Magazine | November 17, 2014, Issue

Overruled on Appeal

Robert Downey Jr. and Robert Duvall in The Judge (Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.)

When skills are neglected, they atrophy. When crafts are abandoned, it’s hard to pick them up again. When forms of art grow rare enough, people can simply forget how to re-create them.

These are all possible epitaphs for a movie that by rights I should be praising as a model for our adolescent-chasing, franchise-recycling, superhero-happy film industry. It’s a movie for adults, a drama about family, an intimate portrait of ordinary human life. It has as good a cast as any film you’ll see this year; it stars an actor who ought to be making more films like this instead of rotting away inside a superhero suit. I saw it, notwithstanding negative buzz, because I wanted to believe that a big-screen drama along these lines could work, entertain, succeed.

And . . . nope. The movie is The Judge, and it stars Robert Downey Jr. as Hank Palmer, a defense lawyer who’s rich and successful and as arrogant as Iron Man, who gets summoned back from the big city to his native Indiana sod by his mother’s death and his dad’s decline. That dad is played by Robert Duvall, and he’s the judge of the title: a small-town icon presiding over a private-fiefdom courtroom, a Great Santini–esque disciplinarian whose punitive spirit drove his middle son (Downey) to rebellion and exile, even as older and younger brothers (one a failed athlete, the other a mentally challenged sweetheart) remained under the old man’s thumb.

But the judge is aging, maybe ill, definitely subject to occasional mental lapses — and just as Downey’s Hank is about to shake the dust off and head back to his cheating wife and wise-child daughter in Chicago, the old man gets in a car accident, one that conveniently bumps off (literally) a recently released ex-con who had a run-in with the judge long years before. Before you can say “Atticus Finch,” the prodigal son is offering his services as defense counsel, and though the old man demurs crustily at first, you know that it won’t be long before our Hank gets his day in court, his chance to tangle with the hotshot prosecutor (Billy Bob Thornton as a character named, I kid you not, Dwight Dickham) who’s bent on convicting the judge in his very own courtroom.

This summary, overripe as it may sound, does not begin to do justice to the overstuffed quality of The Judge, which finds room for endless subplots, all (necessarily) underplotted. The older Palmer brother (Vincent D’Onofrio) lost his pitching career when Hank crashed their car and broke his arm, and his resentment is a slow-burning fuse that you keep expecting to reach the dynamite. (Spoiler: It doesn’t.) The local beauty whom Hank once romanced (Vera Farmiga) now runs the local diner and has resentments of her own — as well as secrets, notably the paternity of her lovely daughter (Leighton Meester). Hank’s impending divorce gets 1.5 scenes; his daughter’s introduction to small-time life comes and goes and is forgotten; about the younger brother’s Rain Man–ish antics with his video camera, the less said the better. And then of course there’s all the local color (the town is supposed to be a Mayberry, though its main street looks more like one of the richer towns on Metro-North), the courtroom posturing, and even a random tornado that whirls through so that Hank and his dad can yell at each other while branches are falling on their heads.

The whole movie feels like the work of a committee deep within some studio, staffed by men who have spent their entire careers making remakes of reboots of blockbusters from 20 years ago. Suddenly, they get a tossed-off query from their boss. “Hey, we used to make movies for grownups. How did those work?” And this is what they come up with — a movie that’s a simulacrum of an authentic human drama, with plotlines stolen from a dozen films and a script that feels like every line was copied.

And the thing of it is, Duvall is good enough that The Judge is almost still worth seeing. The rest of the cast, Downey unfortunately included, is pulled down by the material, but the judge is somehow real, lived-in, charismatic, and Duvall’s performance alone suffices to remind you why this kind of story — the kind with fathers and sons, and without special effects or psychopaths or superheroes — is still, after all, worth telling.

Now we just need to find somebody who remembers how to tell it.

In This Issue


Politics & Policy

Jurassic Cards

The business card seems to be surviving the speedy displacement and long death of print media, but nobody knows exactly why. Already a relic before the 20th century began, an ...
Politics & Policy

The Ike Theme Park

After a federal planning board rejected his unpopular design last spring, architect Frank Gehry downsized his proposed national memorial to Dwight D. Eisenhower in Washington, D.C. In October, both the ...


Politics & Policy

Empty Integrity

The Oxford English Dictionary defines “integrity” in part as “soundness of moral principle; the character of uncorrupted virtue, esp. in relation to truth and fair dealing; uprightness, honesty, sincerity.” This ...

Books, Arts & Manners

Politics & Policy

A Vanished Breed

‘Republican in name only,” “country-club Republican,” “establishment Republican”: These are the terms grassroots conservatives use to attack their moderate Republican opponents, whom they consider “squishes” and elitists — people who ...
Politics & Policy

Touched by the Divine

Someone who wants to understand why conservative Protestants don’t vacate the public square now that their kind of religion seems to have been so completely routed — can anyone think ...
Country Life

In a Dry Season

The mountains upstate are the tap, the fire hydrant, the wellhead for the city. Decades ago the thirsty megalopolis bought land to serve as gigantic offsite gutters and rain barrels. ...


Politics & Policy


The Inherent Danger of SWAT Teams Regarding Jay Nordlinger’s piece “A Job Like No Other” (September 22): I certainly sympathize with the police in general. It’s a necessary and difficult job. ...
Politics & Policy

The Week

‐ President Obama’s credit card was refused. From force of habit, he shut down the Washington Monument. ‐ Two in Canada, one in Queens: The end of October was marked by ...

It’s Ineffable

If you wanted to change minds and win hearts about the issues that face women today, of course you’d take cute little girls who embody the sweet joy of innocence ...
The Long View


TO: New-Business Teams, Both Dem and Rep FROM: Media Team RE: Signing up new clients for Campaign Cycle 2016 Hi all . . . As we all digest the midterm results, we’ve got to ...
Politics & Policy


MORE SPACE An anthropology of space? A Cape May Scenario: porches, hammocks, flags; lawns Without stone ornaments, small windows That are bow-shaped for the sea wind, Mail boxes with salt-air-withered signs, The pavements narrow enough for ...

Most Popular

Politics & Policy

ABC Chief Political Analyst: GOP Rep. Stefanik a ‘Perfect Example’ of the Failures of Electing Someone ‘Because They Are a Woman’

Matthew Dowd, chief political analyst for ABC News, suggested that Representative Elise Stefanik (R., N.Y.) was elected due to her gender after taking issue with Stefanik's line of questioning during the first public impeachment hearing on Wednesday. “Elise Stefanik is a perfect example of why just electing ... Read More
White House

Trump vs. the ‘Policy Community’

When it comes to Russia, I am with what Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Vindman calls the American “policy community.” Vindman, of course, is one of the House Democrats’ star impeachment witnesses. His haughtiness in proclaiming the policy community and his membership in it grates, throughout his 340-page ... Read More
Law & the Courts

DACA’s Day in Court

When President Obama unilaterally changed immigration policy after repeatedly and correctly insisting that he lacked the constitutional power to do it, he said that congressional inaction had forced his hand. In the case of his first major unilateral move — “Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals,” which ... Read More
White House

Impeachment and the Broken Truce

The contradiction at the center of American politics in Anno Domini 2019 is this: The ruling class does not rule. The impeachment dog-and-pony show in Washington this week is not about how Donald Trump has comported himself as president (grotesquely) any more than early convulsions were about refreshed ... Read More

A Preposterous Review

A   Georgetown University professor named Charles King has reviewed my new book The Case for Nationalism for Foreign Affairs, and his review is a train wreck. It is worth dwelling on, not only because the review contains most of the lines of attack against my book, but because it is extraordinarily shoddy and ... Read More