of cards,” Furet observes. Marxist regimes proved ultimately incapable of competing with democratic-capitalist societies in achieving human happiness and unleashing productive might. But the Communist idea could survive, at least as an abstract hope for some kind of post-capitalist world, Furet argues, because it was born from the frustrations “inseparable” from liberal democracy. What were those frustrations? The French Revolution introduced a demand for human equality that free societies, with their room for divergent talents and fates, can never cease undermining. And liberal democracy — the “bourgeois city,” as Furet calls it in The Passing of an Illusion — is, for many, unsatisfying in its refusal to recognize any strong notion of the common good or shared transcendent values, basing itself instead on the sovereign individual and his rights. Division is our destiny, something many modern citizens find “intolerable,” says Furet. We’re “constantly searching for unity among ourselves,” though we can never find it. For millions of misguided people during the last century, Communism answered both of these problems.

Communism also exploited the deep current of anti-bourgeois sentiment that runs through the modern age — a kind of bourgeois self-loathing. This attitude “is as old as the bourgeoisie itself,” notes Furet. It has inspired artists and writers and thinkers for two centuries, and continues to do so today, as one can see in many Hollywood and other cultural productions. During the 20th century, it was as much a right-wing as a left-wing phenomenon, Furet reminds us, finding in fascist movements a second revolutionary critique of liberal democracy, this one aspiring not to human universality but to the thick communities of nation and blood. Anything but grubby commerce.

Unlike many on the left, Furet, following conservative German historian Ernst Nolte in this regard, was willing to explore the commonalities of Communist and fascist regimes — not only their anti-bourgeois ire but also their crushing will-to-power, totalizing desire to obliterate civil society, and centralized organization of political enthusiasm — while also recognizing what separated them. Furet was struck, too, by how the “political chemistry” that had fueled the French Revolution at the beginnings of modern democracy — an unstable mixture of claims for universal rights and an assertive sense of French national destiny — had “reconstituted its two poles” in the 20th century, “this time, like sparks across Europe, with Russia the country of internationalism and Germany the country of nationalism.”

Lies, Passions, and Illusions is filled with similarly arresting observations, though many of them aren’t fully developed, given the work’s brevity. One hopes that readers of this book will seek out Furet’s greater works, if they haven’t already encountered them. Furet’s last reflection, in this text and in his life, was a defense of the humble reality of our liberal democracies. “We must accept living in an amputated, damaged state,” he writes, “living in finitude and division.” The temptation to transcend such a condition — to seek “salvation in history” — has been ruinous time and again, but we’re unlikely to be done with it. Sometimes, we’re not satisfied with decent, even if in politics the alternatives tend to be a lot worse.

– Mr. Anderson is the editor of City Journal and the author of Democratic Capitalism and Its Discontents and other books.

In This Issue

Articles

Politics & Policy

Jurassic Cards

The business card seems to be surviving the speedy displacement and long death of print media, but nobody knows exactly why. Already a relic before the 20th century began, an ...
Politics & Policy

The Ike Theme Park

After a federal planning board rejected his unpopular design last spring, architect Frank Gehry downsized his proposed national memorial to Dwight D. Eisenhower in Washington, D.C. In October, both the ...

Features

Politics & Policy

Empty Integrity

The Oxford English Dictionary defines “integrity” in part as “soundness of moral principle; the character of uncorrupted virtue, esp. in relation to truth and fair dealing; uprightness, honesty, sincerity.” This ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

A Vanished Breed

‘Republican in name only,” “country-club Republican,” “establishment Republican”: These are the terms grassroots conservatives use to attack their moderate Republican opponents, whom they consider “squishes” and elitists — people who ...
Politics & Policy

Touched by the Divine

Someone who wants to understand why conservative Protestants don’t vacate the public square now that their kind of religion seems to have been so completely routed — can anyone think ...
Country Life

In a Dry Season

The mountains upstate are the tap, the fire hydrant, the wellhead for the city. Decades ago the thirsty megalopolis bought land to serve as gigantic offsite gutters and rain barrels. ...

Sections

Athwart

It’s Ineffable

If you wanted to change minds and win hearts about the issues that face women today, of course you’d take cute little girls who embody the sweet joy of innocence ...
The Long View

Memorandum

TO: New-Business Teams, Both Dem and Rep FROM: Media Team RE: Signing up new clients for Campaign Cycle 2016 Hi all . . . As we all digest the midterm results, we’ve got to ...
Politics & Policy

Poetry

MORE SPACE An anthropology of space? A Cape May Scenario: porches, hammocks, flags; lawns Without stone ornaments, small windows That are bow-shaped for the sea wind, Mail boxes with salt-air-withered signs, The pavements narrow enough for ...
Politics & Policy

Letters

The Inherent Danger of SWAT Teams Regarding Jay Nordlinger’s piece “A Job Like No Other” (September 22): I certainly sympathize with the police in general. It’s a necessary and difficult job. ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ President Obama’s credit card was refused. From force of habit, he shut down the Washington Monument. ‐ Two in Canada, one in Queens: The end of October was marked by ...

Most Popular

Elections

It’s Not Because She’s a Woman

In early October, Elizabeth Warren hit her stride. Her stock in the Democratic primary had been climbing steadily since midsummer, and as Joe Biden continued to lag, the Massachusetts senator became the first presidential hopeful to overtake him as front-runner in the RealClearPolitics polling average. She’s ... Read More
Elections

It’s Not Because She’s a Woman

In early October, Elizabeth Warren hit her stride. Her stock in the Democratic primary had been climbing steadily since midsummer, and as Joe Biden continued to lag, the Massachusetts senator became the first presidential hopeful to overtake him as front-runner in the RealClearPolitics polling average. She’s ... Read More
Film & TV

Clint Eastwood’s Messy, Nuanced Triumph

After a pipe bomb exploded at a concert held to celebrate the 1996 Olympics in Atlanta’s Centennial Park, the FBI came to suspect that the security guard who discovered the device might have planted it to gain a reputation as a hero. The knotty story of that security guard, Richard Jewell, does not lend itself ... Read More
Film & TV

Clint Eastwood’s Messy, Nuanced Triumph

After a pipe bomb exploded at a concert held to celebrate the 1996 Olympics in Atlanta’s Centennial Park, the FBI came to suspect that the security guard who discovered the device might have planted it to gain a reputation as a hero. The knotty story of that security guard, Richard Jewell, does not lend itself ... Read More
Film & TV

A Feeble Fox News Attack at the Movies

Don’t hold your breath waiting for Oscar-winning talents to rip the lid off the scandal at NBC News, whose bosses still have suffered no repercussions for their part in the Harvey Weinstein matter and other sleazy deeds — but at least Hollywood has finally let us know how they feel about Fox News ... Read More
Film & TV

A Feeble Fox News Attack at the Movies

Don’t hold your breath waiting for Oscar-winning talents to rip the lid off the scandal at NBC News, whose bosses still have suffered no repercussions for their part in the Harvey Weinstein matter and other sleazy deeds — but at least Hollywood has finally let us know how they feel about Fox News ... Read More